Dutch Harness Horse temperment?

I’ve recently been given the opportunity to evaluate some Arab Dutch Harness Horse crosses for their sport horse and carriage potential.

Have had horse number one in the barn for a week. She’s 7, broke to ride originally for saddleseat but couldn’t hold her own against the standard show she was back shelfed.

Just curious if this is the general temperment type for the Dutch horse. She’s a little bossy, fidgety, paws while in the ties unattended and VERY free with her hind legs. She bucks and kicks REALLY HIGH! while at liberty, at other horses, and has had some episodes on the long lines. It’s like she has moments of impatience. She also stress and boredom kicks in her stall. annoying…

Granted, I am having to retrain her way of going as she was cranked up for saddleseat but that portion of her schooling has come along very easily and fast. She just seems…fussy, persnickety, distracted without direction.

I’m obviously not so stupid as to lump a whole breed into a category by my first experience with one horse. I’m just curious is the Dutch Harness horse has any temperment reputations. I’m getting ready for DHH number two, a big moving macho gelding. Previous trainer says he is very strong and forward.

And believe me, we will being doing a holy ton of long lining and ground driving as well as desensitizing to stimulus on her body before she even is in the same barn with a carriage!

Any thoughts on this breed, guys?

I have 2 mares ArabxDHH that are 4. They were broke to ride as late 2 year olds. They were ridden lightly off and on as 3 year olds. They were broke to drive as late 3 year olds. The one I thought would be the easiest is the spookiest. The one I thought would be the most difficult is not neessarily. They are very immature…like 4 going on 2. I am working them lightly driving and just waiting for the maturity to come. Both are very kind, they just have moments of what I call Arab spaz attacks. They are both correct, pretty and great movers. Thankfully I have another horse to compete with until I get these two broke enough to compete. :slight_smile:

I met my first DHH in the mid '90’s. Fabulous chestnut gelding, that a young teenage girl bombed around on bareback with a halter. He would jump the moon for her. (And quite a few “very interesting” homemade backyard jumps too.) Ultra calm. A hard worker. It was a love story made in heaven. The horse that every young girl dreams for.

She was from a very poor family & they picked him up for under a grand as no one knew what a DHH was. He became her event horse. Luckily her best friend’s family carted them everywhere with their own eventing daughter.

I have seen a few other DHH’s & they were total opposites of the afore mentioned gelding. Which does not at all imply they were bad horses. Very fancy, high stepping carriage horses. A lot of impulsion. Professional animals deserving of professional handlers.

What I could say in generalities when dealing with Dutch Harness Horses is they are forward, like a Saddlebred or a Hackney, and people who aren’t used to that get intimidated by it, and also that they are bred to be show horses, they are bred to air up when they see something interesting, like other show breeds such as a Saddlebred or Hackney. “Enthusiasm” is one of the scored criteria on the KWPN Harness Horse IBOP test, it is defined as, “Showing happiness, eagerness and being forward.” They are much bigger, stronger horses than Saddlebreds or Hackneys, and some of them learn to use their physical size, as in general they are not stupid horses. I have found Dutch Harness horses, in general, to be very level headed with daily stable life.

Personally the kicking buisness sounds like Arab hijinx to me :wink: I say this half-jokingly, as in the Arabs and Half-Arabs I have known (many) there has been more than one that I would never hook to a vehicle, and I really can’t say that for the other breeds I have worked with (Saddlebred, Hackney Ponies and Dutch Harness Horses primarily, along with some Morgans and Friesians).

I’m not thinking that any of what is described as “being typical for a Dutch Harness Horse”.

Rather I’m thinking it’s typical of any horse or pony who isn’t being well managed and trained and which is perhaps a little hyper on too much food and too little to do.

My experience with them is that they’re relatively easy to train but can be a little stubborn and resistent… even intimidating if they think you’re not up to the job.

I am going to say don’t lump CROSSBREDS with DHH purebreds. We have a LOT of the Arab crosses around here, using DHH and Hackney as the other half. Going for that BIG action in the Halfbred Arab to show in the ring under saddle. What the Arab folks don’t seem to realize is that training, handling methods used on Saddleseat, English Pleasure style Arabs DOES NOT work on these Crossbreds!! There is a WHOLE LOT more horse with a different thinking brain that the little Arabs they are used to dealing with. You can’t just muscle these Crossbreds around like the little Arabs.

As mentioned the Crossbred size can intimidate the handers, along with the athletic ability they can display. You just DO NOT take out the trick devices commonly used, then try them on these Crossbred horses to SCARE them into doing what is desired. Doesn’t work.

So locally, if you look around there are usually some Crossbreds available that have “not worked out” at the Arab barns but are not going to be easy fixes for other handlers either. Not what I would want for driving animals with confused brains, over reactive.

Also locally, they are not doing these two crosses anymore. Breeders and Trainers can’t manage the upcoming Crossbreds, quit breeding them. Wasted time and money on horses they could not handle or train with their Arab methods. People getting hurt.

DHH Purebreds are a very different type horse than show Arabs, not that kind of mindset. Have different reactions to stimuli, need different training and handling methods. Forward scares a lot of folks and DHH ARE big movers, fast when asked!

We are seeing a LOT of peculiar DHH crossbreds, since most stallion owners will breed any mare with the stud fee. Saw a video on a DHH/Perch cross. Looked kindly, but weirdly built body on LONG legs, nothing special in movement. Morgan, Standardbred, are fairly common crosses locally with the Amish.

OPs Crossbred mare sounds like she might need less feed and more exercise as Thomas suggested. Does she get turnout at all? And even being a Crossbred, she might have an all-Arab brain, not a DHH thinker. Local Arab barns think that 40 minutes a day is a LOT of work for show horses. Mine are just getting warmed up by then.

[QUOTE=goodhors;4868085]
I am going to say don’t lump CROSSBREDS with DHH purebreds. [/QUOTE]

:eek: Well spotted Goodhors.

I never noticed we were talking about an arab cross here!

I went from the thread title.

Heck that’s a totally different kettle of fish and I take it all back!

From what is being described about the DHH on here makes me want one even more. :slight_smile:

I’m reminded of an extremely hard headed and bullish National Show Horse. Mentally one of the toughest horses I’ve come across. I like Arabs and I like Saddlebreds- I just don’t like them swirled together.

[QUOTE=katarine;4868426]
I’m reminded of an extremely hard headed and bullish National Show Horse. Mentally one of the toughest horses I’ve come across. I like Arabs and I like Saddlebreds- I just don’t like them swirled together.[/QUOTE]

So, what I hear…

Dutch harness -Hot (but not stupid), stubborn and resistant -with poor brakes unless trained very carefully. But very pretty and big movers (just about what you would expect from the major outcrossings they have added to the breed over the years and continuing to add). Gigantic hackney/saddlebred crosses, with a touch of warm blood for power and presence. As Goodhors said, not for the amateur driver.

and not my kind of horse…

But if you like a pretty, hot horse under carriage, and a splash of danger- they are that.

Then add a touch of crazy ass Arabs -WOW. That could be a deadly combo, if the wrong side of the genes sorted themselves out into a particular individual.

[QUOTE=Cielo Azure;4868505]
Then add a touch of crazy ass Arabs -WOW. That could be a deadly combo, if the wrong side of the genes sorted themselves out into a particular individual.[/QUOTE]

You forgot to add:
horses have been experimented on by trainers who got more than they bargained for and gave up.

For the big macho gelding whose previous trainer says is “very strong and forward” read… didn’t own a bit that would stop him, and now I have to repair my end wall.

:wink: sorry… that wasn’t productive advice, but I think we’ve seen it often enough that sometimes it’s worth a smile.

[QUOTE=SmartAlex;4868517]
For the big macho gelding whose previous trainer says is “very strong and forward” read… didn’t own a bit that would stop him, and now I have to repair my end wall. [/QUOTE]

LOL I have to remember this one when I am shopping for horses.:yes:

[QUOTE=Cielo Azure;4868505]
So, what I hear…

Dutch harness -Hot (but not stupid), stubborn and resistant -with poor brakes unless trained very carefully. But very pretty and big movers (just about what you would expect from the major outcrossings they have added to the breed over the years and continuing to add). Gigantic hackney/saddlebred crosses, with a touch of warm blood for power and presence. As Goodhors said, not for the amateur driver.

and not my kind of horse…

But if you like a pretty, hot horse under carriage, and a splash of danger- they are that.

Then add a touch of crazy ass Arabs -WOW. That could be a deadly combo, if the wrong side of the genes sorted themselves out into a particular individual.[/QUOTE]

This sounds like a totally different breed than i have seen…The Dutch horses I know are super, nice horses, and yes big and gorgeous. Hot, sometimes…dangerous? no. Maybe be the difference in crossbreds and purebred?? Or like in any breed has, a bad example…

[QUOTE=yellowpony;4870337]
This sounds like a totally different breed than i have seen…The Dutch horses I know are super, nice horses, and yes big and gorgeous. Hot, sometimes…dangerous? no. Maybe be the difference in crossbreds and purebred?? Or like in any breed has, a bad example…[/QUOTE]

I don’t think Cielo Azure has actually ever worked with DHH. Dangerous if you are timid and not a person who has been correctly taught how to work forward minded horses, as in how race bred Thoroughbred can be “dangerous” with the way some people handle and ride their horses. Personally I love the breed, I think they are a blast, like Jaguar XKR or Mercedes SLS, the whole package, power and style.

Thanks so much from those of you with DHH experience. I have to say, I kind of like this mare for a lot of reasons.

Some more background: She was bred embryo transfer by a very big name arab barn. She was one of five embryos and they felt, the least exciting of the five. Not pretty enough. She’s a dark liver chestnut with not a white hair on her and a fairly plain Jane face. Translation Boring. They breed specifically for the Saddleseat Division and she just kept getting bumped to the bottom of the training list. As far as a saddle seat horse goes, she is far from a super star. Unfortunately, the Arab DHH cross has flopped more than it hasn’t.

I have found that many of my collegues do go for gadgetry and gear when training a Saddle Seat horse. Very frustrating for me as so many horses are ruined due to the skipping of basic building blocks. So many are expected to go right for the finished frame from day one. No wonder Saddle Seat has such a terrible rep. Oh well…

I have only had her a week, worked her five days over 8. Only long lining now. She’s used to a draw rein long line with sidecheck in a bull pen only. I don’t think she’s been long lined outside a bull pen. I have her in a simple full cheek snaffle and a straight rein long line in the main arena. Just letting her get her body sorted out. Doing lots of spiraling in and out of the circle. I have dialed the training energy wayyyy down. The only time she even gets a sharp word is when she kicks up her heels. A firm turn to the outside rein and gruff “no”. She’s responding very well. She’s already calming out and listening to voice. She’s getting a whoa on her. She’s dropping down in the bridle and stretching over the back (although she has that really annoying habit of a draw reined horse where they grab the bit and yank the reins out long and low out of habitually demanding a release from the draw). Im primarily just getting her to trust that I’m going to take care of her, not chase her up. Also, want her to carry herself instead of expecting to be held up by the bridle. Yesterday, I popped the wood block drag on her at the end of the workout. It’s like you could see the wheels turning. All the sudden, she had a job to do, a problem to work through. After a moment of what’s that behind me, she settled and listened to my voice. Then she squatted down like the big mama that she is and just leaned into that breast collar and marched.

I think, due to her ability of getting her heels WAAAAYYYYY up over her head, she is one of the most athletic horses I have seen in a long time! I think she is Sport Horse DELUXE! Just so powerful off her hind quarters. I know, I know, there’s much more to her than that. But man, you guys should see how high this mare can buck!!! She isn’t as upright and necky as many of the DHH out there. Might be the Arab half that shrunk up her neck a bit. But the rest of her is built like a brick S*** house. Just as blocky and square and balanced top to bottom, front to back as she can be. She was worked fairly inconsistantly at the BNT barn due to being “boring” that she got a reputation and habit of bucking and back humping undersaddle. I think she just didn’t care for their whole process of saddle seat training. Plus, if she has the aptitude for it, she would be much better off going up the training pyramid to the final frame. Not starting out being crammed into it from day one!!

So I have had some fun with her. Going to go very slowly through the steps and see if she proves trustworthy to hitch. If not, no biggie, she can stay under saddle but I think her more the sport horse type than saddle seat.

Oh and yes, she’s totally a fat a$$. The other barn feeds very well plus she was out on grass daily. She is getting turnout here too but we have mostly dirt lots and control their hay consumption. She is on a major diet with only a good grass hay and a vit min low cal balancer. I also had her immediately reset and took quite a bit of lenght off the front feet. If she has natural action I can always grow out some toe to accentuate it but until she learns how to balance her whole body, hoof can go bye bye.

Training time? yes, looong work outs with plenty of mental breaks. I have the acreage and the time to take this horse out. That’s the beauty of not being an assembly line training facility.

Interesting to see such a smart horse and the weird habits she has developed already from her previous training. Bring her out to the crossties and she immediately starts to paw, fuss and flap her head. I am doing small and deliberate corrections along with waiting her out. I have time. You can stand there till you are calmed down. She jsut fuss and fidgets and fiddles getting tacked up. That will take some time but she’ll get it. After workout, totally chill on the ties. It’s all in her head to be anxious before a workout. I think she is a smart girl but she reminds me of a big horse who doesn’t realize how her size and power relates to the rest of the puny little world. Plus she’s been a little frustrated with the previous inconsistency of her training. She just doesn’t know what to expect.

I’ve only put her out with my BIG hard to ruffle ASB broodie in pasture. Until I trust her, I don’t want her inadvertantly beating up on my small fries. and of course as soon as she hit the farm, she went into season and keeps whizzing everywhere. Why do mares do that!!

With regards to the other DHH cross gelding, this one is at another big breeding barn. I think you all are spot on. He’s a little more than the trainer and breeder anticipated and they aren’t quite sure what to do with him. I haven’t tried him out yet but he has also been under saddle for a few years in the saddle seat division. Will be trying him out next week and possibly doing a trade for a broodie on him.

I’m looking forward to these challenges. I love figuring out these “throw aways” from the big farms. So many times, the answers to these horses are so obvious that it boggles me that the “big guys” can’t make these horses work out. You just have to be smarter than the horse! And NO SHORTCUTS!

I think one reason so many of my Arab training collegues are shying away from the Sport Horse carriage divisions is because you can’t fake a carriage horse! You have to take your time and put all the nuts and bolts into the horse.

I’m surprised that no one has mentioned Chester Weber’s team! It is primarily made up of Dutch Harness Horses. His horse Jamaica was USEF Horse of the Year.

I went to meet the six year old Harness Horse stallion my mare is bred to, she is also KWPN of the riding type. He hadn’t been worked in a month, just turned out and put in the equisier. We hooked him up and I drove him. He was calm, willing and a joy to drive. He has only been worked in a dressage frame, so no “show” training at all (thank goodness). He has perfect manners, is kind, quiet and very sweet. He is stabled next to and across from other stallions, there are geldings and mares in the barn as well. He is a wonderful example of what the temperament is supposed to be. I spent three days with him and he was consistently charming.

Jamaica is NOT a Dutch Harness Horse!

I just looked on Chester’s website and he doesn’t have a single “Dutch Harness Horse.” He has one French Trotter, one “International Heavy Warmblood” (whatever that is) and the rest are listed as Dutch Warmbloods.

[QUOTE=CDE Driver;4875901]
I’m surprised that no one has mentioned Chester Weber’s team! It is primarily made up of Dutch Harness Horses. His horse Jamaica was USEF Horse of the Year.[/QUOTE]

Jamaica was almost euthanized for behavioral issues prior to Chester Weber owning him and would have been, if he wasn’t bought by Mr. Weber (at the time, Jamaica was not a young horse). He didn’t settle down as a driving horse until he was in his teens -if I remember right.

So, yes. Jamaica is a perfect example of the type of horse many here have written about: flashy and not for the amateur. I have read in one article where Mr. Weber even remarks on Jamaica’s difficult temperament. Again, nothing wrong with that but DHHs are being marketed and sold as a suitable driving horse for the amateur driver. I am not sure that is completely ethical.

Even the Arab/DHH crosses are being marketed in this way. That kind of bothers me.
http://www.winsomestables.com/history.htm
“Easy Temperament” at the top of the page.
Note that a registry is being started for the DHH/Arab crosses -scroll to the bottom of the site.

Honestly, I would much rather drive a KWPN of the riding type…They generally seem more centered. But I am not a fan of the Hackney personality, nor the saddlebred for driving and yes, I have worked with them.

Most of Chester’s horses are KWPN (at least that is how they were listed this year at Live Oak) of the Tupgaard registry. So is there a difference between KWPN and Tupgaard KWPN? My girls are 1/2 Tupgaard KWPN which I assumed was the same as Dutch Harness Horse. ???

49’r, I’m confused too.

KWPN = What, exactly? I always thought it was “Dutch Warmblood” and that Dutch Harness Horses were a totally different breed.

Sorry to hijack the thread, but could someone please explain this to someone who has never delved into the mysteries of the European registries?

Thank you! :slight_smile: