Euthanasia and Guilt

I’ve had three horses euthanized.

Two were pretty clear-cut and, in fact, one actually died as the vet walked up with the syringe of anesthesia solution. He never did have much use for vets and their syringes and wanted the last word.

The third one was seven, had cervical stenosis from a combination of arthritis that had seriously worsened over a three-year period and unresolvable soundness issues, likely caused, or at least exacerbated, by the cervical arthritis. He was mildly neurologic on the scale (0.5-1 out of 5). I did what seemed to be reasonable to try to fix him and waited to see if it helped, but I pretty much saw the writing on the wall at least a month before we made the final decision. It would have taken a miracle at that point. I had amazing support from my vet (to whom I turned during the horses’ penultimate appointment and said, “is this the right decision?” bc I needed that one final piece of validation), trainers, barn friends, friends from previous barns, family. It was a horrible decision to make and a horrible day when we euthanized him and I felt awful for playing god, yet felt oddly at piece in a way afterwards.

1 Like

Please be kind to yourself OP, just as you were kind to your horse. Many years ago a psychologist told me that “guilt was a useless emotion.” You can’t change what happened other than to second guess your decisions. Hindsight is always 20/20 as is our belief that maybe we might have done something differently.

I have been in your shoes with a horse I owned for 18 years. She had serious arthritis that was helped by Previcox but eventually her knees were being seriously deformed by the arthritis. My vet suggested that we should put her down before something serious happened to her. I did not welcome his suggestion, but I also knew he was right. So one beautiful fall day I had the backhoe man come and the vet put her down. I suppose she could have lived longer, but it was clear that her life as a horse was degrading to the point where the end was going to be ugly. And she was too lovely a horse to deserve an ugly fate.

Giving a horse a good life is what matters. I think you did that OP.

2 Likes

I’m one of those odd (I guess) people who does not feel at all guilty when I euthanise an animal. I feel very fortunate that I can choose to have my equines euthanized when their health begins to decline or their quality of life begins to diminish. I feel like it’s part of my duty as a responsible horse owner to prevent their suffering. I’m a firm believer in “better a day too early than a day too late.” In fact, I’ll go even farther and say “better a month too early than a day too late” or a season too early - I’m not going to keep a horse over the winter when I know that he’s not going to handle it well.

In my opinion, the ones who need to feel guilty are those who prolong an animal’s misery because they refuse to euthanise an animal that is clearly on a downward spiral from which there is no recovery. I know someone who kept a horse alive several months after the point where the vet started recommending euthanasia and I know someone who let a horse die “naturally” because she just couldn’t bring herself to euthanise him. That poor horse had a very rough last few weeks. I don’t ever want to be that person.

3 Likes

OP, you did the right thing. Please don’t beat yourself up. It sounds like this was a well loved and cared for horse. I work in veterinary medicine and what I quoted above is one of the hardest things for me to watch.

1 Like

It’s totally normal to second guess your decision to euthanize, after it’s done. For several horses and dogs, I’ve had those “what if…?” thoughts. Given some time, I’m sure you’ll be able to look back and know you made the right decision at the time.

1 Like

There is a wonderful COTHism:
“Better a day too soon than a minute too late”

{{{HUGS}}} to you @Lovesahorse , you did your best.
The guilty What Ifs are normal - I’ve felt them for every single one of the names in my Sig & numerous cats, 1 dog and (God forgive me) my own DH.
It hurts us to do what’s right for those in our care, but in the end you will know you ended suffering & gave a peaceful end.

If it helps, can you post a pic of your boy?
My DH & his horse are in my Profile pic & avatar - both long gone, but still loved.
ETA:
Ooops - avatar cuts them off here are my boys:

https://imgur.com/a/I4Em9

3 Likes

I have never put down one of my own animals and not felt guilty, even if I know in my heart it was the right thing to do at the time. At one time I worked as a small animal vet tech, and participated in many euthanasias as part of the job. The animals I felt the worst for were the ones whose owners kept them alive because they just could not let them go, even if the animal was suffering tremendously.

About 10 years ago I was in a situation similar to yours where I did every thing possible until the money ran out. And even if I had more money, I don’t think we could have successfully resolved the horse’s issues. That situation drove home to me that I have financial limitations, and there are things I will and will not do when it comes to treatment.

As for comments like Callista’s, ignore them. She has not walked in your shoes! Just like with humans, we cannot fix everything with our horses. Sadly, death is always inevitable.

1 Like

I think you made the most compassionate decision you could

2 Likes

I think it is just in our nature to wonder if we could/ should have done more. There isn’t any animal I have euthanized where I haven’t felt the guilt and pain and wondering if maybe trying just 1 more thing would have made the difference.

After the initial pain fades and I see it more clearly, I can see I did make the wisest choice and the one in my beloved animals best interests.

2 Likes

((hugs)) laced with comfort and understanding ~

I’m sorry for your loss ~

1 Like

I had to euth my Lab back in 2011. I took him to the vet for nosebleeds- I’m talking floods, not drops. She examined him. and said “We can do this, and this, and this, you’ll spend a ton of money, and it won’t change a damn thing”. I looked at him, and he was done. He really wasn’t even my Forrest anymore. That guy had left a month earlier. My guilt is not doing it soon enough. I didn’t SEE. I didn’t WANT to see. Now, I look at that last picture I have of him and wonder how I did NOT see. It’s terrible, but I refuse to delete it. I NEVER want to do that to one of my animals again.

You did the right thing. {{{hugs}}}

3 Likes

I’m grateful the 2 horses and several dogs and cats I have had to euthanize over the years basically made the decision for me. OP you made the most difficult and yet most compassionate decision for your friend who’s health and happiness were declining. I hope that if I ever have to face quality of life issues with my animals I can be as strong as you. You made the right decision and I hope you can remember all the good years you had with your boy.

Be kind to yourself. You did as I would have. I’ve done the same for four horses, and four dogs over the years. Every one of them a hard and wrenching decision.

As said before many times on this forum… “Better a day too soon than a minute too late” I would extend the “day too soon” even further. For some animals the change of season is a hard time to be avoided. One’s financial resource is not limitless. So euthanasia rather than neglect or a meat buyer. You held yourself to the higher standard. You took the emotional pain of loss to spare your buddy the physical pain.

2 Likes

I think it’s a personal decision we all have to make…sending you hugs. You have no reason to feel guilty.

1 Like

I wish you would stop beating yourself up about it and consider that you might just made the right decision at the perfect time. I’ve been in a similar position, my horse had DSLD. He was only 20, I had him for 16 years. I always wondered if I euthanized to soon, if I could have done more to keep him happy and comfortable. But fact is that his bad days outweigh his good and being progressive, it probably was the right time. I didn’t wanted to wait until he was just miserable.
I’m so very sorry for your heart break. Hugs to you. It’s a tough spot to be in.

It’s human nature to doubt ourselves, to search and question for the one thing that will make everything better. I’ve been where you are very recently. Just reading your post made me revisit the long journey, the ups and downs to the inevitable end, and all the hope, doubts and finally the acceptance of what needed to be done. Please know in your heart that you did the best you could, and the reason you feel this way is because you loved this horse so much, you wish there was something else you could have done. Hugs to you. Saying good bye to a beloved family member is so hard, they truly do leave hoof prints on our hearts.

1 Like

((hugs))) to you, OP.
It is never easy to lose a good horse.
But you made the right decision. Better too early than too late.

I may be in your shoes soon, as I have a 20 yo OTTb mare who is getting less sound by the year. And when her bad days outnumber her good days, then I will call the vet to euth her, and I will be sad about it, since I bought her at the track when she was 4 and we’ve been through a lot together… but it will be for the best.

This. 110%

I put down the last 3 horses I owned. Two of them had Wobbler’s, so I didn’t feel badly since it can’t be fixed.

The icelandic was hard. He was too dangerous to ride due to a random bolting issue, so I spent a year trying to find him a babysitter home. He was 20, in perfect health, didn’t need shoes, wonderful ground manners, but I can’t afford 2 horses and keeping him would quitting riding for at least ten years, maybe forever due to my age. I felt horrible about putting him down, but it was better than sending him off to auction.

Thank you all for your kind words, and for sharing your stories. They have been a big help. <3

Malda, I agree that euthanasia is a kinder fate than sending an old and/or dangerous horse out into the world, where even young/sound/safe horses can end up in bad places. You did a brave thing. :yes: