I’ve had some really good feedback here–thanks everyone!
@JB the article about kidney diets was very interesting. I had wondered if a low protein diet was a good idea for cats, and the article addresses this issue. Apparently it’s somewhat controversial. But, I have to make the best decision I can based on the information available, and peer-reviewed studies support using a kidney diet. So for now that’s what I’ll do (and we’ll have to see if the cat agrees).
The IRIS information on staging was also useful. My vet did a basic CBC and chem panel but not SDMA, urinalysis, or blood pressure, and the diagnosis was made on the basis of the BUN and creatinine. My cat’s creatinine was 2.1 mg/dL, which according to the IRIS guidelines puts him in the stage 2 category. His potassium and phosphorus were well within the reference ranges.
@cardinale, thanks for the suggestion to check out the nutritional composition of commercial cat foods. I hadn’t thought of that, and it’s definitely something to consider if he refuses the kidney diet.
This cat is an indoor/outdoor farm cat, and he lives with 2 other cats, so it won’t be possible to totally restrict his diet. He gets both wet and dry food, and he generously supplements his diet with mice and rats that he catches. I only noticed that he was peeing too much because he’s been inside more due to the cold weather. Of all the cats I’ve had over the years, he is the least picky about his food, so I hope I can find a kidney diet he will like.