Getting over the “what ifs” and “what might have beens”

Last winter/spring, I had my horse going better than ever. I was renting a dry stall at a small property with only one other horse. But the ring was tiny, I wasn’t taking lessons, horse wasn’t getting pro rides, and I felt we were ready for the next chapter.

I had visions of group lessons and schooling shows, finding a “barn family,” and progressing as a rider while my horse progressed in the program of a good pro.

I thought I found that. Took a couple lessons to feel the place out. Then, last spring, I made the jump.

Almost right away, it became obvious the environment wasn’t what I bargained for. I could get into it, but it would be a long story. Suffice it to say, it was a year of a slow and then rapid decline in my horse’s behavior and wellbeing, to the point where I was actually considering euthanizing the horse for dangerous behavior and even raised it with the vet and multiple trainers.

Despite all that, I refused to entertain the idea of leaving. I didn’t want to be a barn hopper. I blamed myself and my quirky horse for any friction at the barn. I didn’t think it could be better anywhere else. But finally, the situation got so desperate, I really did not have a choice. It was move or euthanize the horse. Horse was visibly miserable and unsafe to handle. Had to be aced daily. I arranged a move on a trial basis, telling the trainer at the new barn that the horse might be a lost cause. She said to give her 30 days and she’d let me know if she thought that was the right decision.

I was not optimistic. And moving this horse… you cannot imagine what a PITA it was. Truly an ordeal. But I am not kidding when I say that within 24 hours, the horse was visibly different. Within a week, unrecognizable, almost back to normal. Trainer started working with her. Within 3 weeks, she was going back undersaddle. Now it’s been 3 months and I feel like I miraculously have my horse back.

The only problem? I’m 8 months pregnant. I am pretty sure the pregnancy was the precipitating factor for the decline at the previous barn going from “slow” to “rapid,” because I had to stop riding and overall became less consistent. Now, the horse is in a much better headspace and, if I weren’t pregnant, I could theoretically be taking lessons and regaining all the ground we lost. But I can’t ride and don’t see myself riding until fall at the very earliest.

I have been struggling with the fact that things could have been SO different, if I had just moved to this new barn last year instead of the one I chose. I don’t know why I was so stubbornly in denial that things at the previous barn weren’t working. Not only was my horse not happy and not getting the training support we needed, there weren’t really other boarders to have a community with (the clientele were mainly lesson students and leasers).

If I had moved here first—and spent all of last year here—I could have had an awesome year of progress with my horse before getting pregnant. She might even have been at a point in her training where someone could have leased her from me. I could have had an actual barn family and local horse friends to stay connected with through my pregnancy, which would have been a big support through some of the pregnancy’s low points.

Instead, I feel like I failed my horse, like I took a major setback in confidence that I’m not sure I can bounce back from, and like I’m not sure what the path forward looks like from here. I still go to the barn to hand graze and walk around. I started volunteering at a therapeutic riding center, so I feel like I’m doing something with horses even while I can’t ride. I am thinking I’ll start taking lessons this winter, keep mine in training, and maybe venture to ride her next spring. But I can’t let go of the regret, or the feeling that there’s an alternate timeline out there in a parallel universe where I made better choices and created a much better situation for myself and my horse :confused:.

I don’t know if I’ll ever reach the level as a rider that I dreamed I would… if I’ll ever be that confident —or that fit or skinny— ever again in my life. And I guess it just bums me out to think I set myself up for such a rough comeback, when a different choice of barn could have put me (and my horse) in a much better position to navigate a big life change like this.

I don’t have kids myself but have watched many friends have their first and second. So take this with a grain of salt but -

This is pregnancy brain talking to some degree. I have friends who went from hyper-independent, confident, and sometimes wild risk takers, to introspective and somewhat anxious overthinkers for a while with kiddo #1. You’d think it would just be in connection to the kid but it really spilled over into all aspects of life, including horses! It’s such a life upheaval, and it’s no wonder you’re questioning your past choices!

I don’t have much to offer except to maybe look at it this way: you won’t make the same mistakes again, right? And your horse will be fine. Just take it a day at a time and see where you end up. You may be surprised to find it looks different than you once thought, but it’s fulfilling none the less!

22 Likes

Life is full of lessons.
Sometimes the lessons we wish for just aren’t the lessons the universe knows we need.
You learned a whole lot since moving her, and before moving her now learned in hindsight.
Those are super valuable lessons.
Hold onto them they will serve you well with your horse and your kid.
.
Glad to hear it worked out and you’re both in a better place.

6 Likes

Things happen for reasons. Usually we don’t figure it out until much later.

From reading your post, I come away with a totally different mindset. You moved the horse, things weren’t working out, it took longer than you think it should have, but you moved to what is looking like a great place. Things are going great right now.

In the big picture, you’ve just lost a year, maybe 18 months, that’s really not a lot of time. Sounds like you’re rather young (younger than me :smiley:) so you’ve got plenty of time. And, I’ve never been pregnant, but maybe you’re suffering from pregnancy hormones?

Sometimes, late at night, I think back on decisions I made 20 years ago, and think, what if… Then I think how great my life really is and get over it. I think we all think back on decisions we’ve made and get into the what if mind set.

You’re where you’re supposed to be at this point in life. I hope you can get past these feelings.

15 Likes

There are many paths to Rome and we all follow a different one. The key is never losing sight of one’s goals though even those might change a little depending on priorities and life circumstances. The ‘year lost’ is only a waste if you continue to let it be. Energy lost on regrets can never be regained but energy spent on capitalizing on lessons learned can actually help you reach your goals even if the path you’re following isn’t what you had originally had in mind. I can’t tell you the number of ‘oh well and oh damn’ moments that have presented me with the need to revisit and recalculate my plan to my ultimate goal with horses. I have been lucky to have had horses all my life. Not every situation worked out as I had dreamed but they were all invaluable regarding the knowledge gained and I’m a better horseperson as a result of each and every one. Could I have done better? Maybe, but the point is you can’t go back but you can definitely move forward.

That’s the high ceiling view. When I was in my teens and 20’s I had grand plans regarding my riding, professional life and my personal life. By early 30s I had two kids, the horses, the job and a marriage - juggling it all and sometimes a ball would drop but I’d pick them all back up and kept them in the air, time and time again. I’m turning 61 this summer. Kids are grown and on their own. Horses are still a huge part of my life as is my riding. I still work in the same profession as I did in my 20s. The marriage, well that didn’t survive but I have no regrets. I focused on what was most important to me which continues to create a reason for me to get up in the morning and look forward to another day. I have a recognized show coming up this weekend. I have a schooling show next month. I reflect back when I have big decisions to make only with the focus that I will make better choices each time. Life experiences should be your guiding light not an energy sucking nightmare. I got over my pregnancy brain both times :wink:

10 Likes

I am struggling with very similar feelings right now, though not quite the same situation. I bought my gelding at the end of 2022 and he has functionally been out of work since early last year with various ailments. He was meant to be the horse that I could hop on and have fun with, get out showing, etc. as an adult re-rider. Instead we did loooots of rehab.

Now he’s FINALLY going beautifully and we’ve made tremendous progress in the past couple months. We could theoretically have a really fun and successful season this summer. However, we are actively trying to get pregnant and I feel like I’m racing against the clock with my riding (which is also not how I want to feel about pregnancy! I am genuinely excited and don’t want pregnancy to be tinged with any hint of regret). We actually were going to start trying last year but I put it off because I wanted one last summer of horse fun before taking a break. Womp.

I think two things have helped me start to find peace with my “lost year.” One, I’ve been actively thinking about what my horse life looks like with a baby/kids, and brainstorming strategies with my husband and family to make sure that I’ll get the horse time I want. I’m also getting excited about enjoying my horses with my kids (eventually)! Two, I recognize that even though I didn’t get out to show and jump the really big jumps last year, I have learned SO MUCH and really grown as a horsewoman. Dealing with sickness, injuries, rehab, working with lesson horses and green horses while my guy was out, etc etc. And that is really so valuable.

ETA: I think what makes the “lost year” feel so devastating for me (and if I recall your history correctly, might be applicable to you too?) is that I had really just gotten fully back into horses after my post-college/young adult break. And it feels like a really short window where you have the financial stability to really dive into horses but before thinking seriously about kids. And it feels like that really short window was wasted. But I remind myself that there are 60+ year olds out there eventing and show jumping every day. I also struggle with the idea of I’ll never be as fit as I am now after having kids, but my mom is a competitive rower at 70 and I stg she’s almost as fit as me :rofl: So I’m also trying to keep that in mind.

2 Likes

It’s okay to grieve the loss of your dreams. Despite what society says, it is a genuine loss and working through the grieving process will allow you to get past it and build new dreams for a different future.

7 Likes

So first of all, give yourself some grace. Pregnancy is but a short stage of life. Growing a new human is a large task. It’s hard. Many aspects of it suck. You are not inadequate. You are accomplishing something amazing and while you may temporarily feel physically diminished and frustrated, you are in fact doing something extremely meaningful. Also, stop blaming yourself for your decision to move to the barn that ended up not being a good fit. You made the best decision you were able to, based on the information you had at the time. We all have these struggles and have decisions we regret, all you can do is learn from it and move on.

Secondly, pregnancy definitely takes its toll physically and mentally. Having a child to care for also changes things. I felt very similar to you after my pregnancies–that my former self was lost. I had to let go of that and just keep moving forward. My first few months of riding after pregnancy were on quiet trail horses. I was weak and exhausted. But, it turns out that since having kids I’ve been far stronger and fitter and a better rider than before. It is completely doable.

What was much harder was recognizing the new way horses needed to fit into my life. My time and my emotional energy became more precious. I had to let go of a couple horses that needed all the stars to be aligned for them to have a good day, horses that were never going enjoyable to invest myself in because of an “if only” issue. While I felt like a failure at the time, what I realized later is that knowing when to move on or make a change and having the decisiveness to actually do it is a really important and wise skill.

If your confidence has taken a hit, and you’ve had a break from riding, and this horse needs a lot of consistency to be fun and safe, then there is a possibility this might not be the right long term horse for you. Not every horse decompensates when they are at a barn that doesn’t suit them. When your baby is born and you are ready to get back into riding, don’t let guilt or shame pressure you into being stuck with a horse you don’t feel confident or secure on. Find a way to ride such that it is an activity that leaves you happy, not stressed or worried or feeling like a failure.

5 Likes

There’s nothing to regret in your story. (I know: easy for me to say).

You moved barns with the best of intentions and it didn’t work out. You wish you had understood sooner that it was the barn that was making the horse crazy rather than the horse just being crazy, but it’s not always easy to have that kind of clarity, particularly if so many things changed at once. (Horse was in a new barn, had new handlers and a new routine, different turnout situation, perhaps different feed, and was being ridden with different expectations, perhaps by a trainer as well as yourself, etc.). And not all barn situations work equally well for all horses.

Don’t beat yourself up. Things might have been different, sure. But you learned something from the bad experience and you both came out the other side. If you can, you should try to let go of the anxiety (or at least understand why you feel anguished about what might have been), and take away what you can as a learning experience.

I’ll add one more thing: it’s possible that, in your original post, you’ve downplayed just how bad the situation actually was. It could be that the place was actually abusive to your horse and then gaslighting you about the results. If that’s true, you might think about if there are any steps you’d like to take to make people aware of the conditions at the barn.

5 Likes

Yes, it’s this :100:. Feels like I’ve had such an uphill battle to having horses in my life. First it was money, then it was location, then it was being overhorsed. I do appreciate that I learned a lot of aspects of horsemanship that I never would have bothered to learn if I hadn’t had to. But I wish I were a better rider and had used my time more wisely. Feels like I missed a very narrow 3-year window where I could have grown a lot as a rider, built a community and found good mentorship, and learned in a gradual, safe, sustainable way. Instead I spent a LOT of time alone with my horse trying really, really hard and not having anything to show for it.

3 Likes

I worry about that with this horse, though one of my new barn friends was telling me to keep an open mind now that she is finally with a good pro. This forced break could be good for us, and she could come out of it totally transformed, grown up, and sane. Or not. But if not, we’ll find another path forward… I trust the trainer’s judgment and I’m glad I finally found someone I feel like I can trust my horse with. I had really hit rock bottom before moving here and was so burned out from trying to figure everything out on my own.

5 Likes

Yep, I get it. And the loss of that window feels a lot more momentous when you didn’t have the chance to climb the levels/do the big stuff as a junior and already feel like you’re playing catch up (which I am as well).

Of the advice I’ve read on here so far, @RedHorses’s resonates the most. I do ultimately feel quite confident that I’ll continue to get a lot of fulfillment from horses, even if I’m never out jumping 3’6" at shows etc., but that doesn’t always feel like a consolation now.

1 Like

I think living 40 years with chronic health conditions has primed me to do my best to live in the now. I have only felt in recent years that Ive gotten better at it. Also throw in a healthy dose of doing better when you know better. We don’t get hindsight until we go through something, and that hindsight can help us make better choices moving forward.

I used to be a huge what if thinker and I just can’t live like that anymore. Current example for me is my horse is going through his second bout of laminitis. His first was as a 4YO in 2021. Despite weighing everything he eats, being on a limestone drylot, and being in moderate work 5-6 days/week…it wasn’t enough and here we are. My gap there was not being vigilant about testing our hay. Lesson learned that we HAVE to be on top of that from here on out. I had big plans to kick our driving into high gear this summer being at a barn perfect for it. I had big plans to get some serious milage out on the trails too. That’s all on pause.

I’ve managed to not beat myself up over it and shift gears. This time last year. DH broke his foot and was out of commission most of the summer and I did a lot with the horse by myself this time last year and had a blast. This year, DH and I really upped the time we’re getting out hiking/biking/kayaking at one of several of our local park systems. I am also feeling more functional with my health conditions than I have in a long time so I am enjoying each day that I can do more than the bare minimum with home, work, barn, fun stuff.

I can’t waste my precious time thinking about the past or worrying about the future. In regards to my past…I am truly happy with my life and I know I wouldn’t be where I am at today without everything prior to it. It’s easier said than done of course, but making a conscious effort to live in the now gets easier and easier the more you practice it.

Ill also add the disclaimer that I am not and never have been a bubbly optimistic type person so I have never had that in my favor either :joy: I’d call myself a realist/skeptic most of the time with most things.

6 Likes

Is there a realistic scenario on this planet where spending one more second thinking about any of this will improve your life, make you happier, make your horse happier or bring any sort of joy to humankind?

No. You did the best you could with the information you had at the time. So drop those regrets like a hot brick, look forwards and kick on.

You never know what future you is capable of. :sparkles:

9 Likes

I always intended to have horses back in my life. But when I could finally afford it, I was too disabled. Yeah, that sucked, but there is nothing I can do about it. I always try to look forward, not back. I did what I could with my horses with a huge amount of help from my husband. That ended up being driving my ponies around the neighborhood, no more riding. And that ended when my ponies aged out and had to be retired. I am very grateful for what I had. Do I have regrets? Absolutely, but I don’t let them hang around or steal my contentment with my present life. Who knows, if I’d pursued horses the way I originally wanted to, I could have had a devastating injury and ended up in essentially the same place.

Pregnancy is a very weird time. Being a new parent is also a very weird time. But both are very special. Please give yourself the ability to enjoy this phase of your life, and don’t worry about what you can’t change.

Rebecca

8 Likes

As a (not horse related) friend of mine would say-
Coulda Woulda Shoulda.

1 Like

What is key in life to remember is you will fail. You will make mistakes. Some people make big ones - people die - they die. We all have not made THOSE mistakes - thank God. Key is to learn from it. Tell yourself you’ll never make that mistake again. You’ll catch yourself. And you will. And you’ll be proud of yourself and you should.

Most of us here have had some big mistakes with horses. My worst was one I used to get emotional talking about - SERIOUS guilt. My horse growing up was simply amazing. Out galloping bareback and then county fair champion in one event or another year after year. It was glorious.

My parents divorced and my world fell apart. We had to move and sell our property and I never thought to make it work and keep my horse. She was sold into a horrible home where she was so mistreated this perfect, lovely, willing creature became unrideable. I finally forgave myself that I was doing the best I could at the time and I would never.ever let anything like that happen to another horse of mine. That was 48 years ago and I never have. No horse of mine has left me. It still haunts me about her though.

Another horse I took on came out of a terrible situation and I had a woman helping me rehab her because of my tight schedule. What I didn’t realize was she was not helping this horse. When I watched her ride and saw the complete lack of understanding of what this horse was capable of at that moment I stopped it. No more riding. No more involvement. I was shocked. But I took action immediately.

You will do the same. Forgive yourself and commit to doing right about it from now on.

And remember we ALL fail. We fail our way to success.

10 Likes

All we can do is try to learn from experience and try to make different mistakes.

18 Likes

This is not an and, it’s a beginning.Also, there is childcare available, babies like to be with other babies and you can ride a couple of times a week and enjoy the education the pro is giving your horse.I did that (minus the pro riding my horses)and it was SO nice to have something other than a baby to love and care for.Being able to ride then go home and not worry is priceless.Also, congratulations on the coming baby, SO exciting!

1 Like

Luckily my husband has always been my horse’s biggest cheerleader. We’ll have to see how it pans out in practice, but he’s already expressed his intention to his company to leave work by a certain hour each day to get home in time for me to do 5:30-7:30 at the barn in the evenings. So, that’s the plan for after his paternity leave ends. I didn’t even ask him to do that; I overheard him explaining the plan to a coworker and was honestly pretty touched that he’d thought ahead to how to accommodate daily barn time in our schedule. Of course, I’m worried the practical reality of life with a baby will change that picture somewhat… But at least I know that’s his intention going into it. He’s definitely not going to be pressuring me to give up horses. It will just be me and my anxiety I have to contend with.

18 Likes