I’m the other one who paid the price of a jump judge’s dog. My horse is not find of strange dogs (soooooo much better than he used to be, when even my well behaved, very horse savvy dog would send him into orbit). He spooked at the judge’s BARKING dog and lost focus jumping into a pretty tough combination, and left a stride out in a panic. I got the free ride to the hospital and spent over 5 months out of the saddle. Three months of that on crutches.
Funny, I am not opposed to WELL BEHAVED horse savvy, well contained dogs at horse shows. My own dog was sleeping at the trailer when we crashed. And they definitely should NOT be with a jump judge (plenty of reasons why if you do a search for the thread about my accident or search for the discussion on EN’s Facebook page about it).
I still take my dog. But she is VERY quiet (usually…about once every 10 outings, she barks at a dog for about 5 seconds). She is VERY well behaved. She barely acknowledges other horses and people. I can tie her to the trailer with a bed in the shade and water and she sleeps soundly while I’m away. If it’s cool, she happily snoozes in the truck. I can stick her in a stall if we’re stabling, and know she’ll go to sleep and not bark and carry on while I’m gone. It is not unusual for a neighbor to no realize she was even there. When I walk around venues with her, she does not pull or act up. We usually have a loop in her leash, and I stop to watch a round, talk to the secretary, chat with friends, order food, whatever, she lays down at my feet and sleeps or surveys her kingdom. She is an EXCELLENT companion. Better traveled than most humans, better behaved than most humans her age (she’s almost 12).
Are your dogs going to be quiet, content to snooze when left alone? Are they good around horses, strangers, and other dogs? Are they at anxious or aggressive? Are they obedient? Do they have good manners? Will you be distracted by worrying about them while you’re riding?
I would say that if they aren’t going to be very well behaved unsupervised, and a distraction to you, you may be better off boarding them or finding a dog sitter you CAN trust. Dogs are a touchy subject at horse shows and I get it. I also have an amazingly good dog. When she is gone, I may elect to leave the next one at home (my old dog didn’t go to many shows because she was not as good as Stella). Even the best dogs can be distracting, and I do worry, when she’s tied, that a less awesome dog will be loose and hurt her. Be honest with yourself, for your sake, your dogs’ sake, and oth competitors’ sake…are they going to be a distraction?