Do you see how there’s a reply arrow on each post, and a reply box at the very bottom of the thread?
If you click the reply arrow on a post, that is a reply to that specific post, and the person who’s post that is gets a notification that you’ve replied to their post. Here, you’ve replied to one of my posts. See how my avatar is in the upper right on your post indicating this?
If you click on the reply box at the bottom of the thread, rather than a reply arrow on a post, that’s a general reply on the thread and no one is notified, other than the original poster (if you’re replying to a thread where you’re not the original poster.)