Health of US horse racing . . .

This is a worthy read for those worried about the future of horse racing. As the article says, horse racing needs to begin to pay attention to customer and fan experience.

Yesterday at the Waste Management Phoenix Open 203k spectators showed up for the 3rd round. The tournament is played in Scottsville. Scottsville itself has a population of 230k. Lord only knows how many fans and spectators will show today for the final round. If golf can attract crowds like that at weekly PGA events why not horse racing?

http://www.paulickreport.com/news/ray-s-paddock/las-vegas-embraces-new-realities-can-racing-do-the-same/

For a different set of reasons TX looks to follow VA, MA, NH, ID, etc into the obituary of US horseracing. Back in the early 20th century the term for the problems was corruption. Today we refer to the problems as “politics as usual.”

http://www.paulickreport.com/news/ray-s-paddock/deja_vu_texas_racing_on_the_brink/

Ray Paulick talks horsemen leadership salaries

http://www.paulickreport.com/news/ray-s-paddock/honoring-our-presidents-executive-salaries-at-horse-industry-non-profit-organizations/

I am encouraged that the executive salaries are not in millions. The percentage of revenue is discouraging for many. Ray did not speak to leadership productivity. That is where he needs to direct the conversation.

PA is taking a different path to save racing in the state.
I must say I am not sure where this goes. IMO it sounds experimental but apparently the governor is going to sign the passed legislation. Not saying experimental is bad. Here in VA the horsemen leadership has been appallingly bad, the VRC is stacked with “living off their ancestry” elites, and the General Assembly has no idea what is going on the industry. It is no wonder VA horseracing is in turf’s obituary.

I pray that PA is on to something but like AMERICAN PHARAOH at stud we will just have to wait and see. There is always a chance that following a blind man will get you somewhere good.

http://www.paulickreport.com/news/the-biz/pa-senate-approves-bill-creating-new-racing-commission-awaits-governors-signature/

[QUOTE=Shammy Davis;8531709]
Ray Paulick talks horsemen leadership salaries

http://www.paulickreport.com/news/ray-s-paddock/honoring-our-presidents-executive-salaries-at-horse-industry-non-profit-organizations/

I am encouraged that the executive salaries are not in millions. The percentage of revenue is discouraging for many. Ray did not speak to leadership productivity. That is where he needs to direct the conversation.[/QUOTE]

Just wanted to follow-up on this Paulick article. I recently came across an article about what Roger Goodell, NFL commissioner, and what he made in salary and bonuses in 2015. It was an astounding $34 million, of which his base salary was only $3.5 million. Simply, the NFL commissioner made $30 million in workplace production bonuses.

Check this link out which shows the gradual increase in Goodell’s annual income, in the millions, to the total NFL revenues annually, in the billions.

http://www.businessinsider.com/chart-roger-goodell-salary-nfl-revenue-2014-9

There is an old saying that you get what you pay for. The horse racing industry can learn from the successes of professional football, baseball, basketball, soccer, etc. The multiple organizations in place to run racing and horsemen groups are out of date, bloated, slow to act, disagreeable, self-serving, just to name a few negative adjectives. Productive leadership is worth every dime spent on it. Though horse industry salaries look reasonable in today’s economic climate, the state of horse racing can be compared to the fiddle playing while Rome burns.

Two weeks ago the PGA drew a record 300K plus to a 4 day golf tournament in Scottsdale, AZ. 280K of the spectators were party goers obstructing the view of real avid golf fans, but no one complained as everyone had a blast.

Not US, but your neighbour to the north. Northlands park shutting down after 116 years. Will run in 2016. That’s all folks. Another one bites the dust.

[QUOTE=Shammy Davis;8533099]
PA is taking a different path to save racing in the state.
I must say I am not sure where this goes. IMO it sounds experimental but apparently the governor is going to sign the passed legislation. Not saying experimental is bad. Here in VA the horsemen leadership has been appallingly bad, the VRC is stacked with “living off their ancestry” elites, and the General Assembly has no idea what is going on the industry. It is no wonder VA horseracing is in turf’s obituary.

I pray that PA is on to something but like AMERICAN PHARAOH at stud we will just have to wait and see. There is always a chance that following a blind man will get you somewhere good.

http://www.paulickreport.com/news/the-biz/pa-senate-approves-bill-creating-new-racing-commission-awaits-governors-signature/[/QUOTE]

My farm is in PA where we breed and race. The breeding side of things has totally collapsed due to mismanagement by the state/certain officials, and the leadership of the well meaning but clueless Breeders Association. A bunch of amateurs running a multi million dollar company.

Don’t get me started on VA. My adopted state that I go way back with. Colonial Downs was boondoggle from the get go. IMO

A friend of mine was the paid executive of the PA Breeders As. He left and moved to VA for personal reasons and was hired by the VA Breeders. He knows a bit about racing, certainly after being here. He was on the PA racing commission for a while. Family got him that appointment. Don’t believe he has ever owned a racehorse other than the odd Steeplechase horse. Has never bred one let alone put his money where is mouth/expertise is suppose to be. But he is a good guy just one of those that gets by on connections more than expertise.

I can’t for the life of me understand why they hired Danny VanCleif. If they really looked more into what he has done other than his WAY too long tenure as the head of the Breeder’s Cup. They would see he is nothing more than a "good ole boy’. His father was a great guy, one of my father’s best friends and a stock holder and board member of the “old Fasig Tipton”. Danny Jr worked for the company way back when when he was a young man and starting out. I happened to be in the room when his father asked John Finney how Danny Jr was doing. John said, “worthless as tits on a bull”. Almost fell of my chair and had to pinch myself real hard not to start laughing.

John Gaines who I had a number of one on one conversations with said pretty much the same thing about him at the Breeders’ Cup.

[QUOTE=Flypony;8535544]
Not US, but your neighbour to the north. Northlands park shutting down after 116 years. Will run in 2016. That’s all folks. Another one bites the dust.[/QUOTE]

:eek:

[QUOTE=Cartier;8393695]
Things change. Imagine if you will the conversation in 1066 between two breeders of those mamouth horses that had the body mass to carry a knight in heavy armor into battle, “Gilbert, the future looks bleak for us, the numbers are down across the board, and we just can’t seem to get the kids interested in jousting like we were at their age. People can get drunk at home these days, and the women folk can’t stand the smell. It’s the end of life as we know it.”

Things change. To succeed and thrive, you have to change too, and adapt. I would not be playing catch up, or desperately trying to package the sport in a way to appeal to a crowd that has no genuine intertest and will not sustain the sport anyway. Don’t dumb the whole thing down. Educate the public about how unique and amazing it truly is.

I think the focus on betting is too much, I don’t watch the races to bet. Heck, I could probably bet on anything. And I would avoid describing a win or a winning career as random luck. I watch the races because they are uniquely a context for supreme skill, superb preparation, excellent conditioning, raw natural talent and sublime ability. As a fan, when I have even a small bit of the back story on a particular horse, I am drawn in and will follow that horse.

I think the appeal of American Pharoah was the horse himself, his raw talent and ability, and not the bells and whistles surrounding him. His entire team kept the focus where it belonged, on the horse
 a race horse, and not a media clown.

Market racing intelligently, by using informed experienced industry insiders, who’s opinions are grounded in an accurate understanding of the sport, it’s history, what it takes to breed a champion, and what it takes to nurture phenomenal genetic potential to a winning career. Let the public understand that to preserve racing, they have to preserve more than just a track. It’s about zoning laws, and affordable space for training centers, and breeding farms, and supporting professionals in the sport at every level. Let people accurately see that racing is not just about getting drunk in your fancy hat on the first Saturday in May.

I’d stay away from outside PR people marketing the sport to neophytes, creating a mob frenzy of lunacy like we saw with C Chrome. There are far too many non-racing / non-horse folks involved in marketing the sport. They start with a premise that you need to dumb things down for the average guy, making horse’s like Chrome’s name synonimous with a profound ignorance of the sport. The average guy is not and will never be your target audience. The focus should be on attracting the next generation of informed fans and participants.

People love baseball. The sport is thriving. It’s a complicated game, with an endless list of statistics, requiring expensive venues and community support. You would never see some silicone injected blonde bimbo announcing a game, or doing the color commentary. Baseball is treated with respect for what it is, and respect for the knowledge it takes to know and play the game well. Fans are expected to step up and “master Baseball.” And they do. Racing should be packaged the same way, with respect for what it is, and how unique and valuable it is, both on race day and in our communities the other 364 days a year.[/QUOTE]

Everyone loves a winner though.
I saw with the advent of OTB stores in NY, spectators dropped like rain.
Then The NJ casino(s) opened

Vegas started showing those big screen races.
Its like trying to compete against big box stores. Maybe we can have our
horses made in China to keep costs low and have give aways for actual people coming to the parks.
but to be real, If I were a spectator, I would pick and choose a day at the races, not many days at the races.
The recession/ depression really took its toll this time.

I worry about the continued research and if that will also be put the wayside.
I’d bet money on that already.

I miss the days we all pored over the newspapers racing information and stories about sires,dams,owners,racing stats. We all knew every jockies name and personal lives, every horses name and kept percentages and place in our minds like baseball
stats.

I love racing, my pop loved racing but we were sad to see the decline in vitality of health .

Actually I stopped by this thread to see if there was any line breeding going on the
increase canon size and foot size/healthy tissue issues.
Penn State?

Hokey dokey, sorry to butt in.

Decoupling=the push down the slippery slope

[QUOTE=NMK;8537880]
Decoupling=the push down the slippery slope[/QUOTE]

I was just going to chime in on the decoupling issue. The situation in many states is dire without a percentage of revenues from casino gambling being diverted to racetrack operations. WV and FL legislatures (maybe others?) are considering bills that would make it even less financially feasible to have live racing. I don’t know where the bills stand.

The legislators are clueless about the economic impact that the horse industry has. It is very frustrating to watch.

They should never have been coupled in the first place. The idea that a casino MUST be placed at a racetrack and MUST share it’s revenue with horses is bizarre.

They are two different types of gambling, and can and do coexist in the same universe, they do so around the world.
Racing should have concentrated on selling itself to the public as it’s own gambling and spectating product. Living off of slots welfare is both unnatural and unfair. It should stand on it’s own two feet. Slot revenue means it hasn’t had to try, like the unemployed 35 year old dude still living at home.

When online video content became available, did they pass laws that Netflix etc should share revenue with Blockbuster Video? Hell no, that would be patently bizarre.

Racing is thriving in other parts of the world, and in some of those places there is more gambling competition than in the US. So I don’t buy that racing can’t compete with casinos. Give the American public a product and experience that excites them more than the handful of high profile races a year and maybe they will go back to the track. Boutique meets like Keeneland, Del Mar and Saratoga are where it’s at. Maybe some racing needs to go away.

FL legislature passes decoupling and purse pools. TX racing commission repeals historical betting. Guess they blinked in face of extinction. NH tables Rockingham casino proposal. Finger Lakes keeps 155 days racing. Fairgrounds increases over night purses by 10%. And you still don’t have to be lonely at Farmers Only.com.
Don’t known what to make of all this but looks like an even split of good over bad last week.

Article says that FL mortgaging the future to save racing today. Who would have guessed?

http://www.bradenton.com/entertainment/article61517407.html

Lots of chatter on this subject. Too many links to keep up with. When horsemen leadership state by state coupled their future with gamblers they dug the industry into a big hole. The business model for profiteering gamblers is based on taking people’s money. Don’t believe sharing profits is in their thinking.

And then there are tracks that are just struggling to pay the bills.

http://m.therepublic.com/view/story/23dc0e76380944feab5c2bb876713ccc/ND--Fargo-Horse-Racing

Kentucky Derby listed as one of ten sporting events to have lost it’s appeal. The list includes the Tour de France, Davis Cup, America’s Cup, and Indianapolis 500.

http://www.realclearsports.com/lists/top_10_sporting_events_lost_their_luster/intro.html

http://www.paulickreport.com/news/the-biz/website-places-ky-derby-on-list-of-fading-sporting-events/

A skeptical Ray Paulick reports on racing town hall meeting discussion on whether horse racing is capable of solving it’s most serious problems.

http://www.paulickreport.com/news/ray-s-paddock/town-hall-meeting-can-horse-racing-solve-its-biggest-problems/

Good things for horse racing occurred last week. Notable is Fargo, ND racing gets funded. TX commission survives. Yadayadayada. And then there is this in FL.

http://www.sunshinestatenews.com/story/black-friday-florida-horse-racing-going-going

Just goes to show that stupidity is rampant regardless of political affliction. The FL legislature must have been humming “Carry Me Back To Ole Virginny” as they passed the decoupling bill. To FL’s credit or saving grace horse racing still exists there. VA’s Governor actually allowed a bunch of political appointees to destroy an entire industry. Casinos aren’t an issue in the Old Dominion.

In this article Bill Shanklin looks at the problem of stagnant parimutuel handles at tracks across NA. He suggests experimenting with a reduction in takeout and lays out plan to experiment with the idea.

Very thoughtful article.

http://www.horseracingbusiness.com/experimental-design-and-takeout-rates-13783.htm

WV legislature seeks to stop racetrack modernization 4 years earlier than planned.

http://wvpublic.org/post/house-finance-passes-bill-end-racetrack-modernization-fund

FL senate comes to it senses and kills decoupling.

http://www.miamiherald.com/news/local/community/miami-dade/article63355667.html