Is he that bad? No. There are far worse.
Full disclosure: I have never stepped foot in Hollendorfer’s barn. But I think Hollendorfer probably does need to go to make an example of a model of “horsemanship” that we cannot continue to tolerate or support in the 21st century if the sport is to survive. If I am wrong about this, someone please speak up, but he has always seemed to employ the formulaic treatment of horses like commodities duct taped together with modern medicine. I’d unfortunately say most trainers operate in this manner to varying degrees.
But… I think this is a situation where two wrongs don’t make a right. How the Stronach Group has gone about this is a real head scratcher. You can’t single someone out for muddied reasons and expect people to learn from it. You can’t single someone out for doing the same thing everyone else is doing and expect to win your case.