How do you define pasture sound?

I agree. Both of the above horses can be laid to rest with dignity and a clear conscience, knowing you’ve gone above and beyond.

Look, all horses are going to die. It’s a one way street. WE GET TO CHOOSE to allow them to suffer, or to prevent that. It is a gift. There is nothing to be gained by letting them drag along trying to hide how much pain they are in, and most of the issues described are incurable or barely manageable.

Realize the the difficulty in performing this act for them is that, selfishly, you love and will miss them. You can miss them now, or miss them with a dose of added regret later when they have taken a turn for the worse and it’s an emergency to get them put down.

Give them some amazing days and let them go in peace.

2 Likes

I just want to take a moment and thank those who responded to both of our plights with our geldings. I have definitely been thinking about my gelding’s quality of life over the last few months, and really defining in my head what I owe to him. And being able to type it out for the first time and read it back along with others comments does put it in perspective. For a long time i was throwing all the treatments at him because of his young age, and really hopeful that something would eventually work - or we’d find the magic mix of maintenance and treatments to make him comfortable enough to live a quality life. I needed to do those things for him because I knew I’d question myself for the rest of my own life if I didn’t, I knew I wouldn’t be able to live with it, too many “what if’s”. The money spent to do so will make anyone cringe, but in my mind it was money well spent, and had the treatments actually worked, I’d continue with it without question. Selfishly, I wanted to fix him. Yes, for him to have a comfortable and productive life, but for me too. But now that the stones have been turned, and to no avail, I feel a little more at peace with thinking through what the road ahead looks like for him, and myself. Admitting defeat is tough.

At the end of the day, I have changed my stance on what I owe him. Initially it was I owe him a chance at a comfortable, long life. But given all of our failed attempts, I don’t think I owe him a long life at all. I owe him comfort, and if I cannot give that, a peaceful, dignified end. And since we’re struggling with the comfort part, I think I know where I stand. Its a conversation I am prepared to have with my vet. Thank you, all.

11 Likes

I will choose quality of life over quantity all day. I think it’s actually the more ethical position.

8 Likes

I euthanized my sweet boy two weeks ago, and I can say I did go too far and regret it . He was lame the last two years from LCL injury right front and both stifles, then six weeks ago he broke P1. CSU said the surgery would be easy and honestly my love for him made me make the snap decision to do the surgery. He ended up developing laminitis shortly after the surgery and spent the last month of his life in pain and I regret deeply not letting him go when I should have. It would have been much more humane to have let him pass peacefully when we found the broken leg. I have been so sad since losing him and hate that the barn isn’t my happy place anymore. I’m not sure how long it will take to stop expecting him waiting for me.

6173E736-A7E8-4A40-AE08-2C0A3B8A8A08.jpeg

5 Likes

How heartbreaking… you did the best you could with the information you had at the time, out of love. Don’t punish yourself for trying.

1 Like

I am so sorry for your loss @Kmisschuck

I, too, euthanised my young lad (discussed in this thread) at the start of October. After doing a set of spinal and neck imaging, it was revealed that he had very advanced spondylosis on the ventral (underside) aspect of his thoracic vertebrae. Apparently this is not overly common, and while some horses can live on relatively pain free, my horse was experiencing a rapid deterioration in quality of life since July, despite NSAIDS and other therapies. Given that plus the laundry list of other things, it seemed rather unfair to expect him to carry on- and he was never going to get better. I chose to to euthanize before the situation became critical for him, which could’ve been weeks/months/or even years- but doubtful given how quickly he was deteriorating over the summer. He passed peacefully, at his home, on a warm morning filled to the brim with peppermints, muffins, and carrots, and surrounded by those who did our very best for him.

The loss is still fresh and raw - it just plain hurts. I too still expect to see him in “his” stall at the barn, which is now occupied by another. I still know that letting him go was very much the right thing to do. Looking back, I do wish I had gotten the spine xrays earlier, and I do think he was experiencing more pain than I realized - and a lot of the strange/odd ball behaviors now seem so crystal clear. But like @Xanthoria says above, we do the best with the information we have at the time, and out of love.

2 Likes

One that isn’t sound for consistent work, but when not in work is more sound.

However, I wouldn’t just pull shoes and put a horse out to pasture that is used to living in and being pampered. Those poor souls always look so miserable.

I get that there is a transitional period, but if the horse is still miserable months later… bring him inside.

1 Like