How long do you expect a blanket to keep your horse dry in the rain before switching out?

Title is pretty much the question. I was told by a CS rep at a major blanket manufacturer today that 12 hours is a long time for a 1680 denier, lightweight (100 gm) to midweight (220 gm) to be in the rain on a horse and that I should expect the blanket to leak if I am asking it to repel water that long without switching out. This is a $200 blanket that has a lifetime guarantee on the waterproofing.

I was pretty floored–I’ve had blankets stay water repellent for DAYS in nasty weather, keeping my horses dry when they stand outside 24/7, not using the nice shelter they have. Including blankets from this manufacturer! She made no response when I pointed this out and simply reiterated that 12+ hours was way too much to ask a turnout blanket–not sheet–to keep a horse dry.

So, COTHers, I ask you. Do you have enough blankets that you can swap out every 12 hours as needed in rain? Or do you expect your blankets to hold up to a few days of nasty weather? Or perhaps something in between? I’m trying to figure out if my expectations are truly too high, or if they’re just trying to explain away their blanket’s waterproofing failing.

I expect them to stay waterproof for days of wet weather :slight_smile: I usually buy the Horseware Amigos (although the newest ones are VERY lightweight) and have never had one leak or lose its waterproofing. The one I used yesterday is 8 years old! The real waterproofing is actually in between the liner and the outer materials, not whatever waterproofing is applied to the outside the blanket. The sheets sometimes LOOK sopping wet, but the horse is dry underneath.

All that said, I wash them infrequently, using cold water and a gentle detergent and I hang them to dry. I do not leave them outside when not in use.

3 Likes

The CS rep is obviously not on the West Coast, then :lol: ! Days of unrelenting rain is the normal this time of year, and all my horse’s (good quality- Horsewear- all 3 lines) sheets and blankets have withstood the deluges without once being changed. I also generally use sheet and liners so wash only the liners on a regular basis and the covering sheet infrequently, like at the end of the season and maybe once in the middle of the winter.

2 Likes

Same as newhorsemommy. I expect my high quality turnouts to keep my horses dry…period. The longest they’ve had to sit in a constant downpour is perhaps 24hrs, but horse stays dry. 12hr rains are not unusual, and I would be pissed if my horse was wet.

That said, I wash my blankets infrequently, and I usually leave a rainsoaked rug on until the horse’s body heat dries it out. Taking a dripping rug off to hang, it will probably take longer to dry and may be damp inside several hours later when you go to put it back on a horse.

2 Likes

The only blankets I buy anymore are Rambos. Yes, They are expensive, but for piece of mind and lack of leaks they can not be beat. I can leave a blanket on my horse 24/7 for weeks just pulling it to groom with no leaks. If a blanket started to leak after 12 hours I would throw it away. I have an ten year old Rambo that just became an “in stall only” blanket this year since it finely leaks a little after several hours of rain. They have worked well on many horses for me in a whole variety of boarding situations. They also have a blanket trade in program every fall that can help reduce the price.

4 Likes

Thanks for the responses, everyone. They echo how I felt about the situation!

The company I reached out to was Schneider’s Saddlery; I’ve used their blankets for years with great success and love the fit and durability for my playful TBs. I’ve also never had an issue with the waterproofing–until I ordered their VTEK Armorflex Warrior/Stormshield Marathon lightweight blankets, which have 80gms of fill along the topline and are essentially sheets with no fill through the sides. I wasn’t thrilled to discover this design, since I am not a big fan of sheets and don’t typically expect them to stay super waterproof, but figured I would give it a try since their guarantees are so good. Well, first big storm, and my horse is wet on his sides but dry through the top. Ok, well, I’m not pleased and contact them–get a fantastic reply and they send another blanket promptly, saying this was considered a waterproofing failure. No kidding? I expect the second blanket to work better–nope, big storm we had in CA last week, horse is wet underneath the sheet part, dry underneath the fill. Mind you, these blankets are less than 6 months old and never seen a washing machine or even a hose. They lived in their packages inside until the rain started. Additionally, the horse in the medium weight of the same style and size that I ordered at the same time stayed totally dry through three days of unrelenting rain.

So at this point I resign myself to lightweights only being suitable for light rain/mild weather, and call to inquire about the Tekno-Fleece lined blanket, which is supposed to be comparable to a lightweight but hopefully the complete lining will help it stay drier. Then began the entire discussion where the CS rep essentially told me I was nuts for using these blankets for that long on pastured horses and “no breathable blanket will go hours without getting saturated.” This is a really sharp turn from the amazing customer service I’ve received from them in the past. As I mentioned in the original post, she had no response when I mentioned my medium weight SSTack blanket staying waterproof and dry for three days, or the fact that I have one of their 100gm EuroCut stormshield blankets from 2014 that has never been washed beyond a quick hose down, has sat out on fence posts during the summer, and just generally been through hell but STILL remained waterproof for several days when I had to swap it out because my brand new one was soaked! And my Shires blankets did just fine as well, keeping everyone dry and comfy for about a week straight of nasty weather.

I suspect I would be quite happy with the Tekno-Fleece blanket, but I’m so peeved they may have lost me as a customer. Her suggestion was to toss the nasty blanket in the washer and dryer to “revive” the waterproofing, and just have enough blankets to swap out, or to stall my horses. Um…NO!

Time to go see what other blankets Shires has on offer…

2 Likes

I have Horseware Rhino mediumweight Wugs and just had it on one horse for a week straight through the storms we just had. Sun came out this morning and the blanket came off. The blanket is heavy and gross but the horse is clean and dry. A day with some dry air and the blanket will be dry and ready for the next storm system. (I don’t bother cleaning it; the horse will just put the mud right back on…)

The blanket stays on as long as it’s raining, however long that is. He has a second lighter sheet for light rain but really the Wug is it for any serious rain. And this Wug is 5 years old.

3 Likes

I expect years out of my blankets, and there is no reason not to. With the new fabrics and weatherproofing, they should hold up. I’d be pretty pissed off if a blanket was only waterproof for 12 hours, I don’t care what name brand it was. I don’t wash my blankets or dry them in a dryer, as I understand this can be detrimental to the weatherproofing.

2 Likes

I’m also in CA, and both of my horses stayed dry in their Horseware sheets. My mare has the Amigo Bravo Wug, which actually at 1200d is a little heavy for my area (a sheet that’s too heavy!), but she’s got high withers and it fits her well. My gelding has the new Amigo with ACY fabric. I LOVE this sheet. I think it’s 900d? So a little sturdier than the super light Amigo but not as heavy as a 1200d. I only paid about $120 for it and I think it’s a really nice sheet. For our downpours yesterday though he wore the super cheap Amigo (less than $70) and stayed plenty dry. I’m hoping they come out with the Wug in a slightly lighter weight fabric because the 1200d really is too warm for my area with a furry, unclipped horse.

1 Like

I’m in wet Oregon, and my two ponies are in rhino wugs, and my riding mare wears Hug turnouts 24/7. It can rain for days and their turnouts keep them dry. I never switch them out because they’ve leaked. I do have backups of all their rugs so one can be in the wash and they are still covered. That rep is full of it.

1 Like

I’ve had problems with Schneider’s leaking. My rambo wugs both sheets and blankets never leak even after days of rain. I waterproof them about every 4 years.

1 Like

I bought a few turnout sheets during Schneiders last blanket sale. It was supposed to rain one evening without getting cold, I put the sheets on, turned the horses out, and went to bed. The next morning, not EVEN 12 hours later, the two horses wearing the two new sheets were NOT dry under their sheets. I did send an email to CS and got a prompt reply asking for some information on the tags, but have not followed up yet. I have always had good luck with my Schneiders blankets and sheets until this year and that makes me sad. They have been my go to for many years.

1 Like

Another PNWer - I typically own two rain sheets and two mid-weight turn-outs per horse. Sheets get used for 4-6 weeks early fall and late spring. Mid-weights typically stay on 24x7 mid-fall through spring except when horse is being ridden or groomed. I’ve had Rambo and Amigo products go for years and not leak. I typically send them out for professional washing and repair in the off season.

1 Like

My Weatherbeeta’s doesn’t leak after days of NoVa rain. It has even kept my pony dry in the middle of a hurricane. Three year warranty and cheaper than Rambos with the same warranty. I wash them myself and have yet to have to re-waterprooof them.

I purchased a cheap pony sheet at Dover and it leaked after 12 hours. I’m debating on using this stuff to waterproof it and have it as a backup.
https://www.amazon.com/303-30674-Fabric-Guard-128/dp/B0000AY1W7/

1 Like

We waterproof after washing. We wash on the rail not in a machine. So far, so good. I’m pretty sure I’d ask for my money back if a new blanket was leaking after 12 hours of wear. Unless there was a disclaimer at time of purchase.

2 Likes

I expect at least two seasons of dry-in-any conditions before I see leaks and re-waterproof. At this point, I only buy Rambos and Amigo Bravos. I caved and grabbed a Pessoa 1680D sheet off the clearance rack at Beval a few weeks ago, but haven’t tested it yet.

Bolded by me, in reference to my question:

Is it possible that the water or wind from the neck area (or some other maybe not fitting right)? Just asking (and I doubt it). I am NOT disputing you. You’d just think if it wasn’t waterproof it would go through the fill as well?

And what horrible customer service.

I wish I had grabbed a picture–the horse was wet literally EVERYWHERE there wasn’t fill. You could literally draw an outline of the blanket pattern. If it had just been his shoulders/chest, I would agree, but his whole side and flank was also soaked, on both sides. I agree with you, tho–I don’t know why the parts with the fill stayed dry, but the sheet part didn’t.

1 Like

Another comment about how any “waterproof” turnout sheet/blanket better be WATERPROOF no matter the length of time on the horse or how long it rains! I now only buy Horseware brands as in addition to the waterproofing, they just fit the horse better.

1 Like

I’m in CA, too. My blankets last for years and years.

They are not expensive ones. I buy what’s on sale, sometimes super cheap ones. About once a year I might put it in the washer, or clean it well with a hose, and respray it with cheap waterproofing I got for houses about $20 a gallon.

The blankets I have now run from three to probably fifteen years old and have patches and repairs and none of them get wet on the body.