How to deal with neighbor's "free range dog"

I’ve lived here for 9 years and have been on good terms with my neighbor, until now. When I first moved in, he introduced me to his “free range dog” which was allowed to wander anywhere. The dog occasionally came into my yard but never bothered my horses.

That dog died a bit over a year ago, and last summer my neighbor got a puppy. Said puppy is now almost a year old and is the new “free range dog.” This dog is in my yard for hours every day, wanders down the street, narrowly misses getting hit by cars, and is roaming farther from home. Two days ago he ran into my mare’s paddock and chased her - I happened to see it happen and went after him with a lunge whip, at which point he ran home.

I’m at the end of my rope with this neighbor. Since he got divorced a few years ago, he’s started all sorts of fun behaviors, like setting off fireworks, burning when we’re under red flag warnings, letting his teen daughter do donuts on my lawn with their Polaris, etc. Now, the dog issue.

The mare in that paddock will attack dogs, but my other mares won’t. I just put the third ride on my four-year-old the other day; if the dog chases her while I’m on her, it won’t end well. (My ring is about 30 feet from the paddock the dog was in.) I have hot electric fencing, but the dog slips through. It’s HorseGuard, so animals have to touch both the top and bottom wires on the tape simultaneously to get shocked; I think it’s unlikely the dog will do so.

I can talk to the neighbor, explaining one of my horses will attack, but even so, I can’t see him caring enough to do anything about it. The dog wanders the neighborhood for hours at a time; clearly my neighbor isn’t concerned with his safety.

Our animal control out here is absolutely useless; I left a message but doubt I’ll hear anything back. My thoughts are to put up game cameras to gather proof and document anything that happens. But, said neighbor has been in foreclosure for a year; if I sue for vet or medical bills, I’m unlikely to see any money. Plus I don’t want an incident to occur in the first place.

What would you do? I don’t have the thousands of dollars it would cost to put up a perimeter fence. Adding another line to my existing fence will also cost a bunch, and given the shocking issue mentioned above, I don’t think that it would stop the dog. I’ve been looking at electric dog whistles and things but have a hard time believing they’ll work. Any thoughts or suggestions?

Honestly, I’d grab the dog and drop it off at a good animal shelter a few counties away.

Tagging it with a paintball gun is another option. Or a super soaker filled with skunk scent.

43 Likes

This is very much a rock/hard place situation.

The poor dog, being owned by such an idiot.

The level of stupidity is over the top. Who freaking thinks it is OK to let their kids ruin the lawn of their neighbor?

I am giggling way too hard at the advice to use a super soaker with skunk scent. I did not know you could buy skunk scent, but that idea sounds so fun. The problem is, this owner would likely not notice since they clearly just let their dog roam free.

Paintball gun stings too, so that might deter the dog from hanging around.

If the dog is chasing your livestock, there is always SSS.

16 Likes

I plan to call the police to come get the dog if I can catch it. Going off to search out where to buy skunk scent for a super soaker!

2 Likes

Yes, it’s an absurd situation, and I feel bad for the dog. I don’t want to SSS because this isn’t the dog’s fault and I don’t think it’s actually aggressive, more wanting to play, but still, I have to protect my horses. A paintball gun is an interesting option.

4 Likes

If your animal control peeps are useless, this probably won’t accomplish anything & will tip your hand to the neighbor. If the dog just… disappears, it’s a lot easier to feign ignorance.

Making friends with the dog & putting some training in is another way to go. No, you shouldn’t have to do that at all, but if he can learn NO, come, down, and stay, your life probably gets a lot easier. So maybe it’s worth the effort.

6 Likes

I have been through this unfortunately. This is really the only solution other than a perimeter fence. And its probably temporary until the idiot finds another puppy.

Don’t waste your time with animal control/police.

In my state a dog chasing livestock on your property is a valid reason to “dispatch” them, but I could never do it.

15 Likes

we just got a bigger dig, had a huge German Shepherd Dog that was said to have been 1/4 wolf (140# plus), he kept any and everything that was not supposed to be here away.

Currently have a Great Pyrenees who is the watch dog of watch dogs with a powerful bite force, with estimates ranging from 280 to 500 PSI. Nothing that she thinks is of ill nature is overlooked. (be aware the things BARK a lot and Often )

5 Likes

Same. Won’t stop the other neighbor behaviors, and won’t stop him getting another puppy, but at a certain point…

Maybe donate to the shelter while you’re there, or sponsor the pup. Usually it’s pretty cheap.

3 Likes

How is a dog going to solve her problem? She doesn’t have the money to put up dog proof fencing, so is she just going to let her dog run loose too? It would be cheaper where I am to buy fencing than to buy a dog and pay its bills for its training/vet bills/food etc for a lifetime.

11 Likes

Super soaker with deer urine.

Or a string of low set hot wire works.

My neighbors dog comes in my yard all the time, I usually hit him with the hose. I like my neighbors, they just don’t watch their dog.

3 Likes

Pump pellet gun. Excellent long range training tool for dogs and horses. Non-lethal, neighborhood friendly, more pumps equals more sting. They come in wide selection of neon colors. Explain and show free-range dog owner. Otherwise your mare will GET that puppy - its a matter of time.

7 Likes

But you could take an eye out and if these owners are this negligent the dog could not receive medical treatment.

I’d load up the dog and drop it off at animal control. Either it gets claimed or a few rounds of having to pick up and the owner will change their behavior.

5 Likes

I’d probably take the dog. Next best would probably be some electric wire, baited with bacon. If he can’t see your house and immediate yard from his I might even just keep the dog :laughing: Or at least for a couple weeks before taking it to the shelter. It’s gonna get hit in the road.

4 Likes

What type of horse field fencing do you have ? And how many acres are we talking about ? I learned a long time ago that if I’m going to have livestock, I have to have some kind of woven wire horse field fence at least 4 feet high. Because there will always be another dog. Or some other predator. All I can do is keep my animals safe. I can’t fix stupid.

8 Likes

I have 5 foot diamond mesh. And dogs dig under. I try to push any downed pine trees up to the fence to discourage digging but even that fails sometimes. Unless you have really flat land it is hard to get the fence flush to the ground. It is good to deter but it is not infallible. Unless you have $$$$ to put concrete on the fence line. And hot wire - I love it but you have to keep the fenceline mowed to keep it from being shorted out. Which I am not doing in the summer sauna. My mantra “It is not my job to keep your dog at home”. If it could be safely done - I would take it to an animal shelter out of the area. Maybe the dog will get a responsible owner. Roaming is not a safe solution for a dog - they get hit by cars, shot, in dog fights. If you love your dog you do not do this.

5 Likes

Yes but you can run a hot wire along the bottom. If you have smooth wire or barbed wire you can’t do that. Round up. That’s why I asked about the size. Because if you were talking about a couple acres? Then you can absolutely fence the threat out. Because there will always be a threat. And it’s our responsibility to take care of that.

3 Likes

I have lived at this farm for over 20 years. At first we were very rural. Then … Florida. And subdivisions. And clueless people. I know people espouse SSS. But there is no part of me that punishes a loose chasing dog for an owners stupidity. And so many of them are stupid AF. Now if I saw a full on attack I would take care of that. But it’s my job to fence the threat out. Which I’ve done. And it certainly is a job. And yes Florida is flat as a pancake. Your experience may vary. Just sharing what I DO

3 Likes

Agreed.
Around here - Ag/Res properties mostly with surrounding SubDs - AC charges the owner to retrieve their loose dog. Higher fee if the dog isn’t tagged.
I had a yellow cur that chased my freerange chickens. Never bothered the horses, but…
Stoopid dog was friendly enough that I could catch him, put him in my car & deliver to AC.
A couple rounds of that & I stopped seeing dog.

ETA:
I also like the idea if getting something nasty on the dog.
May I suggest syrup?
Won’t hurt dog, PITA for owner to get off, especially if dog rolls in something :smiling_imp:

2 Likes

Just don’t accidentally get any skunk scent on yourself - that would be a downer!!