[QUOTE=Bellabeau;8490952]
Thanks - I will read that post. Initially when I started him in this bit, he would take it and stretch down into it when I took up contact so I would soften and reward him for seeking the bit. [/QUOTE]
Maybe he is confused - you first rewarded him for “seeking the bit,” and I understand what you mean, but what you want to reward is progression towards softening and self carriage. Maybe he is confused - he was first rewarded for taking a hold of the bit, now you don’t want him to do that. But he still remembers that reward, so he still keeps trying it. I’d go back and do tons of exercises to help soften his face and teach him to give to bit pressure, from the ground to standing still while mounted to walking etc.
Did you ride English at one time? I did, and it’s a very different experience riding Western for me. I always preferred to have my horse up in the bridle and going forward to the jump, so it took me a while to really “get it” with the Western stuff. If I do indeed “get it.”