In 1977 I bought a mysterious horse, looking for answers now.

I was 30, with a 5 acre piece of ground in Maryland. I had some “free”, old horses and my blacksmith was Charlie Smith who eventually went on to become a national professional reining champion. He knew I wanted a “good” horse, and in December 1977 he brought over a stunning red chestnut mare, clipped and braided, and left her with me. He refused to tell me anything about her, didn’t know her age, no papers, didn’t even know her name. “Trust me” he said. $700. My husband didn’t even know I was getting this horse.

So I tell him no go until my vet looks at her, that’s ok with him. My vet by the way was James Morgan, who eventually went on to become the amateur reining champion.

Its freezing cold, the mare is clipped, and by the time Jim Morgan sees her she is sick, sick, sick, with what we called “shipping fever”.

She went on to recover, I gave Charlie Smith $600 dollars, and for 25 more years I had the best family horse ever. But I never found out anything about her. Dr Morgan who raised quarter horses said he thought she was a foundation QH, with hugh jaws. She had a big white face and four high white stockings above the knee, which in 1977 made her ineligible for registration as a QH, and she could only be registered as a paint. She was also too placid and non-reactive to be a good reining horse, which made her a wonderful family horse.

I met Garvin Tankersley, Jr., through our bank. He had some of his step-mother’s Bazy Tankersley’s Arabians and in 1980 I bred that mare to one of his stallions, and got my dream horse for the next 25 years.

But where did the QH come from? Who clips and braids a horse in December and puts her in a trailer for hours or days? I wondered if he stole her, maybe an auction, maybe a western show in Oklahoma??

I have no answers for you, but I hope someone else does. You’re asking a lot of interesting questions.

1 Like

It sounds as though she needed to “disappear”. Usually that is because someone wants to put down a perfectly good animal for some bizarre reason. Or send them to an auction to get rid of them. Or it is a nasty divorce. Or… I doubt you’ll ever find out unless he is still alive and willing to talk now. Sounds like it was a great deal for you though! I don’t think they did DNA back then, just blood typing. But it probably wouildn’t be searchable that far back even if they did.

2 Likes

I too was thinking death, divorce, or someone got really mad at a delinquent child and followed through on the threat to take away the pony! Or horse was abandoned at a trainers or a payment to the farrier for a debt or he won her in a poker game.

I doubt he stole her

Maybe horse really embarrassed somebody by being lazy at some competition and they wanted her gone.

3 Likes

As you stated, back then a Quarter Horse baby that had too much white (a" crop-out"), was ineligible for registration with AQHA. I’ve been told that some of the Quarter Horse people absolutely did not want it known that their bloodlines were throwing crop-outs and would make these horses “disappear”.

5 Likes

I’d guess a divorce or an estate or family problems or a bankruptcy. Someone has a well-bred show-horse, but can’t keep it (probably for financial reasons), and also doesn’t want the husband to have it, or the creditors to get their hands on it, etc. Horse gets “sold” for a nominal price or given away to a professional who promises to find the horse a good home far away from the previous owner’s home, so that husband or creditors or family members can’t find it.

It’s a great story; you could write a novel or short story with this as the opening “hook.”

3 Likes

I don’t have anything to add or answers to your story but Charlie and Dr Jim are good people. I seriously doubt they were involved in shady business. Charlie has been a wonderful mentor and friend to me. Always a name I look forward to coming up on my phone. He is older now and living in Florida. Perhaps I will ask him about the red mystery mare next time I speak to him.

4 Likes

I actually discovered that Charlie lives about 2 hours north of me in Florida now. I found his email on a reining horse judge website. As soon as I get a photo of the mare downloaded, I am going to email him and see if he will solve the mystery.

7 Likes

Good luck solving your mystery, it is an interesting story!

I wouldn’t be surprised if your mare was related to Mr Gun Smoke, he is a famous reining sire in that era that threw a lot of excessive white.

His line was known for being a little more explosive in temperament, but each horse is an individual so who knows.

https://www.aqha.com/-/mr-gun-smoke

You know, I always heard that some of his pedigree were hot, but every one we had was wonderful to work with and not hot, nervous or uptight at all.

We assumed it was some crosses that may just have not been that good a nick and gave those lines that bad publicity.

Please update if and when you do!

Message me if you would like Charlie’s phone number. He may have been technologically inclined at one point but these days he has his flip phone and calls me when he occasionally needs info off the internet. 🤣

1 Like