I had great luck with marshmallows as bait in the live trap. Cats didn’t go in to eat the food and get caught. Our live trap is covered on the outside with hardcloth wire wired on, so coons can’t reach out and do other damage. Before that hardcloth wire addition, one we caught just tore the feed room apart grabbing things and throwing them around. Even metal grain cans!!
We kill whatever gets caught in the traps, otherwise you are just moving problems to someone else’s place! Could also be spreading disease if animal is a carrier. I do NOT appreciate someone dumping their problem animals around here, so I don’t do that to others. There are PLENTY of animals living around here in their own territories, don’t need new ones. And the ones who don’t come in the barn do fine, not a problem to me. Luckily there is usually only 1-2 animals in a year to deal with. Some years there are none, even better!
My friend dumped what she caught in her live trap, and they were back in short order. I couldn’t believe how MANY she was catching and asked her if they were returnees. She was sure they were not, but then put some paint on the tails before release. Sure enough, even going 10 miles to dump them, they ALL came back. So no more Mrs. Nice Person, she killed them and still does when she catches one causing problems. Her birds are a terrible attraction to varmints of all sorts. Even worse since she lost her big dog and hasn’t gotten another one.
I will do what it takes to get varmints removed on the first try. They learn and are usually harder to catch a second time. I don’t do poison, but catching and permanent removal has done the job for us.
I close up the barn at night, horses are outside in summer, too cold to leave doors open in winter, which seems to help some. Cat food out is only enough for them to clean it up while I do chores. Not a temptation coming inside. Varmints are not tolerated in the barns. They have caused damage, carry diseases, killed my cats, so they are not welcome at all. Plenty of nice outside habitat for them to manage and find food in.
I don’t have domestic birds, so no temptation there for them.