Lawsuit filed re: death of jumper near Aiken

Posted by Despina Pakidas on the Aiken Area Equstrian Page. She said folks could share via screen shots so I feel okay copying and pasting here.

https://www.facebook.com/share/p/18eWNMEr7Z/?mibextid=wwXIfr

“With the recent settlement of the Cobain vs Shannon Eckel case and the new light being shown through various social media platforms such as tik tok and Facebook, I thought it was time to share my side of the story. While being a minor I wasn’t able to share what could’ve been crucial evidence but I want to put the truth out there now. From the ages of 14-15 I worked for Shannon Eckel of Hat Trick Sporthorses as a working student in exchange for the occasional lesson and what was supposed to be a good learning experience. I endured verbal abuse and In my time there I saw more than one case of un kind behavior pointed towards the horse, clients and her personal. Cobain, was left in his stall almost 24/7 because Shannon felt he didn’t deserve time out when he started walking the fence line. The stall he lived in for the majority of his time spent with her was bedded with un cleanly straw. Shannon often tied him as a punishment for circling his stall causing it to be more messy. Shannon decided to switch Cobains main discipline from the jumper to barrel racing without notifying his owners. On the morning of the despicable incident Shannon was attempting to load Cobain to go to a barrel race, not a show where he would be asked to do the .90s like she had stated in a comment. When Cobain refused to load she tied his head to the highest bar as punishment like she did often. No employees were notified to keep an eye on Cobain, Shannon Eckel left that poor soul there and went on with her day. There is no excuse for the kind of human she is and her actions. On another occasion with a clients horse named Sherlock, she chased him with a four wheeler as an attempt to run him when he wouldn’t let her catch him. After Sherlock attempted to get away by jumping a fence he had impaled the side of his stomach where the girth would go with part of the wood fence. Shannon refused to call a vet. Sherlock was terrified of Shannon, whimpering to the back of his stall every time she walked in. Another punishment method of Shannon’s was to tie horses to her aluminum trailer for hours on end in the blazing SC sun. Shannon often overworked the horses as an attempt to end the ride on a “perfect note” - an example of this is when she was taking a sale video of a horse named “Mile High Club” where she jumped him for an hour straight, cold hosing in between sessions so he wouldn’t heat stroke but never did she decide she was satisfied with the ride. She instead replaced her jump poles with 4x4 boards so the horse would lift up his feet more for a more exaggerated jump look. Shannon is a despicable human who should never be aloud horses again. If me speaking out gets any sort of justice for Cobain, Sherlock, Mile high or any other horse that has been or may be in Shannon’s care then I want everyone to hear my voice. RIP Cobain, gone but not forgotten”

15 Likes

Dear God in Heaven……

5 Likes

I think I know that woman. Did she used to live in Washington? I observed a woman doing almost the same thing.

She used to live in New Jersey.

Rope halters are wonderful because they don’t break. That’s why you carry a pocket knife. Nothing wrong with tying unsupervised - as long as the horse is taught to tie. Stop with the gross over statements.

4 Likes

A horse should never be left tied unsupervised no matter what kind of halter it is.
Interesting, showing up to defend this [edit]

24 Likes

Large blanket statements really help no one. (I think that was the point.)

I don’t know about you, but sometimes when I am riding I have to stop and pee, so I tied my horse (appropriately) and do that, or I have to go to the registration desk at a show while my horse munches hay at the trailer. Technically my horse is tied unsupervised in both those situations.

I do not think either of those make me (or others like me) a bad horse owner.

On the actual thread topic - It is sad that this trainer is still out there handling horses.

9 Likes

I would think the norm would be at show when you have to run out to pee etc there are other people around them to see the horse should he get in trouble. I don’t know how long it takes you to pee, but it doesn’t take me very long. I can run over to the port a John or into my trailer or into my stall and take care of business fairly quickly. I don’t think that was the case here in this situation at all. This horse was tied and left for a very extended period of time as punishment. That’s not appropriate ever I don’t care who it is.

15 Likes

You did not say in this situation, you said a horse should never be left tied unattended.

I agree, how this horse was handled was VERY wrong.

5 Likes

Oh dear sweet lord. Get some flea shampoo for those nits you’re picking.

6 Likes

The problem with tying a horse in a rope halter that doesn’t break and leaving it unsupervised, is that you won’t be around to use that pocket knife if the horse gets into trouble.

21 Likes

Its not the tying that’s the problem. My friends barrel horses stand tied all night to her trailer, unsupervised, in rope halters at a race, it’s no big deal. English disciplines are the ones who don’t think Pookie can be left alone for a minute unsupervised while tied. … This despicable woman on the other hand tied this horse HIGH & TIGHT as punishment then left!

18 Likes

This got shared to my regional horse group on fb, which I then screenshotted and promptly sent to DH who is in Aiken the next 2 weeks training.

This is disgusting.

1 Like

I am not defending this disgusting person AT ALL. But leaving a horse tied in a normal fashion is not cruel. I did breed shows as a teen. We generally had 5 with us, and they spent give or take 8 hours either showing or tied. Including a foal every year, to no ill effect. They had hay nets and water, and were perfectly fine. They were not closely supervised, either, although there was enough activity nearby that someone would see if something happened.

Zippering flame suit now.

18 Likes

I did a breed circult for a while, and left, one reason being this kind of tying. They literally called it “hanging the horses”. They wanted the horses neck so stiff that all the horse would want to do it hold it low for their under saddle classes. Disgusting.

I read enough unsettling stuff in the daily news. I don’t want to read all these comments, so please don’t tell me there are people defending this. It is not just “tying”.

14 Likes

This^^^ over and over. It’s not.

Edited to add what happened to the horse who was tied out of anger is not tying. I don’t know about breed shows as referenced above.

8 Likes

I am not talking about “this kind of tying” I am talking, literally, about a nice safe loop in the lead rope. Not long enough that they could get a foot over it, but not restraining their heads at ALL. Just normal horses tied to the outside of the trailer. No doubt they were bored, but in no other way was this harmful. And, as they learned it at ~6 months, none of them were fretful.

10 Likes

my understanding from reading the article and another I saw linked on FB is that the horse wouldn’t get in the trailer so they left it home, tied in the stall, alone for several hours with no one checking on him, while the trainer left with other horses and went to a horse show. Very different from standing tied at a horse show for several hours with their friends, haynets and people in the general vicinity all day.

One account I read said he broke his jaw and severed his spinal cord fighting against the halter/tying.

2 Likes

Yes, I was responding to some comments that a horse can never be left tied for any reason. I think that is ridiculous.

10 Likes

You do realize this is someone who advertises herself as a jumper trainer right? Not a breed show person. Regardless of who does it, it’s disgusting.

5 Likes