I LOVE the detangler. It doesn’t leave a film and lasts quite a few days before you need to reapply (smells nice too). I also have the spray on conditioner that comes with the two bottles. Haven’t used to smaller bottle because it calls for a LOT of the conditioner; the larger bottle uses a small amount with water. Probably won’t repurchase the conditioner when it runs out since my pony doesn’t have any coat or skin issues… He has a very very long white mane and darker forelock and the detangler is effective with just a tiny amount. It also keeps his mane white, and he lives outside 24/7 in a dirt/mud/poop field.
I had a small sample of Cowboy Magic that I was using up on my pony’s tail and had excess on my hands so I smoothed it on my short/buzzcut hair. ICK!! It made my hair so sticky and gunky.
In almost 50 years of being around horses I have never purchased Show Sheen. It feels like Armor All and all that silicone can’t be good for any type of hair. Manely Detangler doesn’t leave that slickness.