Manure Spreaders

Hello all,

Excited, proud owner of a new farm here! We are working on rehabbing the pastures (they are fine, but being picky not great - not loved for many years, so weeds want to overtake grass, but they are big and have potential - we are working on fertilizer/lime/rotation solution), but we also are looking to see what other people like best for a manure spreader. We would not be a high output barn…most of ours are either 24/7 out with a small bunch in 12/12. Given a handful of horses while also wanting to maintain a modest manure compost pit, we won’t have a ton. We also have farming neighbors who would like our manure when our fields don’t need it…so we can spread off property. We are approximately 8 horses / 12 acres. We have a compact tractor.

I’ve so far gotten a lot of folks who like Millcreek. I was looking at the 57 and the 77 models, but leaning towards the 77 with our 8 horses pushing the limits of the 57.

I was also looking at ABI, which I got to via the John Deere website (our tractor is a JD, so I went looking for compatible spreaders).

I would love to hear your thoughts, experiences, preferences, etc!

Many thanks!

I started a fairly recent thread about an ABI spreader. Might be worth a read. Google is your friend because you can find out all kinds of information about various models.

I can’t imagine not getting one that’s PTO driven–especially if you want a pile for composting. Ground driven will only “unload” when in motion.

@debug I would highly recommend checking out the ABI spreaders. We have a 65cu and just love it!
We compared a lot and their biggest competitor was Millcreek. We found that when we actually compared apples to apples on the ABI vs Millcreek, you got A LOT more bang for your buck with the ABI spreader.

We wanted something that was low maintenance and would last a really long time especially knowing how corrosive urine & manure are. The ABI spreader appears to cover all the bases and it is built like a tank but easy enough to move it by hand down the barn aisle.

Have fun shopping & good luck!!

PSA… I also work for ABI as the equine market manager

1 Like

@lkweber–Not stating up front that you work for the company is kinda sketchy.

@debug–searching here and on the google is never a bad plan. Here’s my thread about a miserable experience with
ABI. Clearly not everyone had a bad experience, but there’s no amount of money on earth that would make me buy one in the future. YMMV.

2 Likes

I was an owner of the spreader before I ever started working here. I would of loved to get a little discount had I known I would be working there in the future. Doesn’t mean I don’t still love it.

I made the choice to work for them because they are an awesome company who makes awesome products. By the way, the issues that your barn owners had with the spreader can easily be remedied and it wasn’t directly with our customer service, you just got dealt some maintenance issues that are never fun to deal with. I get it.

My opinion, having used both, Millcreek and ABI, the 57, smaller ground driven ones, the first one is made lighter, which means easier to move around by hand, like in a barn aisle or to hook up.
ABI is made with stronger metal, will last longer and take more abuse of rougher handling and bouncing around uneven ground, but also you won’t be moving it by hand very much, too heavy.

Now, for the bigger spreaders, I would say it makes more sense to get PTO and the heavier one, as it will be used harder, with heavier loads.

My problem with PTO is that, unless you leave yours attached to the tractor for regular use, or don’t have to attach it most days, that PTO stuff gets old, is so unhandy to hook up all the time.
That is why we went with a smaller one and ground driven, if necessary making more trips, rather than a big spreader that takes a tractor to use it.
The 57 you can pull easily even with a mowing tractor, or 4 wheeler, we use an UTV gator and hook and unhook it easily.

If you don’t have to spread, just dump in a compost pile, the tractor loader should be fine, muck into it and drive it to dump, as many times as it takes.
Or get a dump wagon to clean into and dump in the pile.
That dump wagon can work fine for all other that needs hauling and dumping dirt in low spots, etc.

I am sure that, whatever you decide, you will find a way to make it work for you.

It would save you a tremendous amount of time if you spread directly and did not compost first, especially if you use Sanicare bedding or at worst, a pelleted pine. There is a lot of wrong information about having to compost before you spread. I add lime as well as fertilizer when I muck into my spreader, which saves me from having to lime and fertilize as well.

https://ohioline.osu.edu/factsheet/AGF-212

Otherwise you are mucking, dumping, turning, loading into the spreader, spreading, and then also liming and fertilizing when you could just spread once directly onto the pasture once the spreader is full.

Another vote for ABI. Mine is small but mighty–it really flings the manure and breaks it up. I had to call them yesterday about a stiff lever, and their customer service was great. Told me exactly where the grease fitting I had missed was.

Reason 1,001 why I love COTH. In 20+ years of being around horses this is literally the first time I have heard about this option. Perhaps not the right fit for everyone but this sound amazing if you have the space to rotate fields after spreading fresh manure.

1 Like

I have posted before that for long time and some times still now I spread directly from the FEL on the tractor, driving along and letting it dribble out in the pastures.
It has never clumped so it burned the grass or caused weeds to grow anywhere, works fine, but a spreader is definitely better as it produces a more consistent coverage.

You don’t even need to rotate fields - unless you are one of those crazy people with lots of time who pick manure out of their fields daily. But yes, I usually spread in a field that is resting.

Spreading directly onto a field give many unmentioned benefits to the soil of the bulky organic matter of stall bedding, which would be much reduced in quantity, bulk, with composting. My clay soil needs lots of organic matter to make soil more absorbent, fertile, a good home to the micro animals that live in soil working for you. Spreading compost is helpful, but I don’t feel as helpful as just spreading the manure itself on acreage. We use a woody fibre bedding, which will take time to break down into dirt. While still woody, it covers dirt with many helpful results, acting as a mulch to absorb water, prevent dirt drying out as quickly so plants have even moisture, roots are not sunburned in heat. Helps prevent erosion In heavy rains, preventing water sheeting off as it drains away. This use of bedding spread directly also helps other soil types be better soil in using the organic matter, not just clay. Got this from our local College, Michigan State, for pasture improvement. Farmers are getting back into grazing for livestock, saves money, is healthier, cheaper as a feeding plan.

I do fertilize yearly after soil testing, the soil nitrogen stays busy breaking down woody things but never is really “gone or used up” as folks claim. Nitrogen is just not available all to the plants NOW, so more needs to be applied for the green plants. My pastures have improved incredibly, we have nicer soil now, with the use of daily spreading of stall bedding on the pastures. Other improved pasture keeping methods like regular mowing grass high, better rotation of horses, also keep pastures in good shape.

We have a larger, not big or huge, PTO driven spreader for manure handling. I had a ground drive spreader as our first one, would never go back to ground drive and the distances needed to drive to fully empty it!! We live in snow country, want that emptied ASAP on wintery days! I feel like I have better options with the PTO, dump in a pile if ground is too wet, snow too deep to get to the pasture for spreading. The one small tractor is 90% used to run the spreader, stays hooked up most of the time. I do not find it a problem to unhook when I need tractor for mowing or dragging, then rehook the spreader which gets used daily. The spreader tractor is a Ford 8N or 9N. We have had several tractors this size over the years. Fairly cheap locally, easy to repair youself until you don’t want to, then replace it with another like it. Sell the worse running one. We are a smaller place, all horses are our own. This Ford worked great until kids left and I had to do my own stalls! Told husband I needed a tractor with a FEL to move sawdust, was not going to be bedding stalls with shoveled bedding. So we got a second tractor with loader, a nice older Kybota. I love it! Feel like I hit the lottery driving it.

We also use the empty spreader for moving branches, fence trimmings, other loads, around the place. I collect raked leaves into it in spring, which also get spread on the fields for their organic matter addition to the soil. Have to say loading, then dumping the leaves is sure easy with the spreader! Never realized how many leaves we had before I collected them, but I got five full spreader loads this last spring. Rake onto a tarp, dump into spreader, makes leaf removal go fast. We have hickory and oaks, no maple trees, so they are fine on pastures. Spreader sure comes in handy for a number of uses. Trying to keep extra trailers, implements, things down because of restricted parking space. Need to sell some stuff, get the space back again.

I seriously HATE my ABI elite. I wanted a ground driven spreader that dumps manure out the bottom, which it does. However it is corroding and I am sure it will soon be worthless and it can’t happen soon enough. I want my Newer Spreader back.

1 Like