<BLOCKQUOTE class=“ip-ubbcode-quote”><font size="-1">quote:</font><HR>Originally posted by Heather:
I refrained from replying to this thread, becasue (disclaimer) my hubsand and I consider Denny and May to be good friends, so I’ll admit to some bias on the topic.
This is hardly the first time it’s come up, and I’m constantly surprised by the thinly veiled jabs at Denny and May that appear. <HR></BLOCKQUOTE>
and unfortunately Heather, your bias came through overly loud and clear in your post. Too much so I’m afraid. I always enjoy your posts very much, but I can’t help feeling that you have been blinded by your friendship on this one.
I have read this thread with great interest as I am a sporthorse breeding nut, and my overall opinion is that it has been a super thread and in no way coloured with snide, attacking or veiled insults. There are always negative points to every stallion, and the ones that were written here about the Emerson studs were in my opinion clinical rather then emotional. What is wrong with an observer saying what they didn’t like about a stud’s conformation/temperment vs. their mares? That is part of making a breeding decision.
and nothing drives me more nuts than someone claiming that their stallion or any stallion is PERFECT and the RIGHT choice for EVERY mare, because that is ludicrous.
Which brings me to the other point that has been brought up about the “evils” of using an European stallion vs. an American bred one. I think it is far more important to find the good match for your mare rather then worry about whether you are supporting the area where you live - sure the Emerson studs are lovely, but if they are not a good match for your mare, there is no point in breeding to them. Just because they’re not right for one mare doesn’t mean they are suddenly being trashed as bad stallions 
<BLOCKQUOTE class=“ip-ubbcode-quote”><font size="-1">quote:</font><HR> originally posted by Rebecca: Yes, there actually are some of us left in this warmblood loving country, and if people who dislike the Thoroughbred want to do so, fine for them. They dont have to be so petty that they smear a good horse publically in print, though. And I would love to hear how their qualifications as horsemen stack up against Mark Todd and the O
Connors?
How many gold medals do they have?<HR></BLOCKQUOTE>
Rebecca, get a grip. Why does this always come down to tb vs. warmblood? Nobody until YOU even brought that up! And again, there was nothing posted here that could ever be called a smear on the horses.
Frankly it annoys me that posters like JER et al are being attacked for making a sound breeding decision for their mare just because they didn’t use a local TB stud. That is so stupid 