To me, the fact that outside players are stepping in to censure riders is evidence that perceptions of abuse or cruelty are becoming a threat to the sport and the sport needs to evolve. (See: modern pentathlon debacle, Mark Todd debacle, etc.)
It doesnât really matter if Fuchs was pissed off or not. It doesnât matter if the horse was about to go up and over or just blowing through his aids. 99% of people canât tell. The people on this board canât even tell. Put aside everything you know about horses: what would a random person in the grocery store think if they watched this video? To them, it just looks like some guy in a silly outfit beating an animal. The context and the details donât matter to them. If you say âWell, itâs a dangerous situationâ theyâll say, âCanât the rider just stop, why does he have to keep jumping?â And if you say âWell, then youâre teaching the horse it can get away with bad behavior,â theyâll say âIf heâs the best rider in the world, canât he find a different way to teach it to behave better?â Both great questions.
These riders need to understand that they are being filmed and watched at all times⊠including by people who do not understand the sport or horses. Itâs not like it was 15 or 20 years ago. You cannot lose your temper. You just cannot âwhack a horse upside the headâ in public at a major competition anymore. (See: debacle about outrider correcting Rich Strike post-Derby.)
These top riders can basically get any horse over any fence and FEI gives them plenty of leeway about how to do so. It doesnât mean that they SHOULD. At some point the bigger goal of the public perception of the sport is going to have to be more important than riderâs day-to-day competition and training goals. If riders feel the need/desire to correct the horse in a way that could lead to animal abuse investigations⊠time to retire and say it wasnât your day. If doing so ruins the horse, maybe thatâs part of the cost of doing business now, and a reason to look at your program and ask yourself how you ended up in this situation.
I see Kevin Lemke a lot at shows in my area. In the grand scheme of the horse world, dude is a nobody⊠but if his name seems familiar, itâs because he beat the snot out of a horse at Thermal last winter and it blew up on Youtube and PETA jumped all over it. Go read the comments on the videos of these incidents and people are calling for jail time for the riders, not just a little USEF suspension and fine. It seems extreme to us because weâve normalized hitting horses but that is a real sentiment that is floating around.
I get so nervous about something like this happening at the Olympics. At least with pentathlon the equestrian community had a credible out that these people werenât âreal riders.â If a top show jumper is in Paris and the horse starts acting up and the rider feels himself losing his temper⊠is he going to think, âI am on the world stage, hitting my horse twice on the shoulder could become a major PR incidentâ or is he going to go on competitive autopilot and whack the horse? I work in marketing so maybe thatâs why I feel like this but⊠we live in a world where we are always, always being watched and judged. Optics are everything. And the OPTICS of these incidents are terrible, even if the rider made the correct choice in the moment from a horse training perspective.