I just bought a pair of the Fiorentinas that I will be returning. Stylistically, they are gorgeous. Super high spanish top, and I love the no laces look. Leather seems durable (not super soft, but also not like cardboard) and the boot is well constructed for something that costs around $200.
Sadly, the fit was just plain wonky on me. Footbed was extremely roomy. I wear a pretty standard 9 in most brands, and it was too big for me. The ankle was also not very slim fitting, which disappointed me but then again I have SUPER small ankles. I also fell somewhere in the middle of the measurements for the calf, so the boots were pretty easy to zip. I imagine if I were to keep them, they might be too big so that is another area I would want to go down a size on.
Overall, if you can fit into off the rack boots I think its a good, inexpensive choice.