Ladies I am an outlier here, I never got into competing. I never got into dressage. I did jump 3ā6" for many years, but back then adults were expected to be able to jump 4ā since that is where the open jumping started at. I just never had your type of goals for my riding.
As a handicapped, crippled riderāI greatly prefer riding Arabians. I can go up to an Arabian I will start riding, explain to the Arabian exactly what my handicap is, how much of a klutz I am in the saddle, how I will drop a rein accidentally occasionally and anything else I can think of. I end all this with a solemn promise that I will do everything I can to avoid hurting his mouth.
Arabians are small. Arabians have been bred for centuries to be RIDING HORSES, and that is all they were bred to do. If you need a bigger horse there are Thoroughbreds, if you donāt like Thoroughbreds there are American Saddle Bred horses, both breeds of horses excel at being RIDING HORSES. Quarter horses also qualify and the better ones have a good bit of modern TB blood in them to make them better riding horses.
Carriage horses and draft horses were NOT bred to be riding horses, and that is the root cause of a lot of modern riding problems with the āwarm bloodsā. Their gaits and their movement were NOT bred in to become good riding horses, they were bred in to make super flashy carriage horses, pulling a good bit of weight up and down hills when needed, or really strong draft horses who could pull tons of weight. They can be really good horses, for that purpose, pulling vehicles. (I will give a pass for Trakheners (sp?), depending on the individual horse.)
If you canāt find what you want in this country there are numerous Barb descended breeds, especially in the Iberian Peninsula who were also bred to be riding horses.
I know my limitations in the saddle. I want to ride RIDING HORSES, of a reasonable size (13.2-15.2 hands high), whose gaits were bred in to be comfortable riding gaits first, with a few breeding lines going into high stepping (ASB) but still comfortable for the rider.
That will no longer win at dressage nowadays. That is a great pity, since dressage was developed to improve RIDING HORSES. Now it seems to me to be more to enable a rider to control a carriage horse, with big gaits.
And yes, I know all the warm blood breeds have lots and lots and lots of TB and Arabian blood in their pedigrees, but they rewarded and bred on the taller horses who mostly have the super impressive carriage horse gaits, not the more energy conserving TB and Arab movement. This can make them harder to ride and control.
IF you are crippled, handicapped, whatever, you will do much, much better riding a horse of a breed who was developed first and foremost as a superior riding horse, one that does not tire you out riding their natural gaits, one who is conformed to be responsive to the reins and all the other aids we use.
IF I ever buy another riding horse it will be a purebreed Arabian, to me nothing else measures up for my particular needs. A horse who has been bred for centuries to be a comfortable riding horse, who if they like their rider will ACTIVELY work to take care of you if your body all of a sudden stops working.
Debbie first put me on this Arabian gelding who was definitely too much horse for beginning riders. He would bolt, he would carry his rider off to the gate, and he demanded, absolutely demanded riding that suited his build as a riding horse. He was a very spirited horse.
I explained to this Arab ALL my physical difficulties (along with the promise to never hurt his mouth) and he forgave me all my extensive riding faults. If he felt me get unsteady in the saddle he would do his best to fix that, If my arm or leg stopped working properly he merely adapted his movement to my current abilities. If I dropped a reināno problems. When my body worked properly he could do everything I asked him to do. I LOVED riding that horse!
I am sure that there are horses like that in other riding horse breeds, I advocate the Arabian because it is much more likely to be that way with me, an experienced rider who sometimes rides worse than any beginner. The Arabs seem to UNDERSTAND at a deep level that sometimes I just cannot ride properly, and are willing to make adjustments to my body which can change from week to week, and sometimes minute to minute.
Get yourself a smaller horse of a breed that has always been bred for riding. You might add decades to your riding career even though you will have little hope of ever beating a warm blood behemoth in the show ring.
These horses, the small riding horses, can be a lot of FUN to ride.
Sorry for the lecture, but warm bloods were not developed to take care of their riders (there are exceptions of course) or for comfortable walks, trots and gallops, they were developed to look really impressive with high stepping impulsive gaits suitable for pulling a carriage in the park where you want to impress other people, and often nobody ever rode them.