need to replace my manure spreader--Suggestions/comments??? HELP!!

My 1951 John Deere model L has finally bit the dust!!–My husband is not mechanical at all and I have to hire someone everytime a link in the chain breaks etc. The Axle is out of allignment and it has cause numerous problems that have been “patched” over the years.

I have looked at the Ab Instruments one, the Pequea, and the one John Deere sells (a repaint of another brand-can’t remember)–I have seen them on line but none in person.

I have 4 horses stalled at night but I don’t want to pull it more than twice a week so it needs to be around 70 bussel or so. I can either go ground driven or PTO. What do you have and what do you like or dislike about it.

HELP

I shopped used spreaders, got a nice older one for $1500. It was in working condition. but husband did paint it to cover the old metal with a layer of protection before using it. Had it now about 6 months and it has done a great job for me. Husband located it parked with a For Sale sign, on a country road. He even dickered the guy down some in the price!

We had been hunting on Craigslist and he was keeping an eye out on his daily drives. Just were kind of overpriced and worn out in many cases.

Husband had “put in his time” keeping our old JD spreader patched together over the years, but had reached the limit of his patience when he started shopping for another old spreader.

You might want to look at fixing things yourself, is not really hard on a spreader if the gearing pieces work. We put on new bars as they wore out, enough new links that chains were replaced at least twice over the years we owned it. Had almost a new chain and bar set when we sold it. One of the gears wearing out on the old spreader is what made us choose to buy another spreader. That ONE gear would cost $900 to replace. More than half of the cost of the replacement spreader!!

Do consider SELLING your old spreader and be honest when listing it. I sold our old one on Craigslist, but said it was for parts or use as a wagon. Had good tires, a good wooden floor. Got a number of calls on it. Ended up with a man buying it for over $300 for the parts and he planned to sell it on as a wagon after he took the parts off to fix HIS old spreader! He was very happy to get it, thought the price was OK. I was happy with the money, it was gone from here!

Are you shopping for a new spreader? Tractor and equipment dealers might be a good place to search for used spreaders.

I just don’t leave the spreader loaded because the urine and manure will really eat the chain, walls, and kill the metal in short order. Wood floors, even treated wood, doesn’t last very long if you keep manure in there for days. And in this cold, you risk the load freezing hard around the bars and chain, so they are easy to break when you turn on the PTO. Then you have to shovel and fork out the frozen load by hand, before you can attempt to fix the chain. I don’t LIKE dumping daily in bad weather, but to save money on replacement parts, problems later (ALWAYS in the coldest, worst weather), broken machinery, I do daily spreading anyway.

If you don’t want to spread daily, you could have a manure pile and spread every so many months, a few loads one afternoon generally should do it.

You can’t find hardly any manure spreaders around here, only the big truck commercial ones.

Here, you have to order from far away for one.

Where r u located Bluey? I want to sell my new one because I really need a larger one. In Dec 014 I could not for the life of me find one on Craigslist/sitting on roadside to buy that was not a ruined piece of crap. The one I purchased is great and gets the job done and now there are 2 bigger ones in great shape on craigslist but I cannot buy until I sell this one or have a sudden wind fall of $1000 check ur PM

[QUOTE=nashfad;8040184]
Where r u located Bluey? I want to sell my new one because I really need a larger one. In Dec 014 I could not for the life of me find one on Craigslist/sitting on roadside to buy that was not a ruined piece of crap. The one I purchased is great and gets the job done and now there are 2 bigger ones in great shape on craigslist but I cannot buy until I sell this one or have a sudden wind fall of $1000 check ur PM[/QUOTE]

I am in the TX panhandle, iced over, 20F and spitting snow pellets right now.

Try advertising yours where you are, hardware, feed stores, vet clinics, horse barns, local papers, Craiglist.

I would not know where you are what the market is to sell one and right now, if your weather is like ours, no one is out there driving around if they don’t need to.

A bit later would be a better time, I think, to attract buyers for farm equipment.

[QUOTE=krfarms;8037938]
My 1951 John Deere model L has finally bit the dust!!–My husband is not mechanical at all and I have to hire someone everytime a link in the chain breaks etc. The Axle is out of allignment and it has cause numerous problems that have been “patched” over the years.

I have looked at the Ab Instruments one, the Pequea, and the one John Deere sells (a repaint of another brand-can’t remember)–I have seen them on line but none in person.

I have 4 horses stalled at night but I don’t want to pull it more than twice a week so it needs to be around 70 bussel or so. I can either go ground driven or PTO. What do you have and what do you like or dislike about it.

HELP[/QUOTE]

OP, taking into consideration the factors you’ve mentioned here, Millcreek spreaders have several advantages that would suit you very well.

  1. Low maintenance: Millcreek spreaders are the only ones on the market with sealed bearings. They require no greasing whatsoever. Just squirt a little WD-40 on the chains every couple months and you’re good to go - you could handle that yourself! :wink: They also have superior engineering, but if something should happen to go wrong knowledgeable customer service and parts are just a phone call/email away. This is not the case with all spreader manufacturers.

  2. Manure storage (i.e. only spreading every few days): Millcreek offers the Deluxe option which means the spreaders comes with Rhino lining, a urethane spray-on coating on the body. If you’re going leave manure in the spreader you will definitely want this coating or the body will eventually rust. The floorboards are poly, by the way, and warranted for the life of the spreader.

Now, if you want the ultimate in a spreader that’s going to last, and that’s specifically designed for those who only want to spread every few days, Millcreek is the only company making stainless steel models. These are the only ones available warranted against BODY rust-through for life (along with the floorboards).

  1. Ground-drive vs. PTO: I encourage you to watch this video which addresses the pros and cons of both. It’s a very common question! http://bit.ly/MCGroundvPTO

Not sure where you’re located but Millcreek now has FREE SHIPPING east of the Rockies. Hope this is helpful!

I have had a NewerSpreader for over 10 years and really liked it but the newly retired Mr P did not so now we have an ABI elite.

I have not decided if I will sell the NewerSpreader.