New Horse Not Adjusting Well

So I brought home my first horse last Friday (Nov 30th). She’s a 17 y/o QH and she was at her previous home for 13 years, very calm and sweet, wants to run back home on the trail but I’d say that’s her only vice. Her old stall had a small turnout and she lived with one other horse and two minis. I was expecting a long adjustment period considering that she was at her previous home for so long, and going from a private backyard home to a large commercial barn, but we’ve run into a few bumps.

First day she’s here, we put her into a 12x24 pipe stall with neighbors on both sides. She seemed relaxed enough and got along okay with her neighbors, and by the third day she was eating all of her food and drinking well (she thought bermuda was gross at first but now accepts it, haha). Fourth day comes around and her neighbor is taken out for a ride, she paces back and forth and calls for the neighbor for hours, and doesn’t eat her breakfast because she is so anxious. That, combined with her stall becoming a mud pit from the recent rain, prompts me to move her to a barn stall.

First night in the barn stall, wouldn’t follow me into the stall and seems afraid, won’t eat or drink, paces back and forth for hours and works up a sweat. Long story short, after calling the vet and talking to my old trainer and getting some tips from both, she’s eating well and drinking again, and is calmer. Follows me into the stall and watches what she can from behind the bars (barn stalls have windows but aren’t allowed to keep them open for long). Rolls and runs around when I turn her out, then just paces back and forth in the direction of that neighbor she loves so much. Here’s my problem:

I don’t know if I should keep her in the current barn stall, or move her back outside to a different pipe stall. Her old owner says that she’s a busybody and that she’s very social and loves to observe, which I can tell. She seems upset that she can’t see past the barn stall walls or say hi to any other horses. So I have the option to move her to a different section of pipe stalls, not close to the neighbor she got too attached to. She might be happier up there since she isn’t isolated and this one neighbor that she got too attached to may have just been that certain horse. On the other hand, she may just latch onto her neighbor no matter who it is because she’s anxious, in which case it might be better to keep her in the barn stall even though she seemed happier outside. I’ve always been of the mindset that outside with neighbors is the most natural, but the separation anxiety is upsetting for both her and myself. It’s apparent that it’s going to take a lot of time for her to be back to her normal self, and I just want to make the adjustment period as easy as possible for both of us.

BTW, I’ve gotten advice from old owner, old trainer, new barn manager, other boarders, and everyone is saying different things for different reasons. So I guess my solution is adding more opinions into the mix :sigh: haha, please help!

First off take a deep breath. It takes at least 3 to 4 weeks before a horse gets settled into a new place. My husband use to be in the military and we moved my horse at least every two years. My horse who is a low key kind of guy would take at least that long every time. As long as he was eating, drinking and pooping; it was fine. With my guy, it really helped to develop a new routine and stick with it for at least a month. I would be reluctant to change too much unless it was really needed until after a month. For me that includes turn out paddock/pasture or his stall. Any changes usually made the nervous period last longer. After that first 3 to 4 weeks of getting use to the new place, he really did not care at all what happened.

14 Likes

@sheltona01 Haha thank you, I do need to breathe…it just upsets me to see my mare so anxious when I know that’s not her true personality. That’s another reason why I’m hesitant to move her stall again - yet ANOTHER change. I’m not in a hurry, after all. I could always move her outside in the spring if I still felt like it would suit her better…

What’s the turnout situation if she was in the stall barn? I would be afraid of her getting a little too attached in the pipe barn- and sorry, I have no idea what that is.

It’s only been a week and horse sounds herd bound. Honesty with how worked up she got, I would watch for stomach issues. A calming supplement for a while may help take the edge off for her too. I’m sure she’ll adjust, but I agree, it’s harder since she was at her last home for 13 yrs…please keep us posted.
​​​

1 Like

@TWH Girl The pipe barn is just 12x24 pipe stalls attached to each other in two rows, with one big metal roof in the middle that spreads to both sides, so it’s not really a “barn”. I’m the only one turning her out, this barn doesn’t do group turnouts, but I’m hoping that once she settles in that I’ll be able to turn her out with a few other horses that she’s met and appears to get along with. I go every day, and I turn her out for as long as I can but I put her back when she starts to pace back and forth, because then she just works up a sweat and I’m worried about her drenching herself in sweat in the cold. Honestly, she got attached to her neighbor in 3 days, I was not expecting that! I want her to be able to socialize, but that separation anxiety was not fun to deal with…for myself or any of the boarders in my section. I actually have Gastrix coming in the mail Tuesday for her stomach, and I was thinking about a calming supplement if she’s still nervous in a few weeks.

Given the options available, I’d just do whatever I could to make her as comfortable as possible while she adjusts . In fact, I still go to a fair amount of trouble to decrease stress when I shift horses around, because I’d prefer they don’t get hurt running the fences because took their buddies away and left them all alone (or at least they feel like they’ve been left all alone). It involves some extra effort, but a sick or injured horse involves even more extra effot, so I go to the trouble to at least try to keep everyone calm.

We bought an older horse who had been in the same home for 10 years, and he went through the same kind of adjustment period. and while his anxiety decreased slowly and steadily I’d say that it was over a year before I felt that he was at least getting close to as calm as he’d been in his previous home.

2 Likes

One thing you could try if you haven’t already, is to hand walk her all over the entire place (if possible) – every day for a several days. I think horses need to ‘see’ where they live, see what other horses are there, see all the goings on, be allowed to calmly explore and smell things.

Then I would ride her (if she’s calm) all around the place for several days in company with another rider – even better with different horses and riders each time. Make it a routine then go about it by yourself.

This isn’t a fix for seperation anxiety – it but it should offer her a modicum of relief in general – it gets her physically and mentally involved during adjustment period.

4 Likes

This is going to sound ridiculous. But I think that the adjustment process is easier on both horse and human if you equate it to your preteen child moving middle schools. Horses are about as cliquish as 11-13yo humans. Your mare is the girl who attended the tiny school with one class per grade who now finds herself in the big city school with tons of classmates. Now, add in the fact that your “child” is a 1000 lbs animal whose survival in the wild depends on getting out of Dodge first and asking questions later. And has an impossibly sensitive digestive tract that needs babied. :slight_smile:

1 Like

@kande04 Oh man, a full year?! I hope it doesn’t take my mare that long to adjust. I want her to be as comfortable as possible, and if I asked her where that was it would probably be the outside stall. But, as the human horse mom, I also know that putting her outside could risk getting her attached to another horse, and that would create bad separation anxiety every time that horse left. But I can’t tell her that :cry:

@danacat I’ve tried hand walking her around the property, but the farther we get the more and more she works herself up. So we can only go on short walks. And she’s way too anxious to ride, which is fine with me, I don’t want to overwhelm her. I’m thinking of hand walking her inside the turnout, and doing mini exercises there until I can get her focus in turnout, then try to keep her focus outside the pen.

@Wanderosa Haha, that is a good way to think about it! It must be so overwhelming for her, poor girl :no:

You need to get her brain focused on something other than finding new friends. Is there a trainer at the barn that can work the horse for 30 days or so? the longer she sits and gets to work herself up into a tizzy the harder it is going to be to get back to work.

When you do your groundwork I would suggest using either a stud chain over the nose or a rope halter with knots (personally I hate rope halters). Also put your helmet on - safety first and mind your melon :smiley:

Talk to your vet about possibly giving her a bit of a sedative before doing your groundwork - calm & cool or a cc of Ace. This is not a long term fix but will help her stop being a spaz.

I hate stalls where a horse cannot stick her head out to look around. I say that they are “in jail” and I will not put a horse in a stall like that. If she is social, keep her where she can talk to other horses. She will soon learn that her friend will come back. If possible, take her out for a walk when her friend gets ridden. Anything you can think to do so that she does not whip herself into a frenzy. Losing shoes, losing weight, colicing – all are on the list of bad things that can happen. I know you want to do everything you can, so look at the world through her eyes and try to be empathetic.

She has every right to be in a real tizzy. After 13 years in 1 place, she has been thrown a real curve ball. I would talk to your vet about a mild, but long term (2 weeks), tranquillizer – I am thinking of Reserpine --. Way back when I was getting young horses off the track, if they were not adjusting to private life, my vet would give them a shot. By the time it wore off, they were fine.

Best of luck, and a big hug for both of you.

2 Likes

Two things I would do: 1) Try to take another horse or two with us on our outings around the property. 2) Spend as much time with her as possible on the ground hand grazing, grooming, walking around, round pen work, etc showing her that being with you is pleasant and easy for her. Don’t forget that you’re new to her, too. She doesn’t know what you’re all about yet. I’m a fairly decent rider. Plenty of people around are much better than me. But over the years, I’ve been successful handling and even riding horses that they couldn’t. Only thing I do differently from a lot of folks is taking a little time in the beginning for the horse to gain confidence in me and figure out that I’m not going to ask more of him than he’s capable of. And that I’m fun and easy to be with.

1 Like

Ditto to both.

1 Like

I brought a new horse home on Nov. 22 ( a week before yours), and, like your horse, he has pretty much been in one spot his whole life.

He is juuust starting to really settle. It takes time! So don’t be disheartened yet.

I have been doing groundwork, and that has helped, too.

1 Like

If you’re going out every day, set up a routine for her. If you can try to come to the barn around the same time everyday, and then do exactly the same thing for the next 10 days or so. That can be groom for 15 minutes, then hand walk for 15 minutes, then do something that requires a bit more thought like walking over ground poles for 10 minutes.

In other words give her some structure to her day and do things with her that will help her bond with you.

After the next 10 days, if she seems to be calmer, start varying the routine a bit, a little at a time.

If, on the other hand, she’s so revved up that you’re concerned about your safety (and it always makes sense to wear a helmet when working with a horse), by all means try either giving her a calming supplement or, as another poster suggested, asking your vet about giving her a long-acting sedative.

Good luck.

1 Like

Are the pipe stalls not fully covered? If not, put some dry stall in and put her back outside. Also watch for ulcers. A preventative may help with that. Also keeping hay in front all all times.

1 Like

This is good advice. Keep it relaxed and positive. I find that lunging/round pen/in hand work goes better once i can get the horse keeping it’s focus on me through grooming, etc.

1 Like