That’s a good question. I have L&R buffalo saddles, a couple of cutbacks and an Elan cc, all of them brown. I have also owned Schneider’s Joseph Sterling buffalo saddles. I just used Lexol pH cleaner on them, Lexol NF that’s non-darkening, and some 100% neatsfoot oil sparingly whenever they seemed dry. If they faded badly, I re-dyed them.
L&R’s site recommends (or used to recommend) Oakwood but it would be a job to apply it sparingly enough, rub it out thin, and then take a toothbrush to the saddle to clean out all the pores and grainlines, then rub it down again to remove residue so that dirt won’t stick. :eek: I’ve deep-cleaned a few L&R buffalo saddles from Arizona, and they had dust glued all over them, probably because it stuck to some greasy residue.