PA Governor Raiding Horse Development Fund

Fyi for those folks who are PA breeders or with horses racing in PA
https://patha.org/pennsylvanians-speak-out-against-governor-wolfs-proposed-budget-raid-that-would-devastate-agriculture-industry-and-end-horse-racing-in-the-commonwealth/?fbclid=IwAR338aNAr9vuAMvVksLytjHSZ3J6bwyJsCSxxBKjGBA4EYQuZdFiTsR2Nkg

Individuals throughout Pennsylvania’s agriculture industry reacted with alarm today to Pennsylvania Governor Tom Wolf’s FY 2020-21 budget proposal, which seeks to raid $204 million from the Race Horse Development Trust Fund.

“If approved by the legislature, this raid would result in the end of horseracing in Pennsylvania by eviscerating the primary funding source for the purses and breeder incentives that serve as the lifeblood of the industry,” said Pete Peterson, Executive Director of the Pennsylvania Equine Coalition, an organization representing the six Thoroughbred and Standardbred horsemen and breeder associations in the state. “This scheme would destroy an industry that provides a $1.6 billion economic impact and supports an estimated 16,000 to 23,000 jobs in the agriculture, manufacturing, construction, retail and hospitality industries here in Pennsylvania.”

“Race horse owners and breeders whose operations preserve 100,000 acres of open space in Pennsylvania would be put out of business,” continued Peterson. “Hundreds of farmers who preserve tens of thousands of additional acres growing crops such as straw for bedding and alfalfa and other feed products for horsemen – their largest and highest paying customers – would face financial ruin. This anti-agriculture budget could not come at a worse time for many Pennsylvania farmers who are already struggling financially, as evidenced by a 20 percent increase in farm bankruptcies in 2019.”

Peterson noted that purses and breeder incentives enable owners and breeders to pay a range of individuals in a variety of jobs directly tied to racing, such as jockeys and drivers, trainers, exercise riders, farriers/blacksmiths, veterinarians, exercise riders, grooms, equine dentists, equine therapists, jockey agents, hot walkers, nutritionists, bloodstock agents, and more. In addition, countless small businesses in the manufacturing, retail and construction industries count horsemen and breeders among their major customers for horse trailers and vehicles, feed equipment, riding tack and other supplies, capital investments to replace barns and fencing, and more.

Beyond the economic ramifications, Peterson noted that the Governor’s proposal is fundamentally flawed as it seeks to raid a trust fund the legislature established in 2017 to blocking such transfers. Money in the Race Horse Development Trust Fund (RHDTF) comes from an assessment paid by casinos on their gross terminal revenues from slot machine gaming. The legislature noted in the 2017 Race Horse Industry Reform Act that the money in the “are not funds of the Commonwealth” and that the “Commonwealth shall not be rightfully entitled to any money” in the RHDTF. The goal of the trust fund language was to spur new long-term investment in Pennsylvania’s racing and breeding industry by providing increased economic certainty for investors. The trust fund language has been working as intended, spurring millions of dollars in new investment in the state economy by horse owners, breeders, and other businesses in the past two years. In addition, Peterson noted that because the raid is not legal, it leaves a primary initiative of the Governor without a viable funding source.

In the last 24 hours, a chorus of individuals from throughout the state’s racing, breeding, agriculture, and manufacturing industries have reacted in alarm and expressed their strong opposition to the Governor’s devastating proposal:

Pat Chapman (Annville, PA) (Owner of Smarty Jones) “I cannot believe that our Governor would turn his back on the horse breeding and racing industry. This would be absolutely devastating to so many of us in the horse business. I brought Smarty Jones back to Pennsylvania for breeding because of what we were told four years ago and I thought I could trust what we were told. If the Governor goes through with this proposal the end is near for my breeding and racing days in the state of Pennsylvania and the end for many others. This is a very devastating possibility.”

Saw this… pretty discouraging IMO. :frowning:

Hopefully it does not actually happen and the backlash from the community causes the change. This would not be just a major blow to the racing in PA but the entirety of the agriculture community which is very prevalent in PA.

Politicians amaze me with their inability to understand unintended consequences. They see a fund, and get a serious case of the “grabbies”

What part of “trust fund” do they not understand. This needs to be a case of the governor proposes, the industry disposes.

There’s a way for all of these students to tap into that 200 million dollars…put them in a shedrow at Penn or Parx walking circles, or a hay field in Lancaster Co (“you pick up, you stack”,) I’m sure some of the folks who can’t find help these days will accommodate.

1 Like

well the impact is greater than what is outlined as

The 68 mushroom farms in the state of Pennsylvaniaproduce 63 percent of all U.S. white mushrooms, valued at $554.4 million…where will they get the waste straw bedding they need?

2 Likes

This is a brilliant point. And it goes deeper…

The farms that bed on straw do so, largely, because they can dispose of it easily, and perhaps make a few bucks, as the mushroom industry has their own trucks to go to the equine operations, and pick up the straw and manure. They will NOT pick up shavings. There are some cottage industry companies that have cropped up, who will pick up the shavings and manure- but, you have to PAY them.

If you do not file a manure management plan with your local Conservation District, and they find that you are storing manure on your property, long term, they get very cranky. Of course, you can set up compost pits, etc., but this can be expensive, and take up a good bit of space. Not to mention the fly issues.

So, if, and Clanter points out, the equine operations fold, the trickle down is going to be devastating.

PA has a huge state deficit, mainly made up of unfunded state pension liabilities that the state government can’t seem address.

PA has the worst roads in the US (according to long distance truckers) and the highest gas taxes in the nation, second only to CA.

Guess where the gas taxes that are supposed to be designated for road maintenance is going? To fund the State Police pension. This grab was justified under the logic that this was funding for “public safety”.

I figure this TB Trust Fund grab is another grab for moneys as the state shuffles budgets and robs Peter to pay Paul.

1 Like

Not sure if it is still the case but back when I was on the board of directors at Penn National we funded a big chunk of our healthcare program (pre-casino) with straw/manure pick up from the mushroom farmers. I was not on the board when the slots then casino legislation was finalized so am not sure of the exact details but I do know that funding purses at the track was built right into the law which leads me to believe the law would need to be altered to do this.

FYI…Appropriations Committee hearing on Feb. 26
https://www.lancasterfarming.com/news/farm_policy/ag-budget-keeps-farm-bill-but-makes-some-cuts/article_bedd99ad-7900-5c02-9938-669c1289783b.html?fbclid=IwAR0-CltZ7z-SLCSy2C-BLSVjyVnh-hCqOsiavUUbMxu-OCItYdo9nX3UTWo

It seems the Governor consulted with no one that had expertise.https://www.bloodhorse.com/horse-rac…s-budget-plans

The Ag Secretary seems to think this is OK? He is just no bueno!!

https://www.bloodhorse.com/horse-racing/articles/238764/pa-ag-secretary-supports-raid-on-incentive-fund

It was interesting in the commissioners meeting, because he appeared to back the horsemen, and then his op piece came out right after. There were definitely a lot of fireworks. I will say that this is one of the first times that I’ve seen the entire industry in PA start to band together - this will be a bit of a long, drawn out process, so anyone who opposes it needs to keep up the heat.

And then there was this from today:
http://tharacing.com/pa-lawmakers-question-gutting-of-race-horse-development-trust-fund/?fbclid=IwAR1uQLZHUoLjdU2xT55Ko3YMI11rAGpvKz9Xl-esVyoSq8yNuIDK2RU5Egs

1 Like