As a CWD 2Gs owner, my 2Gs does not make either of my horses’ back sore. My guys move much better in this particular saddle than other brands due to the carbon fiber tree. My horses’ chiropractor even mentioned how much looser my horses’ back muscles were in comparison to when I was using my old saddle. It is just a good fit for us. I know what you’re thinking, and no, I am not sponsored or associated with CWD. I’m just a customer who is offering my experiences with my 2Gs and the knowledge I have gained from a saddle fitter.
Any saddle can make a horse back sore if it doesn’t fit them properly - that is just fact. I don’t think that CWD saddles make horses back sore any more than any other brand on average. Yes, CWD saddles can make some horses’ back sore, but so can a Butet or Antares if it doesn’t fit the horse correctly, which does happen since there is no one-size-fits-all brand. Different saddles work for different horses. To combat this, CWD does offer the pro-panels, but honestly who can expect one saddle to fit the dozens of horses a trainer will ride? That is simply not realistic, and that is probably where some of the claims of CWDs causing sore backs have come from - a not so glorious horse and saddle match-up.
I also don’t think there is any one model of CWD saddles that makes a horse more back sore than the other. Like I stated above - it all depends on the shape of the horse. No two horses are the same, so no one brand or saddle model will fit every horse and rider on the planet. Saddles are tricky business.