I guess I have to be the lone voice of exception here on Rotspon. I was not sold on this guy based on the foals I have seen personally. I read the stats and I see he has produced some super horses (and I personally LOVE the R line, so it’s not that), but I happen to know he can produce widely diverse get.
He has a tendency (again, we are talking tendencies here, not absolutes) to produce get that vary widely in size. 2 o/o 3 of the foals I’ve seen (and I saw 2 of them into adulthood) were quite small: under 16 hh. They were also not particularly attractive or good movers, although they were all sweethearts in terms of temperament.
The mares bred were above average, although not superior. One was a TB mare who had been highly rated by AHS. The other was a Weltmeyer daughter.
So I would only be happy w/Rotspon as the damsire if I personally knew the quality of the mare he produced…either by seeing her myself, or having her excellence proven via a show record or superior production record. Because he certainly did not improve the mares in the cases I saw…and you would have thought that o/o 3 mares at least 1 or 2 of the foals would have been better.
Maybe just my bad luck…
I do know his frozen semen is supposedly outstanding!!