Saddle shopping: best consignment shops in the US?

Im looking for a used saddle and belong to a lot of FB tack groups (200+ groups) and Im watching ebay too. Can you all recommend some consignment shops that list their saddles online?
TIA

Middleburg Tack Exchange and Pelham Saddlery both have big selections and list online, but if you’re trying to fit stuff remotely I think Pelham does a better job.

1 Like

These are the two I have dealt with:

http://www.pelham-saddlery.com/tack/newusedsaddles.html

http://www.saddlesource.com/

https://www.dfwtackexchange.com/

What kind of price range, High end or otherwise? Pelham, Equestrian Imports, M&M tack, Hastilow, Classic Saddlery, Dover to name a few.

We have a great one here in Ocala - Good Apple Equine COnsignment. goodappleequine.com

I really like Fine Used Saddlery …bought and sold from them online. Excellent service

http://thesurreysaddlery.com/index.php/products/saddles/used

They are knowledgeable of all types of saddles, and about fitting.

Interesting to see such a range in prices. $3000+ for a used jumping saddle? Less popular brands (that I used to ride in just fine 20 years ago) under $1000. Wow.

Middleburg Tack Exchange and Galloping Grape are both good.

horsesaddleshop.com

Dallas/Fort Worth Tack Exchange and charlotte’s saddlery in Texas also. Both have great buys for english saddles.
I forget the name of the California saddle shop where I bought a great saddle a few months ago.
Also you can see and buy on eBay.

You will have to search for the actual links but I have been happy with all of these: yoursaddle.com, Calabasas Saddlery (in Ca, look on Facebook), EquusNow, St. Croix Saddlery, Saddler’s Row, Olsen’s Tack, Maryland Saddlery, Maryland Tack Exchange, Farmhouse Saddlery

I’ll put in another plug for Pelham. Hundreds of saddles in the store and on their website, with really good service and a good trial period.

I had a great experience buying from DFWtackexchange.com.

Second this. I’ve had excellent experiences with Patricia at Fine Used Saddles. She’s fast, attentive, super helpful. Goes above and beyond with service. I really, really enjoy working with her and have referred several people to her who have all had similar experiences to mine.

The nice thing with FUS that I’ve found is that even if she doesn’t have what I’m looking for, she can help direct me to what it is I need (even if it can’t be purchased through her). Super, super knowledgable lady.

1 Like

Horsemans Exchange in Littleton massacre.

Beval Saddlery www.allthebestusedsaddles.com
Bucks County Saddlery www.bcsaddlery.com

Craigs List Search www.searchtempest.com or allofcraigs.com or adhuntr.comCWD www.used.cwdsellier.com/saddle/
Dutchess Bridle & Saddle www.dutchessbridleandsaddle.com
eBay www.ebay.com
Equestrian Imports www.Equestrianimports.com

Equine Inspired Touch http://www.equineinspiredtouch.com/j…dles.htmlEquus Now www.equusnow.com
Fine Used Saddles www.FineUsedSaddles.com
Fox Hunting Shop http://www.foxhuntingshop.com/catalog/
Happy Horse Tack http://happyhorsetack.com/consignment/
High End Used Saddles www.HighEndUsedSaddles.com
Hobsons’ Choice Saddlery: http://www.hobsonschoicesaddlery.com/used.html
Lightning G www.usedsaddles.com
Maryland Tack www.mdtackexchange.com
Middleburg Tack Exchange www.middleburgtack.com
Olson’s Tack http://shop.olsonstack.com/category_s/86.htm
Pelham Saddlery www.pelham-saddlery.com
Rick’s Heritage http://www.saddlesource.com/
Saddler’s Row http://www.saddlersrow.com/consignme...ddles-s/77.htm

TackTrader www.tacktrader.comThe Chubby Pony http://www.chubbypony.com/saddles-consignments.shtml
The Galloping Grape www.GallopingGrape.com
The Gray Pony, www.greypony.com
The Happy Saddle http://thehappysaddle.com/sales/index.html
The Snooty Fox www.snootyfox.net
The Tack Box http://www.thetackboxinc.com

Trumbull Mountain http://www.trumbullmtn.com/

Strafford Saddlery http://straffordsaddlery.com/wp/sadd...ntact-saddles/
Warmbloods For Sale - Saddles www.warmbloodforsale.com/saddles

Here’s a list someone on HGS sent me years ago.

Beval Saddlery www.allthebestusedsaddles.com
Bucks County Saddlery www.bcsaddlery.com

Craigs List Search www.searchtempest.com or allofcraigs.com or adhuntr.comCWD www.used.cwdsellier.com/saddle/
Dutchess Bridle & Saddle www.dutchessbridleandsaddle.com
eBay www.ebay.com
Equestrian Imports www.Equestrianimports.com

Equine Inspired Touch http://www.equineinspiredtouch.com/j…dles.htmlEquus Now www.equusnow.com
Fine Used Saddles www.FineUsedSaddles.com
Fox Hunting Shop http://www.foxhuntingshop.com/catalog/
Happy Horse Tack http://happyhorsetack.com/consignment/
High End Used Saddles www.HighEndUsedSaddles.com
Hobsons’ Choice Saddlery: http://www.hobsonschoicesaddlery.com/used.html
Lightning G www.usedsaddles.com
Maryland Tack www.mdtackexchange.com
Middleburg Tack Exchange www.middleburgtack.com
Olson’s Tack http://shop.olsonstack.com/category_s/86.htm
Pelham Saddlery www.pelham-saddlery.com
Rick’s Heritage http://www.saddlesource.com/
Saddler’s Row http://www.saddlersrow.com/consignme...ddles-s/77.htm

TackTrader www.tacktrader.comThe Chubby Pony http://www.chubbypony.com/saddles-consignments.shtml
The Galloping Grape www.GallopingGrape.com
The Gray Pony, www.greypony.com
The Happy Saddle http://thehappysaddle.com/sales/index.html
The Snooty Fox www.snootyfox.net
The Tack Box http://www.thetackboxinc.com

Trumbull Mountain http://www.trumbullmtn.com/

Strafford Saddlery http://straffordsaddlery.com/wp/sadd...ntact-saddles/
Warmbloods For Sale - Saddles www.warmbloodforsale.com/saddles

Middleburg Tack Exchange is my favorite