Shade/rain sails at the barn

I have never used a shade sail but the idea just occurred to me to try it in my dry lot. I have a run in area inside the barn attached to a large dry lot. I was pondering the idea of attaching a large shade sail (waterproof would be even better) just outside the run-in over the hay feeder. Attached to barn and nearby trees.

Has anyone done this? Reasons it’s not a good idea?

In the long run I’m going to have a 14-16’ wide lean-to added onto the barn where the run-in entrance is located that will provide an additional 14-16’ x 40’ covered area. But that is not in our renovation budget for the spring/summer. Looking for a temporary shade fix (and perhaps rain) in the mean time.

I did a shade sail over my 24 x 48 sun pens. I put the shade sale over 24 x 24 section of it. I really like it. Due to the size of our sale we opted for very large posts and set them deep. In the next corral we gave our mini a triangular one. They provide adequate shade, but I do not consider them a rain sale.I have had no problems to date and they have been in for approx 1 year now.

I’ve never seen anything like that in my area, but it’s very windy here at times, and my concern would be that it would either blow off or get ripped up. You may have better luck in your area.

Fine until the next hurricane.

They are good for shade, but not very useful for rain. At a former boarding barn they used some over the cross-tie area. If you are going to the trouble to sink deep posts, you might as well put a more durable cover over the area.

I built a red-neck rain shelter (horse tent) using a heavy duty tarp and extra-tall t-posts. This is for small ponies, and they also have more traditional run-in sheds, but they LOVE the fresh air this gives them. To be honest, I created several iterations before finding the best approach, as my first attempts collected the rain and we had to constantly dump the water to keep it from all coming down.

The successful approach was essentially an old style tent (or simple house roof shape). I centered two tall t-posts — I think ours are 10 foot, with 2 feet in the ground — one at each end. The t-posts are covered with PVC pipe to discourage rubbing. To form a ridge beam, I topped each of these center t-post/PVC pipes with a PVC elbow and ran a PVC pipe between them, forming an inverted “U”. I then placed shorter t-posts (8 foot tall) at what would be the four corners of the structure (again with PVC pipe covers). At each end I ran parachute cord from one short corner t-post up over the tall ridge beam down to the next corner t-post. I then placed a large, heavy duty tarp over it all, using the grommets to tie it to each grommet and to the parachute cords.

You would think (or I did) that pulling the tarp tight would keep rain from collecting, but this is Oregon and rain has no mercy. What worked was to all the tarp to droop slightly along the sides so the rain has a channel to run off.

Once again, this is built for small ponies, so the 8 foot center height works for us. I don’t know if it would hold up as well with full-size horses. You can purchases taller t-posts, and the ceiling, being tarp, is not rigid. I would be extremely cautious of the parachute cord “rafters” with taller horses and probably use something else.

I mentioned this in an earlier post and promised photos, by I’ve found photos do not clearly illustrate how it is built. I’ll draw up a schematic if anyone is interested.

There are so many ways you could improve this — once I hit upon what worked, I stopped, but you could use pipe gates or panels to build three sides or build this in a corner for two solid sides. Shelter Logic has a hoop house style shelter with metal framework covered by tarp that is secured to pipe panels.

Also:
Years ago we acquired a Shetland filly, throwing our existing horses into turmoil. Suddenly our mini stallion no longer got along with his gelding companions, so I quickly fenced off another part of our property which had no shelter. It was summer, and this new corral had a number of tall fir trees, so I tied the four corners of a tarp up into the fir trees. I had to go back and tie up additional grommets along each side. This would NOT have worked in heavy rain, but for a temporary shelter it worked just fine. He likely would have had plenty of shelters from the tree canopy, but this made me feel better.

I’ve also never seen anything like this in my area. I’m in the north east. I was intending to attach the sail to the barn and trees to avoid sinking posts but I do agree if I were to go that route building a more solid structure would make the most sense. We do get some wind but usually not crazy and no hurricanes! :slight_smile:

Ours are in California. We get Santa Ana winds. I did do very deep concrete poles due to the size of ours, but i did not want to add any “formal roof-line” to our farm and this fit the bill nicely. You can buy different thickness covers and we have survived a very wet winter(for us) with no problems. Mine, the rain does not permeate, but the height I set them at does not give a lot of weather protection so to speak. In the summer they are the bomb! Horses love it back there!

We use some permeable shades over a set of pens that get lots of afternoon sun- they work great! Each only about 10 x 12’ but really helps with that late afternoon sun.

Ours are attached to the barn roof edge on the high side and then stretch across to 12 x 12’ pen to steel pipes that rise above the welded wire pen fencing.They have a bit of an overall downward slope from barn to posts.

We get Santa Ana winds (50+ mph) and they have been fine as they are quite permeable. The original nylon tie strings have snapped but we replaced with medium size chain.

I would not do water proof tarps in our setup as they would have to be stretched very tight not to allow water to pool in the center, and it would be very heavy. Because there is a sewn hem on all four sides of the shades, it tends to be tight along the edges and create a big hollow for rain.

Ours have been up 1 and 2 years so far with no tears or damage. We’ll see if they last another summer, but at only about $125 each they have provided good value already. Plus they match the barn room and gutter, so it looks very tidy. Kudos to my boarder who figured this out!

A local barn has them over their outdoor wash racks. Provide nice shade. And regarding hurricanes? They are SUPER easy to take down. Just a few bingeing attachments.