Shelter Logic type building for hay storage

I tried to search this topic but got a lot of random threads and not what I wanted to find.

I am going back to work and looking for options for hay delivery when I am not home. My barn is inside my fencing and I am not interested in hay delivery people responsible for opening/closing gates or moving horses when I’m not home.

I could have delivery into my garage but I hate to put hay in there (BTDT…very messy). But a shelter next to my garage would be easily accessible when I’m not home. It would be out of the prevailing wind, and could also possibly be anchored to my garage if necessary.

Has anyone used one, and if so, what size did you get and how many bales (small squares) could you fit?

I’ve used a couple in the past:

  • The tan colored fabric did next to nothing to stop the sun-bleaching of the outer layer.
  • The silver fabric did a much better job of blocking UV light — however, it didn’t hold up well to the round bale spear on my first attempt to fill it. :eek:
  • I used the tan one for 5 years before I moved - It was starting to tear at the roof corners, but still mostly protected. The silver one was only 3 years old - out side of the bale spear and the tree that fell on it - the fabric was still in great shape.
  • I didn’t have to rake the snow off the round roofed shed - the garage style roof required snow removal (It held 12" of snow on more than one occasion)

I have one of the silver ones and use it for hay storage during the winter after I run through my hay in the loft. I like mine but I also have it sitting under a barn overhang so it doesn’t get heavy direct rain, just the sideways, wind-blown rain. I got the 10x12 (or around that size) and can fit 50+ bales if I stack neatly. There is a gap between the ground and the shelter but you could probably secure it down if necessary.

Thanks for the feedback so far. I hadn’t thought about flat roof versus rounded, but yes I definitely would like to avoid having to remove snow from the roof.

I was thinking something about this size: https://www.northerntool.com/shop/tools/product_200485243_200485243?cm_mmc=Bing-pla&utm_source=Bing_PLA&utm_medium=Tarps,%20Canopies%20%2B%20Shelters%20>%20Instant%20Garages%20%2B%20Instant%20Shelters&utm_campaign=ShelterLogic&utm_content=21059&msclkid=086ef2665a4516acba66ae6f256439b1

It’s a 10x20 so maybe could hold nearly 100 bales. That would be perfect; we could get delivery of 50 or 100 and if there was some that couldn’t fit they could go in the garage and get moved to the barn hayshed first. I just hate the idea of storing hay in the garage for the whole winter.

I use one for my hay storage. I think I have the 20x12x8 or something like that. Stacked tight, I can fit 200 bales or so. DEFINITLEY get the thicker cover. I bought the green one and it tore all down the seams. Mine is in direct sun. They were good about replacing it and I upgraded to the gray cover. I also have one for my tractor, mower, etc storage. Inexpensive and effective.

I just bought a Tuff Shed and I love it. Other sheds were cheaper, but I would have to paint, add shingles, and install. Additionally, the materials were weaker in the cheaper sheds. Tuff Shed also offers a galvanized steel base to discourage termites. I have a 10 x 10 and store 32 bales in there.

I have a silver 10’x12’ Shelter Logic that lasted 5 years through some really bad New England winters. It held around 50 bales. The cover tore from tree branches falling on it, so we moved it, and reinforced it with a $40 tarp zip tied over it, and that worked perfectly. I also have an unassembled one like you’re thinking of buying — a friend gave it to me. They’re a pain to assemble, IMHO, and it really helps to have 2-3 people around. Also, their longevity is enhanced by staking them down well and getting them as level as you can. The round tops do much better in snow and heavy rain — they don’t collect it in pools. I’m impressed by the robustness of the frame — we just re-used it as a temporary goat shelter and it held up quite well.

We’ve had a number over the years. Brown last longest around here. Wind is what always ends up killing them.

Thanks for commenting about assembly. I am thinking of paying someone to do it; I am not good at these things and the shed itself is pretty cheap, all things considering.

I love so much about my barn setup (how it blocks the prevailing wind, etc.) and I understand that the previous owners never used the fenced barnyard as a turnout area, but that meant that the horses couldn’t use the stalls w/ Dutch doors as a run-in. In fact, they had no shelter at all in their pasture which I thought was terrible - no shade, no windblock. So they were either out in the elements 100% or in stalls 100%.

But - not being able to get in/out of the barn by vehicle without being let through a gate is annoying. Especially for hay delivery. Not a lot of options, though. It would require some major rebuilding to change it.

A quick note on the assembly… The 12 x 20 x 10 one that I purchased - there were two small pipes hidden inside the larger pipes in the packaging phase. I built 90% of the frame and came up two pieces short. THEN I read the manual which stated to make sure pieces weren’t inside of each other. I had to dis-assemble most of the frame to find those pieces and the re-assemble!

I have this one https://www.harborfreight.com/10-ft-x-17-ft-portable-garage-62860.html but it is 10x20. Have used it for 3 years now and it is still like new. Even made it through hurricaine Irma’s 50 mile sustained winds and hour and 70-80 Mile an hour gusts without any issues. I can fit 100 bales in it with room for about 20 bags of shavings for good measure. Very impressed with how it has held up.

I have the one that you linked to and a smaller one. I really like them. A bad storm shot a branch through the roof of the larger one, but I got a really good tarp and covered it, and it has been going for over a year like that with no problem. The assembly requires patience and will test relationships. Also, my ground is too rocky to sink the things that secure it into the ground, so I have it roped to trees, cause when I didn’t, it went for a walk in the woods. No prob, I got it back. Also, I recommend getting the vents. Cheapest place if I recall for the vents was online from Home Depot.

1 Like

Have you checked these kinds of sheds you find at Home Depot, Lowes and such:

https://www.acehardware.com/departments/storage-and-organization/outdoor-storage/sheds-and-garages/7367105?x429=true&utm_source=google&utm_medium=cpc&gclid=EAIaIQobChMInNKB6qaa3wIVAQlpCh12sA8lEAQYAyABEgIIrvD_BwE

Those come in different sizes and models.
They can be moved around and resold when you don’t need them any more.
They are a little more sturdy than canvas ones and about similar priced.
I have seen them used for hay around here.

The problem up here is the roof is too flat so they get crushed by snow. I’ve driven by several that collapsed.

The round top canvas storage building shed the snow.

Mine is very similar to this one, but mine is 24L x 12w x 11h with the “barn style” top, don’t think they make that beast any more https://www.northerntool.com/shop/to…1404_200411404

This topic comes up from time to time, so I’m lazily copying and pasting a prior response : ) :

love my Shelter Logic hay building. I put it up almost 10 years ago specifically for hay and its still going strong. Its survived several hurricanes, including Sandy.

I chose a spot that was protected from the wind (though I have had damage due to falling tree limbs over the years). Before installing, I prepped the ground for moisture, I graded the earth (by hand) and installed 6" deep bed of stone (by hand!) and put a heavy duty tarp over the top for a moisture barrier. Stacking hay on single pallets will result in musty bottom bales, but double pallets work to keep even the bottom bales clean a year later.

I can stack 7 bales high down the middle, 6 on the sides. Though experience has taught me to stay 5 high on the sides, 6 in the middle. I can fit 3 pallets across, 6 pallets deep, the barn will hold about 240 40# bales, though I usually stay around 210 so I have some room for other barn items like yard equipment.

I don’t stack to the ceiling as that creates a moisture trap. I also don’t touch the sides of the tent with hay if I can help it as the plastic will sweat in certain circumstances (heavy humidity, hot sunny days, cold nights).

I did have moisture issues the first year, even with the doors left open. Its routinely hot and humid here for about 4 months. Condensation developed in the apex of the roof which rained back down on my hay. I cut vent holes in the doors as high as I could go without risking ripping the door. I reinforced the vents with gorilla tape. Those two little vents have eliminated my moisture issues.

Putting the barn together was a supremely unpleasant experience, as mentioned, the written instructions stink. Nearly cost me my relationship with my boyfriend : ) Customer service was great though, and directed me to updated directions on line that worked much better. We were clever and laid out the roof portions on the ground first and then marked them with a Sharpie.

We were not clever however and didn’t make sure all the bolts were installed with the nut portion facing inwards. The few that are facing outward have caused rubbing issues on the covering. Were I to do it over again, I would duct tape all of the joints and bolts to eliminate rubbing.

I did not use the pathetic grounding augers that came with the kit. I bought 12 2’ long rebar hooks, drove those into the ground and used ratcheting straps to secure the building to the earth, and used 8 2’ augers, 2 in each corner to anchor. After the covering was in place, I back filled the sides where it overlapped the ground with cinderblocks and earth to keep it from flapping.

It took about 4 years for pin holes to start appearing in the roof from sun and tree damage. I put heavy duty tarps over the top as second and third layers before any real damage occurred. Everything is safe and sound a decade later.

If you have a protected area, and the patience and help to really install it correctly and double down on securing it, its a great, fast, inexpensive option for hay storage.

I will add, the nice thing about the dark green color is that it heats up on even the most cold and overcast day. Doesn’t take much sun at all for it to get 10° warmer inside. Even though we can get snow measured in feet, not inches, snow pileup has never been an issue. The barn style shape is sturdy and snow sheds quickly.

1 Like

This seems way too small to make it worthwhile. Ideally I could store at least 50 bales of hay in it, or it’s not worth my hay guy delivering a load.

Not lazy at all - I knew I had seen a post about this so I probably read your response before!

I like that shed but that beast is a bit more than I need. I can store about 240 bales in the hayshed attached to my barn, but it’s the logistics of getting in and out of there that stinks. So if I can store 50…or just a bit more than that - it would be worth getting.

Good to know the instructions are really bad. My handy man has a couple of these sheds (maybe not so heavy-duty) but he has a regular helper guy and together they could probably manage it fairly well…and I would be happy to pay anyone so that I don’t have to do it!

Thanks for the feedback - this is helpful.

They have bigger ones, wood and metal also, some with steeper roof lines.
It was just a suggestion.

Some here rent or buy shipping containers, that come in many sizes.
They even make tack and feed rooms out of them.
Just more to consider.