[QUOTE=TKR;6160476]
I think those who breed for the sport disciplines have to keep in mind that most of those who will eventually ride the produce are female ammies – so good temperment is a must in the stallions AND the mares! As for Thoroughbreds, I always feel compelled to defend them for some reason, but having had and handled a number of Thoroughbred stallions, I have to say they are still my heart. I rode Murray through a dressage test with only a halter and lead line for a mare owner at one time. I also rode him in the mare field regularly around mares and foals. Huntsman was an absolute gentleman – took him to another farm for a friend to try out dressage saddles once. She had never ridden him or any stallion and he was super about the whole process. I have ridden him bareback as well. His sire hunted regularly without incident. I also handled both for live cover by myself and I’m 4’10". I worried more about a mare misbehaving than I did them. So, let’s not group “Thoroughbreds” in a bad light, please! I know from going on 40 years with them they are stellar!
PennyG[/QUOTE]
^^ I agree with Penny, it is the individual,not the breed. And very often how the horse is raised and treated.
We have had numerous discussions of temperament and what is a good temperament- I think it is different things to different people.
I agree with notagain, we should not confuse libido with temperament.
I think what is important is how the horse behaves when he is asked to do something, when the situation is different, how he responds to stress, and what does he do in an upsetting situation.
A stallion can be very quiet at home - but can he show?
Can he handle the other horses, the confusion, the activity, the noise?
Can he trot around a ring in a class or warm up ring full of mares( or Heaven forbid, ponies!!) and just go in the ring and get the job done?
What does he do in an emergency when all hell is breaking loose when you really NEED him to behave and listen?
For me, those are the things that truly demonstrate a ‘good temperament’.
I love the Sir Wanabi video - very sweet, thank you for posting, and I too hope the little girl has a full and complete recovery.:yes:
Love the Ironman story too Nancy, no one could doubt what a great temperament he has. Such a lovely horse! :yes:
And I also agree with Maggie F and DQ - it is also important what kind of temperament the offspring inherit (keeping in mind the mares contribute a lot too.)