Swiss Federation bans draw reins at show jumping competitions

As I understood the ban it is on the WARM UP only. CORRECTION … awards ceremony is included in the ban.

So, if they want to use them in the Victory Gallop they can, I think.

Not sure about that though … anyone translating German? Are they banned from the Victory Lap?

There have been many Victory Gallops where no one used them. Once again, though, it was an older generation and the horses were pretty much responsive to the aids under lots of conditions.

ETA: I Google translated the article … posted further down … AND it states, basically, not even in the awards ceremony.

The longer version post at the Swiss Federation site ( link I posted above) indicates that the public perception of their use is a concern, and that the International Olympic Committee is in its turn worried that the public may get the opinion that elite horse competition ( i.e. Olympic level) and horse welfare are not compatible, and the Olympics could then drop equestrian events altogether.

Google Translate "Under Article 7.9, paragraph 3 is new: “reins are generally prohibited (tests, warm up arena, award ceremony”
from http://www.fnch.ch/de/Pferd/Aktuell/Alle-News-1/NEU-Generelles-Verbot-von-Schlaufzuegeln-zum-Wohl-des-Pferdes-und-fuer-den-Schutz-des-Pferdesports.html

In other words, not just warm up, but also banned in the awards ceremony.

Google Translate says:

NEW: general ban on SCHLAUFZÜGELN TO welfare of the horse and the protection Equestrian

October 19, 2015 08:05

The equestrian sport is the focus of the public and, unfortunately partly not only in positive light. Pictures of horses on the reins call the untrained public that the feeling of coercion and subjugation. The Swiss Equestrian Federation will be used continuously and proactively to the welfare of the horses and the prestige of the equestrian sport. For this he has to rely on the understanding and help of its members, officials and riders.

Previously reins were still restricted allowed in competitions of the discipline of jumping. In the current discipline rules of the Swiss Association for Equestrian Sports SVPS under Article 7.9, paragraph 3: “Reins are forbidden for inspections and on the warm up arena after a jump.” New shall apply from 1 January 2016 a general Schlaufzügelverbot. But why does it need such a ban at all?

The equestrian sport is undoubtedly very much in the focus of a wide public. Often this group consists of laymen, which simply lacks a sound basic knowledge of the essence of horse, his education and entertainment and use. That is why it is no accident that certain images, which are often located in tournaments, spectators can irritate - regardless of whether what they see now, is correct or not.

Asked raison d’être in question
Even the International Olympic Committee comes in every now and then, the discussion on whether you want the Olympic equestrian disciplines, including for ethical reasons, refrain. This is because a majority of sports fans has big question mark whether the equestrian ever added fits into competitive sports, let alone competitive sport for the animal is ethically defensible.

Reins as forced
At the heart of the decision to ban reins to events that are subject to the regulations of the Swiss Association for Equestrian Sports SVPS, are primarily the well-being and the protection of the horse and the entire equestrian sport.

Customized response to legislation in Switzerland
In 2014, the framework due to the adoption of the Swiss Animal Protection Ordinance have changed dramatically: The ingots and Rollkur have since prohibited by law (OPA 21g and 21h).

A viewer without sound background takes a horse to Schlaufzügeln true as horse under duress. It makes for an untrained audience and lay not matter whether the Reins is applied correctly or not, as the knowledge for a correct assessment perhaps does not exist.

Hans Wyss, Director of the Federal Office for Food Safety and Veterinary BLV, underlined in adapting the Animal Welfare Ordinance (“Bulletin” 02, 17. 2. 2014), that the equestrian sport would move on a very fine line. “The responsible use of the horse in sport will be crucial for the future.” It will therefore be essential for the equestrian sport as future positions itself towards the public, spectators, media, sponsors and others.

For the benefit and protection of the horse and a positive image
The management team jumping has decided to include a general Schlaufzügelverbot the Regulations. Under Article 7.9, paragraph 3 is new: “reins are generally prohibited (tests, warm up arena, award ceremony).” The amendment was carefully analyzed by the Commission Regulations of the Association and approved eventually. The reaction takes place on January 1, 2016th

The management team jumping justified the change with the changing legal basis in Switzerland and the increased focus of public attention in connection with the use of animals in the practice of any sport. An image of coercion and pressure sends wrong signals and harms the image of equestrian sport. Does not affect you this impression by any means contrary, a complete ban Equestrian could sooner or later result in a meltdown. Here the entire Swiss equestrian world is responsible and called to work for the welfare of the horses and the protection and prestige of the equestrian sport.

Leadership Team Discipline Jumping

*Asked scene - incorrect application of Schlaufzügels, Horsehead is drawn to the chest.
Asked scene - incorrect application of Schlaufzügels, Horsehead is drawn to the chest.
*Asked scene - correct application of Schlaufzügels, Horsehead should not be behind the vertical.
Asked scene - correct application of Schlaufzügels, Horsehead should not be behind the vertical.
Riders in the duty

Which, of course, calls “draw reins” reins …

So all reins are banned :lol:

Yep, the whole enchilada.

[QUOTE=BaroquePony;8383965]
So all reins are banned :lol:[/QUOTE]
Well, that should certainly make the whole show much more exciting, not just the victory gallop.

Glad it’s banned in warm-up only. You really don’t see them there much anyway. During schooling not most but many riders will use, but lots of times it’s groom’s or people’s children just hacking around at shows in draws just in case. Caving to the ignorance of public perception and internet outrage is silly.

The Swiss have banned clipping whiskers too.

I wouldn’t be so quick to think that the power of the public’s perception isn’t important. Fox Hunting was banned in England. I don’t think anyone saw that coming.

If competitive horse sports don’t pay attention, they may end up being banned also.

[QUOTE=BaroquePony;8383944]
There have been many Victory Gallops where no one used them. Once again, though, it was an older generation and the horses were pretty much responsive to the aids under lots of conditions.[/QUOTE]

Yeah, that grey horse Milton was competing just a few years ago when he was wearing them for presentations. But then I think anyone would agree he was also an unschooled rogue being sat on by an incompetent rider. All the old school guys way back when never would have used them, it’s totally a new thing. :wink:

You need to go back further than Milton.

Military riders. Horses essentially trained to go into battle … and they didn’t use draw reins.

If one looks at the back (I think, I loaned out my copy) of de Nemethy’s classic book on riding- The de Nemethy Method- there is a picture of him sitting on a horse with draw reins. He apparently used them all the time. There is a correct way to use them and an incorrect way.

Also, military riders used huge-ass bits with a ton of leverage. So…

[QUOTE=BaroquePony;8383937]
Draw reins can make a mess of the horse if not used properly and normally that means early on in correcting a horse until they begin to work correct over the back.[/QUOTE]

I just think its somewhat ironic that we tend to bemoan the state of American riding and hold up the Europeans as the epitome of what we should aspire to in sport, and now here we are saying good on the Swiss for telling (mostly) European riders no draw reins, since the Europeans can’t ride.

I may be going out on a limb here, but I would hazard a guess that if Steve Guerdat is using draw reins to warm up a horse, he has a reason for it.

Idk I’m all for banning them. They have no place at a show. I have a horse that gets very strong in crowds, and guess what? I trained her to listen better! And I didn’t need draw reins to do it!

Somehow the eventers and dressage folks have managed to survive without being able to use draw reins at competitions, I’m sure the jumper riders will live through the experience as well.

Ok, there’s a big difference between me riding in draw reins in front of, say 100 to 200 people, thinking that’s a crowd, and John Whitaker riding in front of, say 2000 people at Aachen, which is a crowd. Bigger crowd, unbelievably considerably better rider, probably much stronger horse. No way to compare what “we” do to what “they” do. Just saying.

[QUOTE=Hunterkid;8384341]
Idk I’m all for banning them. They have no place at a show. I have a horse that gets very strong in crowds, and guess what? I trained her to listen better! And I didn’t need draw reins to do it![/QUOTE]

Are you saying that the jumpers, jumping the BIG jumps, winning, out of top barns in the world are not trained (as well as yours presumably), since they are more comfortable with draw reins in a victory gallop?

No snark, just curious when the last time you had a VG, with a huge ribbon, flowing cooler and perhaps a rosette as you galloped around a stadium?