I tried one in my jump lesson yesterday and LOVED how my horse went in it. He was soft, round, and, and listened to my half halts. I liked how I was able to stay super soft while getting him to sit on his butt. Unfortunately I was not able to take it home and try it out some more.
The only reason I didn’t buy one as soon as I got home is I’m not sure it will be enough on XC. Our jump lesson was fairly straightforward; working on bending and staying fluid through the grid, not changing anything last minute, etc. We were in a mid-size arena, so not really enough room for him to open up and get a little “wild” (he’s not wild, the arena sounded like it was going to fall down around us because of the 40mph winds and he didn’t care) but he can get a little amped up.
We are going Novice but I’m wanting to move up early in the year. How he typically goes on XC is “Wheeeeee!!!” with his head in the air, ears up, strong and forward. I’ve never felt out of control but I’ve had to have a couple “if you don’t pay attention I will rearrange your molars” conversations. However, he gets very offended and is opinionated about his bit, which is why I was so thrilled that he liked the Beval. We were going in a full cheek Waterford with a figure 8 and a martingale, but there are times I feel like I have to work REALLY hard to package him up. He gets strung out and on the forehand. A few weeks ago we were popping over a vertical on our own in his waterford/figure 8/martingale setup and he started sucking back behind my leg and getting very pissy whenever I touched his face. I have quiet hands so I wasn’t yanking or constantly pulling. He has made it clear that he no longer will tolerate the figure 8 (tried it on his dressage bridle). I haven’t played with the Waterford with a regular noseband, but I plan on doing canter sets next week and that should tell me a lot. His teeth were just done so that is not an issue.
For reference here are bits we have tried in the past: Slow twist full cheek & 2 ring elevator (too much bit), myler eggbutt (no brakes), loose ring Waterford (preferred the full cheek). His dressage bit is a double jointed Happy Mouth loose ring.
ETA - Is there really a difference between the $155 bit and the $25 bit??