Tennessee Walking Horse Soring Issue *Update post 1*

[QUOTE=WalkInTheWoods;6391195]
http://www.chattanoogan.com/2012/6/22/228852/Roy-Exum-Horse-Trainers-Now-Galloping.aspx

Roy Exum: Horse Trainers Now Galloping
Friday, June 22, 2012 - by Roy Exum

Roy Exum The Tennessee Veterinarians Association, which includes almost 1,000 licensed practitioners in the state, came out with a strongly-worded document Wednesday “expressing support and encouragement of further investigation into the use of action devices and performance packages in the training and showing of Tennessee Walking Horses.”

In doing so the formidable group of active state veterinarians joins the two high-profile national groups that have already castigated the walking horse industry – The American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) and the American Association of Equine Practitioners (AAEP) – and the resulting worldwide outcry clearly has the SHOW Celebration, which is well-known for the fiefdom they have built in tiny Shelbyville, Tn.

, on the run, if not an out-and-out gallop.

The malicious and criminal acts that have permeated the walking horse industry for at least 50 years and included thousands of violations of the 1972 federal Horse Protection Act, have been hooted down by the industry’s insiders but now four horsemen have pleaded guilty and are awaiting criminal charges stemming from sickening abuse. And everybody in the industry admits this is just the tip of the iceberg.

Demands to stem the systematic and widespread practice of soring the hoses, which enhance the “Big Lick” of steps as the horses perform, have been ignored and gone unanswered by the Celebration officials since a scathing undercover video was shown on the ABC news show, Dateline, two months ago, but last week the industry’s chief organizers created a new initiative group to curb consistent abuse of show animals.

The troubling part is that the U.S. Department of Agriculture has viable proof that fewer citations are given by the SHOW group’s inspectors than by USDA veterinarians and the widespread belief is that a tough cop isn’t employed for very long by Celebration partisans where money is king. For example, of the Top Trainers of the year for the past 10 years, they have 55 violations of the Horse Protection Act on file.

In the current Riders Cup competition, the top 20 trainers had 161 violations in just the last two years alone and a quick check of the Tennessee Walking Horse Trainer’s Association itself shows that 14 members of the board have a total of 72 violations of the federal Horse Protection Act. Talk about the fox guarding the hen house!

On Tuesday, the Nashville Tennessean had a pointed story that the Walking Horse industry based in Shelbyville has done little to polish its increasingly tarnished image. The group has just introduced a lightly-regarded swabbing method of detecting caustic agents placed on the horse’s front legs. They say that anyone caught would face a two-week suspension of the license, public disclosure of their names and a “request” that other shows uphold the two-week penalty. The proposed penalty is absolutely ludicrous to those who are eager to end the horrid practice for good.

Instead, new laws are being drafted on the state and federal level that will put far more bite into what will become a felony on July 1, but the Celebration crowd’s message – a two-week suspension – wants no part in rigorous rules that will send unscrupulous trainers and their sadistic sidekicks to jail or harm their businesses, as shallow as some may well be.

Jackie McConnell, who was revered in the Walking horse industry and a member of its Hall of Fame before the undercover video reminded others he has had at least 13 violations in the 40 years he has trained horses, is set to go to trial on state charges of animal cruelty in Fayetteville, Tn., next week but the better hope for vengeance will come on Sept. 12 in Federal Court in Chattanooga. He has already pleaded guilty.

Further, when federal charges were brought in the Eastern District of Tennessee earlier this year, it marked the very first time the Horse Protection Act has been prosecuted and federal attorneys suspect there will be more instances where animal abuse will be dealt with by both state and federal prosecutors.

Winky Groover, a Shelbyville trainer who has freely admitted he sored horses in the past but no longer does so, said recently, “We’ve been concerned with the swabbing results that the government (USDA) has been putting out and the Humane Society’s been putting out. We’re wanting to do something to prove that this horse can show and be sound and is not being abused. We’re trying to save our industry.”

The telling phrase, of course, is “we are trying to save our industry,” which shows the 98 percent of “clean” walking horse people now have the louts on the run. With the Tennessee Veterinary Association now “fully on board” and national groups bearing down on those who would cheat, it seems some widespread changes will soon be implemented on behalf of the gentle and graceful horses that are intertwined throughout American history.

Keith Dane, the head of equine services for the Humane Society, will undergo a “closed hearing” in Lewisburg tomorrow to determine if he should retain his seat on the Tennessee Walking Horse Breeds and Exhibitors Board. There are some who are angry he made the video public and the outcome of the hearing will have widespread repercussions throughout the horse industry.[/QUOTE]

Thanks for posting.

With the Tennessee Veterinarians Association on board maybe they will start cracking down within their own ranks and start putting pressure on their peers who keep clients with sore horses. Lots of people enable these jerks, from their vets to their farriers and on down the line.

I sure hope so. The alphabet soup is thickening.

Roy says that Keith Dane’s closed door meeting with TWHBEA is tomorrow. I wonder if there was a change or if he has his dates mixed up.

Story and graphic pics of a sored up 3 year old taken recently.

http://forthetnwalkinghorse.blogspot.com/2012/06/news-new-sored-horse-photos-pop-up.html

[QUOTE=walknsound;6391205]
Thanks for posting.[/QUOTE]

Roy might want to rein in his rhetoric just a bit.

The desire for “vengeance” (his word) is dangerous. The South has a long history of lynching. Let’s not legalize it.

Second, there were criminal prosecutions under the HPA in the early '70s. They were not successful (evidence issues, IIRC). That’s when the emphasis shifted to a “civil” process where the Rules of Evidence are less rigorous. Indeed, the current process is “administrative” where the rules are even less stringent. The successful prosecution of McConnell is to be lauded, as it’s the first successful prosecution under the HPA.

The actions of the TN Vets. are significant as they are the folks “on the ground” involved in animal care. Just what kind of “rule making” they will engage in remains to be seen. Of the vets. I’ve used regularly over the years, all the private practitioners refused to provide routine care to Big Lick barns. They would provide emergency care in a life-threatening situation. The only facility that I deal with that also provides routine care to the Big Lick crowd is the University of TN Large Animal Clinic. They have also been the recipients of large donations from some Big Lick barns over the years (wall plaques and photos memorialize them). Personally, I wish they wouldn’t, but I don’t rule the world.

G.

[QUOTE=WalkInTheWoods;6391233]
Story and graphic pics of a sored up 3 year old taken recently.

http://forthetnwalkinghorse.blogspot.com/2012/06/news-new-sored-horse-photos-pop-up.html[/QUOTE]

A trainer actually came out of the woodwork, shared photos and information? :eek:

Maybe all this public scrutiny has people that were formerly afraid to speak out feeling a little empowered. Hope this trend catches on.

Applause!!!

[QUOTE=GaitedGloryRider;6391260]
A trainer actually came out of the woodwork, shared photos and information? :eek:

Maybe all this public scrutiny has people that were formerly afraid to speak out feeling a little empowered. Hope this trend catches on.[/QUOTE]

Yes. He could bear the responsibility if ‘caught’ with this mare he did not sore…it would appear landrum did. Prepare for musical chairs as torn up horses get moved around …

My MY this STOP SORING ISSUE is still alive. and from da writing on the wall growing. Tennessee Vets want their name to go down as anti action devices,stacking what will ole Doyle say now.

more flies in the TWH ointment than twhbea will be able to get out or maybe i should say the CELEBRATION,

as far as those torn-up horses the HORSES for HEROS maybe look for a FEW GOOD HORSES,so don’t count them out yet.

[QUOTE=aarpaso;6392076]
My MY this STOP SORING ISSUE is still alive. and from da writing on the wall growing. Tennessee Vets want their name to go down as anti action devices,stacking what will ole Doyle say now.

more flies in the TWH ointment than twhbea will be able to get out or maybe i should say the CELEBRATION,

as far as those torn-up horses the HORSES for HEROS maybe look for a FEW GOOD HORSES,so don’t count them out yet.[/QUOTE]

http://www.tennessean.com/article/20120620/NEWS21/306200130/TN-veterinarians-group-weighs-against-soring

The only facility that I deal with that also provides routine care to the Big Lick crowd is the University of TN Large Animal Clinic. They have also been the recipients of large donations from some Big Lick barns over the years (wall plaques and photos memorialize them). Personally, I wish they wouldn’t, but I don’t rule the world.

Hmmm. Wonder what brought the big turn around all of a sudden??? I just hope the Tenn. Vets are sincere.

Well we may see more of the lesser known trainers having courage to come forward to say what they know now that they can see the Big Name Trainers like McConnell are losing their grip on the TWH show world.

I know the gentleman that I have known for years basicly committed professional suicide when he came forward and told what he knew about how soring was done back in the late 1960s and early 1970s.

The trainers who don’t approve of soring and the artificial BL, but were forced by the code of silence that pervades the professional walking horse trainers’ organization, to keep silent should all get together and issue a joint statement foreswearing soring AND the Big Lick stuff. They would be in good company with all the vet’s aqssociations stepping forward.

There is strength in numbers.

[QUOTE=walknsound;6392107]
http://www.tennessean.com/article/20120620/NEWS21/306200130/TN-veterinarians-group-weighs-against-soring[/QUOTE]

hmmmm The Tennessean is no longer letting me browse for articles. Your link took me to a popup window to pay. Could you copy and paste the article here ? I had tried looking for it earlier and was frozen out.

[QUOTE=GaitedGloryRider;6391260]
A trainer actually came out of the woodwork, shared photos and information? :eek:

Maybe all this public scrutiny has people that were formerly afraid to speak out feeling a little empowered. Hope this trend catches on.[/QUOTE]

Would be nice for him to get the $10K he mentioned.

Thank God for Roy Exum. I really believe his involvement and the involvement of others on this board “with connections” (you know who you are) is what really has kept this pressure on.

I thank you deeply for keeping the rest of us TWH enthusiasts informed.

And keep telling us how to see this effort through to fruition!

[QUOTE=WalkInTheWoods;6392309]
hmmmm The Tennessean is no longer letting me browse for articles. Your link took me to a popup window to pay. Could you copy and paste the article here ? I had tried looking for it earlier and was frozen out.[/QUOTE]

A pop up says you only get 30 days free viewing - then you got to pay.

Here is the article:

[INDENT]TN veterinarians’ group weighs in against soring

The Tennessee Veterinary Medical Association called Wednesday for further investigation into the use of painful action devices and performance packages in the training and showing of Tennessee Walking Horses.

The association “strongly condemns the abuse of animals, and this condemnation certainly includes soring and other abusive practices,” Dennis Geiser, University of Tennessee College of Veterinary Medicine assistant dean and TVMA president, said in a statement.

Joining two national vet groups that made a similar request last week, Geiser said owners and trainers continue to circumvent the federal Horse Protection Act and called for better methods of detecting soring.

The walking horse industry has been under scrutiny since the release of an undercover video in May that showed award-winning trainer Jackie McConnell beating and soring a horse in his Collierville barn.

  • Tony Gonzalez, The Tennessean[/INDENT]

all that is needed NOW is for the Hor Governor of Tennessee to make it a felony to sore the TWH or any Horse. To flat out out LAW the Stacks and packages used. end it here and NOW.
in all gaited BREEDS.

anyone bringing a horse to the CELEBRATION that has been staked or packaged in the last 90 days,will be fined and jailed along with the owner.

So I understand that the government showed up at the Athens show last night. Hardly anyone bothered to get their horses inspected. Thirty some odd classes, 5-6 had entrants. Horses were swabbed, thermography camera (I think), walked through cones and palpated, etc. Thorough and a hassle? Yes. Got nothing to hide? Leave early so you have time to get through it…and go show your horse.

If the TWH folks are( mostly )showing sound horses, then why aren’t they getting them inspected at the shows, demonstrating to the government that they are telling the truth, and showing their horses?

We know Endure fly spray will get you a letter of warning. So use something else. Go. Show your horse. Do what you love to do. If you don’t, you won’t have a horse show to go to. You can’t just stick your head in the sand and wait for the gubmint to go away. They can outlast you, folks.

I think the TWH shows will start to collapse under the weight of the investigations and possible repercussions.

The scam has been that the top winning plantation horses are all sound and healthy and no soring has occured.

Now is the time for the Plantation owners to step up to the plate and put money into the pot for shows. It costs a lot of money to put a show on, and that money has, in the past, come from the BL crowd.

That money is now going to dry up and the other discipline foks are going to need sponsors and cold hard cash.

I have spoken with two show secretaries from the west and they will no longer offer any TWH classes. It is a hot potatoe and other breeds are saying we do not want ANY association with TW exhibitors…we don’t care if they are BL or Plantation.

As I had mentioned before, other breeds do use rollers and chains and bell boots and pads without soring and since this on going inventigation could result in banning those “action devices” for training…other breeds are going to remove themselves from any involvement with the TWH breed.

Other breeds will not passively stand by and let YOUR soring issues impact their training and showing. Therefore they will eliminate your breed.

Sadly, the plantation owners have a history of NOT putting their money where their mouths are…and that was also pointed out by the Walking Way many many years ago…they were saying…Hey…if you want a NON BIG LICK publication…you must support it. And, we all know how successful that was.

Don’t hold your breath to see who gets the Ten Thousand Dollars from HSUS. They have a history of offering and not paying out.

Hard to say. Getting rid of the bad eggs may strengthen the breed and bring folks back into showing. Oregon is a good test case.

http://www.walkinghorseworld.com/PDFC-cotten,%20joe%20Copy_0.png

http://www.walkinghorseworld.com/PDFC-cotten,%20joe%20Copy_1.png