the horse should be paying attention to the rider. By the time a horse reaches ANY “Prix” level in dressage spooking in competition should be a non-issue. Classical training ensured that it was. The whole PURPOSE of having a horse between the hand and the leg is so that it will not shy. If the horses are shying they are not between the hand and the leg.
Also, nobody cares to comment on horses putting in TWO extra beats with their supposedly engaged hind ends?
The arguments being made in favor of the “new” style of riding “deep” are the EXACT same arguments made for riding AQHA pleasure horses with their noses on the ground. This is the new style, they use their backs better, they move “prettier”, Mr latida Big Silver Buckle knows more than you because what have you won? What was being done to pleasure horses ruined the “industry” for many, and it is only beginning to recover. What is being done in dressage is ruining it for many, and it will hit the industry hard soon. Watch.
Any time the modern “ideals” deviate from that which is classically correct you know they are doomed to fall by the wayside. Those that take the time and effort to train a horse correctly are rewarded by having a correctly trained horse.