The Maestro has written another book

Re fact checking. A reputable publishing house might or might not fact check things diligently but they do screen for competency and sanity in their authors. Back about 20 years ago when memoirs from regular folk with traumatic events like dysfunctional families and substance abuse and mental health were really popular there were some memoirs that hot shifted to the fiction section after it turned out the authors embellished things. Also the category of creative nonfiction was invented.

But in those cases, the authors were still telling compelling personal stories about growth with some level of self awareness and awareness of audience. Often the readers got a lot out of the narrative even if the authors family said none of it happened.

The book we are discussing here is just a rage filled delusional drama fest. It has no value or interest to a general audience.

Publishers generally steer clear of looney tunes angry revenge writing because it’s going to reflect badly on them. Also most publishers have assets of some kind and they can be vulnerable to lawsuits for libel. There is nothing in this manuscript to make it worth risking that.

14 Likes

Coincidentally, I just submitted a glowing, 5-star review for the Royal Mills canned iced coffee I ordered. It was described as a 24-pack. I expected a drop shipped flat of cans. Instead, it arrived via Priority Mail from Honolulu, with each can painstakingly wrapped in bubble wrap, sealed in bubble envelopes in groups of 4, and carefully nestled in the shipping box. I got a pop-up message saying my review would be reviewed before posting publicly, please be patient as the process could take several days. I imagine they do cross-reference to make sure the submitter is a verified buyer.

14 Likes

Just make sure to critique only the book without critiquing his reputation. I think that is what is getting past the review filters. I’m surprised that bogus 5 star from Garcia is still up actually as it definitely doesn’t review the book so much as blast his alleged haters.

11 Likes

And only one review is tagged so far as a verified purchase. If people report the bogus review enough, Amazon might query whether or not it really is attached to a purchase.

They should require a purchase before a review is permitted; though the scammers get around that by refunding people for submitting bogus 5* reviews.

3 Likes

Which is also why no one will be able to counter anything in the book. Anyone tries and he’ll just point his finger
and whine.

ā€œFinally some spills the beansā€? Really? I can’t believe that review is still up. English, much?

I am thinking that the Maestro has another nom de plume. A woman! Go figure!

5 Likes

Oh, that. It’s a genetic glitch in the breed known as the Nordic schlongenhuesen.

22 Likes

YES!!! That’s it! The forelimbs have to be swinging to show looseness of the shoulders and the hind legs should also be active and tapping a beat. Head up and looking ahead.

This is teaching my horse to tap dance. He needs more motion in his front legs. I’ll work on that. Clearly, this isn’t an Icejordlinger Ā© . He’s not loose in his shoulders or his hips.
image

Remember, people, this isn’t rearing, it is Airs Above Crossties. If you can’t tell the difference, don’t bother me any more.

28 Likes

Maybe I’ll best sponsor an award at DaD for the best tap-dancing non-Icejordlinger Ā©. Other breeds try, too. Many people can’t afford one or good tap-dancing lessons. We shouldn’t discriminate.

9 Likes

Side bar…

Seeing talk of the Icejordlinger Ā© makes me think of this hunk…

A Fjordalusian. Seriously if I was younger, and we still had land, I would be so tempted to breed a few. This girl is giving her young rider her confidence back, such a nice mare.

35 Likes

My god, what a tank of a horse. Talk about SOGGY!

3 Likes

I just found the perfect name for my next horse (in 20 years or so), ā€œIntent to Flounceā€. Inspired by Nick AND this submission to Ask a Manager. The name was found in the first response and the thread is awesome.

16 Likes

:rofl:

I think the famous thread that was a COTH first (getting a thread locked in Tech Help) could be properly termed and Intent to Flounce!!! :joy: We just didn’t know the technical term at the time.

Between that and learning what a sea lion is and what sea lioning is, that was one educational poster!!!

This would be a great name for a super dramatic but not panicky breed. Maybe a Friesian who could flip her/his long mane during the exit?

12 Likes

Galineers Cob/Vanner - weren’t they magical floofy horses recently too?

4 Likes

I would guess (because I have yet to figure out who the special people here are that control these things so I can simply ask them) they do not do that because a person can have used that product or read that book from another source and their thoughts on XYZ shampoo’s amazing ability to control frizz are just as valid. And heck, clicks are clicks.

On the topic Nick Peronace, the more of his book I read the more I feel sorry for him. Not for the reasons he would like me to feel sorry for him. I feel sorry for him because it is obvious that he either has no idea what the truth actually is, or he has no idea how to make a sentence that expresses the truth and his brain thinks he has said the truth. Which ever it is, it makes me sad for him.

The simplest example from his book (a subject already discussed I realize) is when he talks about his victories while riding Crispy. His words (would give the page number if there were page numbers) are, ā€œCrispy performed well, and her looks really captured the judge’s eye. We won every class we entered, beating the brains out of Barbra on her own turf!ā€
Anyone reading that is going to think he places first in every class. Isn’t that what ā€˜we won every class’ means?
He included a photo with the caption of ā€œCrispy and I on our winning dayā€. The adorable pony has four ribbons hanging from the reins. The ribbons are clearly three different colors, something that is obvious even in the old, grainy, black and white photo. My guess is that there is a first, two seconds and either a third or fourth place. A great show day! A show day to be proud of. But not ā€˜won every class’.
So, somewhere in NP’s world/brain the truth gets confused.

33 Likes

I keep coming back to the idea that he hasn’t written alot of the personal congratulations to himself for people who know anything about horses. Saying he won all his classes, and showing all his ribbons, just might ring fabulous to a non-horse person, who has no idea what the ribbon colors mean. For all they know, first place is a different color depending on the class.

I still think what he is doing is running a big con, mostly convincing his family and family friends and beginner horse people who have met him that he is a winner and fabulous. They have no clue that it is not true because they have no understanding of how horses works, so its just as well for them to believe he’s great. He knows more than they do, so we must all just be nit pickers and jealous. Works for him and them.

We keep thinking we are his intended audience, when we aren’t. He’s correcting his reputation among his family, parents, non-horse people and uneducated horse people. Those are the ones he wants to impress, the ones who have thought he is a failure most of his life and who think he has no accomplishments in life. If he can garner some beginner horse people to worship him, or at least hand over money, he can make a tidy career for himself out of them, but they keep getting educated and realizing he isn’t all that, or he screws them over some how and they fade away, or they end up hearing more about him in the small community he operates in, and some even tap into his online exploits of how he treats people and what his con really is, and the honeymoon is quickly over, when he backs up their suspicions of incompetence by acting out or welching on an agreement.

I think he fails himself pretty much with most of his contacts trying to train, but when ā€œweā€ watch him and discuss it, he finds it easy to blame us for poisoning the well he thinks should water him with so much success. That’s how I think his ā€œtruthsā€ gets confused, or how he tries to spin it to get himself out of the losses he makes for himself.

As for the ribbons, in his brain, no one was there who is being told about the day, so if he says he won every class who is there to say he didn’t? Why he shows third and fourth place ribbons to back up his story is a mind blower, unless we just aren’t his target audience, and those who count will never know he didn’t reall ā€œwinā€. Unless meanies tell them about it. Then its conspiracy.

That’s the only way I can follow the insanity of what he writes. Whether there really is any logic for him to what he’s saying or not, he’s clearly a seriously mentally unstable person. What he thinks all this will get him is anyone’s guess, but there must be someone who will read it that he thinks will believe it, and will give him points for all of this. As I said, I think its parents, and family. Not the horse community.

29 Likes

I think he ruined this idea in the book by admitting that he stalks people and goes to their house in the middle of the night with the intended purpose of scaring them because they deserve it. Who wants to deal with anyone who thinks that is even slightly OK?

24 Likes

Agreed, but he doesn’t seem to scare his people away, edited to say, scare people away when he posts online on his page, with talk like that. He gets likes from his family and a few others. He may deal with a category of people who think like that too.

4 Likes

Actually, I do agree. I think he’s ruined most of this for himself with his book. Basic people aren’t going to go near him after reading this mess. Maybe its meant to make his family feel sorry for him or something. But no one who is looking for a trainer for themselves, their horse, or their child would touch this mess.

8 Likes

"my mother was at Spruce Meadows and pointed to some lady’s top and proclaimed that it was ā€˜a beautiful Tommy Haflinger sweater.ā€™ā€

OMG, my dear dad - after reading an article in Dressage Today - in his attempt to impress me on his new knowledge, asked how my horse’s ā€œhalt-halvesā€ were going. Oh I miss him!!

20 Likes