If you wanna talk smack about Cowboy Dressage or Western Dressage, take it to the Dressage Forum.
This thread is about the potential in those disciplines and how to improve 'em.
My view on the question of gaits-that-won’t-fly in DressageWorld but do get seen in some quarters of WesternWorld or W/C Dressage:
It will get better. Also, I think that the Westerners will be able to see the point of asking for pure gaits (if they don’t already).
And a question:
How do you reining types teach the spin? I know you want a planted inside hind foot. Dressagers doing a pirouette don’t. But there is a progression to teaching both “finished” moves. Being from EnglishWorld, I don’t know how you reiners do it. Watching a Western Dressage video, the test asked for a 1/2 turn on the forehand, followed seamlessly by a full turn on the haunches. It looked messy to me. Is that a legitimate stage in the progress of a reining horse?