ThinLine Hunter/Jumper Girth

[Sweet_Thing_Eventing]

I am looking to purchase a new girth for my colt who is slowly outgrowing my older mare’s girth.

I have and love my Stubben saddle so of course I looked there first and thought I was going to get their fancy stitch girth.

But of course looking around I found the ThinLine girth on Smartpak. I love my ThinLine pad, so the girth seemed like a good idea. But the reviews on Smartpak aren’t very positive and I can’t find much other information on them. The bad reviews are over a year old at this point and their dressage girth has a good rating.

So I guess my question is, does anyone have experience with the ThinLine Hunter/Jumper girth? Pros? Cons?

Or any thoughts on the Stubben girth?

Thank you!

ETA: I just noticed that there is a new review on this girth and it came apart for them as well.

[cleozowner]

Bumping as it sounds like this girth has been redesigned, and the concept of a Thinline liner is intriguing…anyone using one now?

[ellisrun]

I use (4) of the thin line dressage girths - all my saddles are monoflap and I love them. The horses seem comfy, they are easy to clean, and have held up for years (but I do clean my tack ). I jump with them, no problem.

https://www.smartpakequine.com/pt/thinline-dressage-girth-9895