Just wanted to update for anyone who might be searching this thread in the future.
I got things narrowed down to two trailers- ironically, neither were on my original list, but the process of going through all of those brands was extremely useful in helping me decide which features I really wanted.
So the final two were Hawk and Kingston- both were at the upper end of my price range, but more affordable than I thought they would be. I ended up ordering a Hawk today- I really liked both and they both priced out about the same, so in the end it was more of a logistical decision, ie. distance to travel, which dealer was willing to do a trade-in vs having to consign it or try to sell it myself, etc. I was also lucky that the trailer shop was able to get my current rig repaired quickly so I have a way to get to my lessons and shows, so that took the pressure off of having to find something already in stock.
For anyone else considering these two brands, here’s a short summary of the differences (in models that priced within $100 of each other- although the Kingston was in stock and the Hawk I picked all of my options):
Kingston:
6’8" wide
4’6" dressing room, bridle hooks, 2 Saddle Pro racks, blanket bar
Slatted head divider
All aluminum, was going to be slightly lighter (I think around 3000 lbs)
10 yr structural warranty
Hawk:
6’ wide (could have ordered 6’8" WB model, but would have been more $$ & I didn’t need it)
5’ dressing room, bridle hooks, 3 metal saddle racks, blanket bar, built-in tack box
Solid head divider (there was a slatted option, but I usually remove them anyway)
Aluminum w/ steel frame, slightly heavier (something like 3200 or 3700 lbs)
Fiberglass roof
Drop down windows in escape doors
7 yr structural warranty
Both:
11’ horse area (Hawk is usually 10’, but we opted to add the extra foot in length)
Fully padded
Wood floors w/ mats (I had decided I really didn’t want to deal w/ aluminum)
Loading & porch lights
Bulkhead window
Windows in storm doors & escape doors
Roof vents
Bar/cam latches on storm doors (Hawks usually have radial latches, the cam latches were an extra option)
Gravel guard on nose
Running boards
Thanks again all for your help and suggestions! It was great to be able to meet with the dealer today and already have a very good idea of what I wanted.