Vtech updated Riding helmet test

Here is a link to a story on how Vtech is has updated their riding helmet test adding a test that takes speed into account. https://news.vt.edu/articles/2025/04/helmet-lab-releases-updated-equestrian-ratings-system.html

Don’t know if they updated them to be modeled on female musculature yet. I’m glad they are not just relying on the pendulum test now. I know they had an explanation for people who didn’t know physics on why that was the right one. However if you knew physics you could see the reasoning was faulty. I think the added test is a much better model. I feel the mistake they made was looking at only falls in controlled settings and not on the varied surfaces and conditions under which people actually ride. That and maintain that speed was not factor in the severity of the fall shows their video samples were not truly representative of the wide spectrum of falls form horses. Having fallen from a horse at speed I know the forces are more severe resulting in double vision for a period of time vs just a headache for a fall at lower speeds.

This is a big step forward in evaluating riding helmets.

6 Likes

It seems to support use of helmets with Mips technology, which are designed for that rotational motion that happens at speed. The new rankings do have Mips helmets in most of the top spots.

1 Like

I’m glad that they updated the test a bit. I’m incredibly frustrated with MIPS helmets though. Not the technology, but the fit. I’ve tried on helmets from brands such as Arro, Champion, Charles Owen, Tipperary and Uvex. None of them have fit me correctly.

Thinking back, I should’ve written a review on each one since I’ve had my hands on so many. Some of them were really well made and designed, just not for me.

1 Like

I am in the same boat. I’m pretty sure I have ordered and returned 20 at this point. I have two more on the way this week. :frowning:

does anyone know where they are at with the airvest testing?

I agree, and have the same issue (although have not been quite as thorough as you have!!)

While I applaud this helmet testing and it’s obviously fabulous, they don’t seem to be taking head shape into account at all, and that seems important.

2 Likes

I think the VT air vest did not come up with enough funding to run it.

But I believe I read somewhere recently that there was another group that was going to run a test on air vests. Maybe an organization in Europe?