I have been using a combination of puffed pelleted bedding and peat moss. I use one bale of peat moss and 4 bags of puffed pelleted bedding. When first bedding the stall, I use a hose to dampen the peat moss, not to saturation, but enough to keep the dust down. Once the stall has been prepared, I find I only need to add moisture occasionally to keep the peat moss at the optimum moisture level. Often this is just by dumping the left over water from the water buckets into the stall, or mixing the pee spot around to spread the moisture around.
I keep the stall bedded around 6-8" deep with the areas under the hay rack, feed bucket and stall door swept back.
I haven’t found it to be any dustier than using puffed pelleted bedding alone, it’s just that the dust is darker.
I have a bay and grey that are currently bedded on this mixture. I started with the bay because he PEES ALOT!!! He was costing me a fortune to keep in, even for only 4-6 hrs a day. I had tried using a deep litter method with him prior to trying peat moss, but he liked to paw in his stall prior to rolling and the ammonia smell was awful. He does the same thing with the peat moss, but there isn’t any ammonia odor. He is not the neatest horse, but if he’s in for less than 8 hours i can usually find all of his poop piles intact. any longer than 8 hours, it’s like he’s taking out his own form of revenge.
I haven’t found either to look less shiny, or to take more elbow grease to get them shiny. It takes just a few minutes to pick poops and rehydrate the peat if necessary. I sweep whatever the horses track out of the stalls back into the stalls at the end of the day. My manure pile is MUCH more manageable since I have started. I started in May and have added more peat/pellets to the original, but haven’t needed to strip the stall completely. I have had to remove some bedding that became over saturated due to his peeing in the same spot several days in a row and I hadn’t taken the time to mix it around with the drier areas of the stall.
A bag of peat costs me around $12.