fuzzydise - I completely forgot about the County extreme. It’s similar to the Stubben Roxanne S, right? I don’t remember.
I bet that’s a nice saddle. I’m very pleased with both my County’s although I no longer use the cc for hunting - it is still a very well made saddle that has stood up to some harsh use. Same with my dressage saddle - the County WB is the best dressage saddle I have ever sat in.
Although - like others said - it really does depend on rider preference. I just like how they’ve held up over the years. I think the County cc will fit the yearling eventually. It’s too wide for the draft cross now and way too wide for the Appendix with his shark fin withers. - which works out because it was just way too flat and thin for me - since I am no longer flat and thin myself!
But the Stubben fits both of them - which surprised me.
For the OP - let us know what you decide on.