Passier & then some…
Depending on who I was hunting…
I’ve had several Passiers over the years, different models - the one I have now I bought used from a very tall German girl who rode jumpers and had the saddle custom made to fit her. It suits about 110% of the time. I’ve had the best luck w/Passiers and generally prefer them for comfort to both horse and rider.
However, I have also hunted in an old Crosby Olympia II and found it very comfy. I liked it because it wasn’t like sitting in a catcher’s mit…I don’t like feeling trapped. The Passier I have now was built with pretty big rolls and blocks so it’s nice on some critters but I preferred the Crosby on my recently retired mare.
Ditto what someone wrote about saddles being like underwear. I’ve seen people hunt for hours in things I would sit in for 15 minutes…to each his own. I’ve ridden in and still own more saddles than I can shake a stick at (Berney, Stubben, Collegiate, Crosby, …) different saddles for different horses for different jobs. If you are near a good consignment tack shop or have the ability to ride in saddles belonging to friends, you don’t necessarily have to hunt in them to know which ones will make the cut and which won’t. Good luck in your search!
I’ll be in the market for a new saddle in a year or two and will probably go the Passier route again…never had a bad one…