This summer I had to replace my rubber reins as they started to get tacky in places. That was OK, they were old. I put them in a bag with other bits and pieces of bridles, and today took all of my tack (so much it is embarrassing) out for the annual cleaning and conditioning. I have stuff from my hunter jumper days including 20 year old gorgeous hunter bridles and martingales that I will never use again, but I keep in case maybe a granddaughter will… but that is beside the point. The reins had melted into tarry gunk, ruining the random pieces they had been stored with (thank goodness it wasn’t the good stuff!) I had to use nail polish remover to get it off my hands and the floor, and I am just chucking the leather bits.
I cannot imagine what did this to them. They were stored at the barn, hanging except for when the groom would take the bridles to her home to take apart and clean. I will ask her if she ever got nail polish remover on them, but can you think of anything else that would do this?