Sadly, I’m such a saddle nerd that my brain went, “Oh yeah, that one!” :lol: I’ve seen it around. I won’t ruin the party and tell everyone where it is.
I can see why you chose this venue since the saddle is most marketable to foxhunters and that saddlery targets that market (both geographically and because they consign a lot of saddles from that brand.) I think you’re smart to either keep it there or move it to “that other” local consignment shop that has a more varied inventory and moves a lot of tack. It’s a tough call because “that other” local shop certainly gets more traffic from a wider range of buyers, both online and offline. Personally I would move it to “that other” store, but it’s your call to make.
But neither of those consignment vendors’ online consignment inventories index into Google. This is a pretty major limitation since Stackhouse has a buyer’s cult of worship, and unless you just happened to know that Consignment Shop X in your neighborhood tends to carry tons of Stackhouses, the Huge Stackhouse Fan isn’t likely to look there.
So if your consignment agreement allows for you to take it off consignment at any time, I would keep it on consignment and advertise it privately. I have seen other Consignment Shop X saddle owners doing exactly this on sites like virginiaequestrian.com. If your ad states “on consignment at Consignment Shop X at [url here],” you are basically giving free advertising to the shop–and thus they don’t mind.
Some venues I’d post the saddle to for sure:
Virginiaequestrian.com
Foxhunters Online list
Your local Craigslist
Other possible venues if you want to be really comprehensive:
Tacktrader.com
Horsegroomingsupplies.com Equine Classifieds forum
Bits and Barter Board (Google it, it’s free)
Tack Classifieds at The Outside Course discussion board
Horse and Tack Apparel for Sale, a group on Facebook
The best way to preserve your sanity: make sure you turn on “alerts” on all these sites so that when anybody responds to your threads or sends you a private message, you get an email about that. That way you don’t have to constantly recheck all the venues.
For that particular saddle, I might consider taking out an ad in Eventing Nation. I’d say eventers are your next-best audience for the saddle, and they have some crossover with the foxhunting community, so it might get some “buzz” for your saddle among people who wouldn’t normally hang out on local- or foxhunting-related sites.