Why aren't Morgan Horses more popular?

One of the hurdles for Morgans having credibility as a sport horse is within the breed itself. In “Morgandom” the primary focus is a love of the breed. However, in sport the strongest motivation is success and enjoyment of the discipline with a suitable equine partner. Therefore, while breed shows are of obvious value to the breed enthusiasts, they do not carry the same weight as open competition. And I don’t think adding prize money would change that. We have a Morgan gelding that is shown at GP and a stallion who would have been out this year at PSG, and it has been all open competition (save one show years ago) because we feel, as Morgan sport breeders, there is more value in showing open.

That isn’t to say that there are not some exceptional individuals competing at the breed shows (as Mulligan mentioned), but breed shows tend to be more limited in the levels that they offer (e.g. dressage is often lower and occasionally mid-levels only) and obviously don’t have the facilities for eventing and combined driving. So, while there are always exceptions, in general you tend to not see the more accomplished sport competitors at breed shows—they go open. And, unfortunately, there were a significant number of these Morgans who are either are not competed under their registered name and/or their riders do not have a current membership with the AMHA—which means that there are probably more Morgans out competing that the breed is given credit.

There is no one bloodline, program or family of Morgans that consistently produces competitive sport horses, even at the higher levels. There are programs that do a better job of getting their horses into the hands of talented, ambitious riders and therefore have prefixes that are more recognizable, but you can find solid, talented Morgan sport horses in all the families. If you want to get an idea of what Morgans are currently competing in most of the sport disciplines and their breeding, take a look at the databases on the Morgan Sport Resource (http://morgansportresource.com/?page_id=40). It includes the sire, dam and breeder.

4 Likes

Another observation is that people who wax poetic about Morgans that they have ridden, and in regards to the breed in sport, often do so in a past tense. If you are chatting with people at an open show, it is the great Morgan I rode before I got my warmblood. Within the breed, folks immediately talk about Big Bend Doc Davis or Denny Emerson on Victor Dakin (who was a part-bred).

In the first case (open show), why aren’t you looking for another Morgan if you enjoyed the first one so much (which admittedly, is the topic of this thread). In the second case, where have you been for the last twenty or so years?

Nostalgia is great, but we absolutely have some great Morgans currently getting the job done. For example (and there are definitely more):

2019 Kennebec Rugby with Anna Loschiavo. The most recent Morgan to go Preliminary in Eventing. First Prelim, finishing 2[SUP]nd[/SUP]/20 in the Open Division GMHA Trials. https://youtu.be/jG5MHjy_lp4

2017 Blueandwhite Raven and Jen Drescher. US Finals AA Grand Prix Freestyle Reserve Champions (https://www.facebook.com/Morgansport…8347376404703/ ) Sorry, only a Facebook video link.

2017 Avatar’s Jazzman and Lauren Chumley. To quote a COH article: “ ‘Jazz’s’ fall season has included the 1.10-meter jumpers at The Ridge At Riverview (N.J.), three dressage shows where he scored 60 percent or better at Grand Prix, the AEC, where he finished eighth in the training rider division, and ribbons at the GAIG/U.S. Dressage Federation Region 1 Championships (N.C.).” Jazzman is 14.1 h https://youtu.be/ryVd41_H-Qs

  1. Suzy Stafford brought PVF Peace of Mind out of retirement to take the FEI 2* Single Horse division at this year’s Live Oak International. Not that long ago (2014) two Morgans: RG Cowboy’s Black Cadillac and Hotspur’s Red Rowl were part of the U.S. Team for the FEI World Singles Combined Driving Championships in Izsak, Hungary.

The photo is of Expat’s Muzzle Flash. Jumping on the Jr pony Danish team. He is 14.2. Jumping Grand Prix 125 cm. [ATTACH=JSON]{“alt”:“Click image for larger version Name: 83944446_2949991938344942_1452171044558209024_n.jpg Views: 1 Size: 25.5 KB ID: 10627103”,“data-align”:“none”,“data-attachmentid”:“10627103”,“data-size”:“full”}[/ATTACH]

83944446_2949991938344942_1452171044558209024_n.jpg

7 Likes

Ah, one of my (many) hobby horses! Sorry, Im off again.

Legislation about microchipping and passports for each individual animal is gradually, slowly, at a glacial speed changing attitudes in the UK horse world. Ireland is even slower: it is still possible to see Irish horses for sale with “dam unknown” in the text. Yet people happily pay MORE for a horse precisely because it has “pink papers” from Germany. UK passporting was initially in response to EU legislation but got the biggest kick from the 2013 public scandal about horse meat discovered in ready-made meals and burgers i.e. lack of traceability in the food supply chain. Now in about the third iteration (early attempts failed: politics, culture, lack of money), there is more support as people come to see passporting has benefits for health, welfare, traceability and security, competition and performance records and it feeds into better breeding. Slow progress.

OK, back to Morgans.

That picture of Expats Muzzle Flash should be the go-to image of the Breed.

1 Like

IME, a lot of Morgan owners interested in non-breed activities dont have membership with the breed or attempt to earn any of their awards. I am not into a lot of showing, but I did show my old Morgan a few times in recognized dressage shows. While I used his registered name, we were no longer breed members and his accomplishments would not be recorded for the breed anywhere. Sorry, but I just wasnt going to pay for that.

I havent shown current Morgan and dont know that I will show recognized. Again, the costs of getting the horse number USEF stuff, then breed membership etc is offputting for a casual competitor. This horse, and I think many Morgans will actually score better at 2nd-3rd level when the training gets there as he finds collection and lateral work relatively easy.

Interesting to see the breeding of the Morgans at third and above. Some names pop up more than others, but quite a variety of breeding overall. And some horses I knew popping up as grandparents!

1 Like

I couldn’t love this post more!!!

4 Likes

Hey, Clanter, have you seen Prairie Hill’s new foal?

1 Like

Maybe it is because many of the successful horses are geldings and not stallions? It makes it more difficult to breed for sport, if the most successful horses are already gelded.

If you look at the breeding of the Morgans that have shown FEI, there is quite a variety. Difficult to say “Get those lines!” from that data. I did find it interesting that Greentree Bonniejohn shows up a fair amount (my horses great-grandsire!) but not enough to point to that as a breeding guide.

1 Like

In case anyone’s interested, Greentree Ranch Morgans still exists, though it’s in Texas now. I had the pleasure of having Cece Green Yelek share a motel room with me at Nationals in 2018. She’s still breeding great using Morgans with a focus on carriage driving, but they work cows and do a lot of other stuff, too. Cece’s husband breeds some Morgan/QH crosses for his personal use at his job working cattle. She’s on Facebook – posting lots of great videos of her silly young foals at the moment.

2 Likes

There are two articles that go into breeding for FEI Morgans in considerable more depth:

For Sires:
http://morgansportresource.com/wp-co…MHSept2016.pdf

For Dams:
http://morgansportresource.com/wp-co…_PROOF03-1.pdf

1 Like