What a bunch of crap. Yes, it CAN be appropriate and it can work. And I don’t care how many books you’ve read, my personal experience over several cases taught me otherwise.
Cats deal with each other physically and none of my cases had any physical reason for not using the litter boxes OR going outside if they really wanted to.
Othello, the pooping cat, was taught with just two episodes of whacking (as I mentioned)…prior to that I changed litter boxes (all cleaned TWICE a day), tried different litter, put mouse traps behind the entertainment center, changed food…I spent MONTHS trying to figure out what he needed.
Finally, when he crawled back there right in front of me to poop while I was watching tv, I snapped! Maybe he just didn’t “get” that the ONE RULE he needed to follow in my house was not to crap outside the litter box. NOT a tough rule.
So I grabbed him by the scruff, rubbed his nose in the poop, whacked him twice on the butt and tossed him out in a snow drift.
Rinse repeat times one.
Never had another issue. That was 5 yrs ago. Othello sleeps on my bed, sits on my lap when we watch tv…in fact he just now gave me a polite “meow” to ask to go out.
So he has not been damaged by the experience. And it worked.
Suffice to say it also worked on another cat – the dog bed pee-er. But I won’t bore you with that story. But the outcome was the same – after several vet visits, many other attempts at a solution, washing dog beds daily, MONTHS of tolerating this behavior, I finally said “enough”.
And he stopped. It was marking and dominance…and all I did is make it real clear I was more dominant. Now we have that settled and there is peace (and love) in the kingdom.
When push comes to shove the house IS mine, although I’m happy to share it with my (currently) 6 cats & 2 dogs. Nothing wrong with me setting the rules…
And when people suggest death is kinder than discipline, something is really skewed…