[QUOTE=Kyzteke;5717196]
Actually I don’t think this is true. If you breed two purebred animals of the same breed, you are more likely to produce the various weaknesses that are prevelent in that breed. You are correct that a mutt is not technically a hybrid, but it IS outbreeding (big time!), which is well known to create stronger stock.
Recently I was reading an article in “Bark” magazine about a doctor doing a study on aging in dogs. He is using Rotties as his base breed (for consistency). The average life span for a Rottie is only 8.5 yrs!:eek: I’ve had dogs since I was 3 yrs old and of all those dogs, the one with the shortest lifespan lived till she was 9 (a PB Bull Terrier). My other dogs have lived up to 16 yrs. and had very few health issues. They don’t get fancy food or special vitamins – just basic vaccines and LOTS of exercise.
Example: a friend of mine has a PB Rhodesian Ridgeback. I have HooDoo, my mutt. Both are the same age (15), both are about the same size. In HooDoo’s lifetime, I’ve spent about less than $1000 total on health issues – my friend has spent close to $10K (the dog keeps coming up with various cancers).
Another good friend LOVES Schnauzers; she got 2 from a local rescue. Geeze, she was spending $$ on these dogs almost from the get-go. One lived till it was 12 and the other till it was 14…and along the way she spent a FORTUNE on them. One had all kinds of food allergies, chronic issues with kidney stones. Then another went deaf at about 9 yrs. and had several other “issues”.
Again, this is obviously not an official study, but I have loads of friends with dogs and most of them have PBs (I’m the mutt person)…and they are constantly spending $$ on their health care, while I have very few illness issues…at least until we start getting into old age or the occasional accident.
As for the dog/wolf crosses (which, as you stated, ARE true hybrids) I would have a tendency to agree with you. Then I met a friend of mine who has a GS/wolf hybrid (spayed female) and just got another puppy (at 4 wks). I’ve met the first dog and she is lovely – very well behaved and sweet.
My friend says the two important aspects are 1) getting the puppy VERY young, so it can bond with humans and 2) getting one crossed with GS or another good-minded breed – NOT a husky or malamute. Both of the latter dogs tend to be more independent/stubborn types.
However, I still don’t understand why one would want one of these animals – still don’t “get” what they bring to the table (other than the “cool” factor) that a regular dog doesn’t…[/QUOTE]
Good points. Out crossing is a good thing…most of the time. for mini Australian shepherd fans, that’s how they got that breed. Inbreed inbreed inbreed…OUTCROSS on a papillion then inbreed again. (i’m not a fan of making a “mini” of every breed just to satisfy consumers who want a perpetual puppy).
I breed Springer Spaniels for hunting. Every dog i own is health tested and proven in the field before ever being bred. They get OFA and CERF ratings on hips and eyes and PFK, a genetic issue with Springers. I only breed to dogs who are health tested and all reputable breeders do the same. I have 3 generations on my place right now and all have perfect hips and their eyes are free of genetic issues. Bumper will be 14 in August and has cataracts, but those are age related, not genetic. None of the many litters of pups we’ve produced have shown up with any genetic problems.
So…purebreds who are health tested have extremely few issues. Sadly, there are a lot of idiots out there breeding crappy purebreds because “everyone wants a Lab/pug/golden/whatever is the fad of the month”. THOSE dogs will have issues.
Cross two different breeds from healthy stock and your chances of poor health are as minimal as crossing two purebreds of healthy stock. Cross two purebreds from crappy, untested stock who are conformational train wrecks? you’ll get puppies with most or all of those same characteristics.
I love a good mutt. I DETEST intentional breeding of “designer dogs”.
As for wolf/dog crosses: for every really GOOD one there are dozens, hundreds, who shouldn’t exist. I think it’s vastly unfair to the dogs being bred. I knew of a pair near Cascade, MT that were sweet, gentle, very friendly. Never a problem. Then one day they got out of their yard…and killed the neighbor’s two llamas. They were not so “sweet and friendly” when called off their kill. both were euthanized.
Sorry, soap box. I’ll step down! 