cked the notes (I have no memory) and appears that he peed in crate June 8, 18,19 and 29th (night of the storm and I feel that was totally our fault and could have been avoided)
Peed in ex pen or loose in dog room on July 3,4,6…
Since he’s even pooped in the ex-pen. It feels like the ex-pen encourages him to potty, the crate teaches him not to…
So then I’m like well, frequency of peeing in crate is far lower and less often than ex-pen… and since he makes a mess either way might as well crate him and just clean the crate and the dog instead of the entire room and the dog.
This is the WHY I have been flip flopping. And yes I agree flip flopping is a poor training technique. it’s not right, it’s just the best I could do given the situation. I;ve never had this issue before.
Puppy came from same breeder as my last dog (she’s3 now) and breeder has them in ex-pen with papers down and open crate with bedding. She lets them out into a puppy proof yard when she’s home and can supervise throughout the day. She also has a dog door in dog room for her older dogs to use and come and go when she is home. This pup was the first to learn to use the dog door, and it;s been suggested to me to get a dog door.
But puppies having free reign to the back yard when I am not home (not safe for the pup) makes me uncomfortable to use. He’ll occasionally bark at the neighbors, eat sticks (literally eat them) and do some other things I tend to find unappealing. I like him out in the yard but only when I keep an eye on him. Dog room door goes to a concrete patio, so I can;t fence off a section for him to potty… unless I put in an indoor potty the kind with fake grass…on top of the patio slab… He will pee on the patio… just like in the ex-pen. he;ll pee ont he floor not the papers…