Another farm under siege article

I’m putting this here because the article references NY carriage horses several times. If it would be better off in The Menagerie or Around the Farm, Mods please move it.

http://www.bedlamfarm.com/2016/04/18/another-farm-under-siege-animal-rights-and-the-war-against-the-farmers/

The article is about a Long Island family who have a sustainable 15 acres on which they raise their food, including a cow. If you read nothing else, read the quote I put in bold below.

Partial section of the article:

[i]Benner and his family have learned how to do something that is increasingly difficult in modern times – live off of their 15-acre farm in affluent, crowded Long Island since 1977. “We learned, made, and had our own heat. We made our own food. We made our own clothing. We raised a garden,” said Benner, who is 75.

In a rational world, this would be considered heroic, especially in our time, where such independence and self-sufficiency and respect for the environment is almost unheard of. We talk about sustainability all the time, the Benners are living it. We talk about keeping animals among us, and finding value in them. He is doing that.

He ought to get a medal, not death threats online and on the phone.

Benner and his wife Jean have also figured out how to make his family farm an attraction to the urbanized community around him. With a family of six to feed, he kept refining his budget and began raising some of his farm animals as a source of food. His farm offers strawberry picking, birthday parties and class trips for schoolchildren.

Opening his farm up has threatened it in an ugly way. On April 2, Jean Benner was taking a birthday party group on an educational tour of the farm, answering questions about what it is like to live on a farm. They met Minnie the cow.

A housewife and mother named Kimberly Sherriton asked about the fate of Minnie and was told she would be used to feed the Benner family.

Sherriton was upset, she said she would find a sanctuary where Minnie could live out her life.

Jean Benner tried to explain the difference between an animal on a farm and a pet, explaining that the farm was a homestead where animals have been raised for meat since 1751. “We grow and produce food for our family on our property,” said Benner. That is how the family is able to keep their farm going.

When she learned that the two-year-old cow will be going to slaughter to help feed the Benner family, Sherriton organized a series of protests outside of the Benner farm to demand that the cow be spared. She started a petition on change.org and collection more than 2,000 signatures and opened a Facebook Page to save the cow that has more than 700 supporters.

Benner said he is nearly overwhelmed with angry, sometimes obscene, phone calls, Facebook posts, bad reviews on his web page and threats on his family.

“There have been literally thousands of people who have supported us,” said Benner, “and a majority of them live right here in the community,” he said. “The people who are trying to impose their values on us do not live here. We’re talking about a national group of people who have a direction – they’re trying to tell us how to live.”

Sherriton’s comments to the media shocked me, even by the very low standards of animal rights rhetoric and lobbying.

“He doesn’t need this cow to survive and feed his family,” Sherriton told a reporter for FiOS1 news. “He puts a sob story on there. Please, tell him to go to Whole Foods and go get some antibiotic -free beef there.”

In a scenario now familiar to many farmers, Benner and his family are now being constantly harassed.[/i]

:mad::mad::mad::mad:

I wish people weren’t so ignorant about where their food comes from.

Well yes, clearly that beef in the store is not from any bovine anyone has ever met so it is OK to eat.

“He doesn’t need this cow to survive and feed his family,” Sherriton told a reporter for FiOS1 news. “He puts a sob story on there. Please, tell him to go to Whole Foods and go get some antibiotic -free beef there.”

And where exactly does she think that beef comes from? :confused: I guess buying beef from whole foods doesn’t involve killing cows, they must grow the steaks in a greenhouse right next to the carrots and potatoes??? :no:

Nothing like a mass produced “lovingly killed and shrink wrapped” slice of heaven from Whole Foods

Self Righteousness at its finest

#educationfail

Very silly, but that’s what happens when you let the public in. The owner of this nice farm should hand out leaflets about the lives of animals on “factory farms”, where most of our meat and poultry come from, redirect people to go there and protest . Or protest in front of a supermarket would be better , or in front of a KFC fast food place.

This woman must be incredibly ignorant. It frightens me that there are hordes of people just like her who are ready to protest anything they find outside their personal values and they are willing to destroy lives in the process. Protest has been made so much stronger by social media. These days it’s a blood sport.

I bet she does know where beef comes from. I don’t think she’s that stupid, she just wants her world view to be shared by all. And Raincityrider is right, she’s willing to destroy lives to get her point of view across. Of course the Benners will end up closing their farm to the public now, and that’s a shame. There are a lot of kids who would benefit from tours and meeting animals, and parents as well.

As a farmer, the difficult part for us is being transparent about what we do with our animals and educating the public, yet not opening ourselves to situations like what has happened on Long Island. Most of the agriculture industry feels very strongly that we need as much transparency as possible and that education is paramount if we are to continue to maintain healthy relationships with our consumers, but this story is the stuff our nightmares are made of.

I did not come from a farming family but was raised in the suburbs in the early '70s. I have very distinct memories of going to a local dairy and seeing them milk the cows, feed the cows, etc. as they were purposely set up to show the public how they did things. I also remember attending “Agriculture Day” at a local college that I later attended, where they had cannulated cows and hearing students explain the process and why the cows were cannulated. Many people do not get the opportunity to see these things, and understand the how and why behind them.

The good news is agritourism is alive and well in the US, and places like this below exist to help educate the American people where their food actually comes from, as many are so far removed from it today.

http://fofarms.com/springbreak

It is on my bucket list of places to visit, and am actually jealous because my husband is getting to go for work next week.

I literally can’t stop laughing. Because the only major difference between “Minnie” and the cattle who are in the counter at Whole Foods is Minnie has a name, not an ear tag number.

I think they should offer her some of the meat being its neighborly. I would like this lady to go tour a slaughter house see how they have to hit cows in the head 2-3 times with the bolt gun sometimes. And then slit the throat or watch when they got shocked with electric. A farm cow gets one shot to the head most of the time lot better way to go IMO. People are so dumb sometimes…

I found this so hard to believe I went looking…it’s true. An article from http://nysapfadvocacy.org/app/document/13008696;jsessionid=nxeDf9A2PQgyfQE3aqS+zQ73.undefined

Sherriton, 47, started the campaign to save Minnie from slaughter last week after attending a birthday party at the 15-acre farm, where visitors can pick organically grown strawberries, learn to milk a goat and take part in gardening workshops.

“I broke down crying when I heard they were going to kill that cow,” Sherriton said, while holding a bright orange “Save Minnie” poster. “She’s so affectionate and playful. She licks like a puppy dog, and she’s treated like a pet.”

Jodie Flynn, of East Yaphank, criticized Benner’s Farm ads, which say visitors can “pet and cuddle” animals, leading her to believe the farm is a petting zoo.

“How can you let children pet and cuddle these animals and then turn around and have them slaughtered? It’s heartless,” said Flynn, 39.

Bob Benner, 73, said he’s straightforward with visitors that his farm “is not a petting zoo.”

and more…

One protester, Julianna Cinone, commented “Minnie is a thinking, feeling animal like cats and dogs and is beloved by everyone- but not like the Benner’s owners as there is no humane way to kill an animal.” Furthermore, dog and cat rescuer Ginger Livingston stated that although they are not optimistic about Minnie’s prospects, the public should be aware and stand up to a tradition that isn’t right [what tradition? eating animals? petting animals?]. She also commented that she understands a farmer’s rights and freelance, but she doesn’t think it is appropriate to raise an animal for two years as a community pet only to slaughter it later.

Sherriton commented that they are not trying to hurt the Benner’s business, but only trying to stand up to something she feels is clearly wrong and makes no sense. She also pointed out that Benner’s posted a picture last week in celebration of Minnie’s second birthday, which she felt was extremely hypocritical.

Furthermore, Minnie is a freemartin cow, meaning she has both male and female characteristics; it is one of the most severe forms of sexual abnormality among cattle. Community members question if the actions on part of the farm was a form of discrimination. However, utilizing their cows for meat has been a tradition at Benner’s Farm prior to Minnie.

Okay that last thing is just bizarre!!

I can see how the community might react when the cow was treated more like a pet, or a horse, than a meat animal being raised for slaughter. Most city people aren’t prepared to kill an animal they made an attachment to. There are two sides to the story, as I suspected, but I am sure the farmer is bewildered that the city folks don’t understand how agriculture works.

A form of discrimination, for goodness sake, because the cow was transgendered, I guess? Poor farmer.

So basically if you treat the cow like a farm animal you are cruel and that type of farming should not be allowed. But…if you treat the cow nicely you are not allowed to kill it because now it is a pet.

Wow. I guess that leaves no options.

The discrimination thing just makes me laugh way too hard. Talk about picking a public hot topic and twisting it to meet the needs of your cause.

Freemartins occur as a defect in the animal, when it is a twin. They are born sterile. Just means they become meat that much sooner.

No discrimination, just a fact of animal production.

Irate at the ignorance!!!

Also If I see one more post about a rescue saving a cow with no frontvlegs or a goat that can’t walk or a three legged horse I will scream!

These vets facilitating this need their licenses revoked.

Such idiots

Oh and I bet the save minnie brigade pops into mickey d’s for a hambuger.

Soooo stupid!

While I think the protesters are silly I can also understand why they are upset. Giving the cow a name and portraying it in the way they did kind of asks for this response. It’s one thing for people to tour a farm and see how animals are used in our society as food, but naming it and having it appear to be a lovable pet??

Everyone I know with livestock names them. Well, maybe not all of the broilers, but the bovines and ovines, etc get names.
All the dairies around me have named cows. Tagged ears, too. The tags/numbers are a bigger help when someone needs to move a bunch to the big field until the end of their pregnancies…easier to go find visible number than Millie, Veronica, Milkshake, etc. :wink:
Every year we had George and Joe out in pens…and every fall/winter we had George and Joe in the freezer.
Amazingly nobody held protests.
Probably because nobody was such an egomaniac as to believe that someone else’s animals were NOT “theirs” because it was named and they met it and they think that someone made that animal a Community Pet.
BTW, half of the moronic protesters at the last protest were wearing leather coats…it was kinda funny. Especially the person wearing a cow suit with a leather jacket over it.

What I don’t understand is that you cannot put a restraining order on protestors or a cease and desist on them spreading vicious lies and condoning threats of violence on social media. When is freedom of speech turn into harassment?

I name everything I’m going to eat.

Tastes better that way.

Naming is not unusual at all.